Initially, the massive nursing credentials scam—disclosed by federal prosecutors early last year—involved three once legitimate, now-shuttered, Florida nurses’ training institutions. Some two dozen criminal operators and recruiters have been arrested and indicted; an as-of-yet unknown number face decades behind bars.
According to multiple indictments, most for wire fraud, the scammers sold 7,600 bogus graduation certificates and transcripts to would-be students, both American and foreign-born. The enterprise raked in around $114 million, charging on average $15,000 for each diploma and transcript set. The illicit operation was headquartered in South Florida but spread to a half-dozen other states—mainly Delaware, New York, New Jersey, and Texas, as well as offshore to the Caribbean basin.
Named “Operation Nightingale,” the 2016–2021 investigation is a collaboration of the US Justice of Department (DoJ), FBI, and Health and Human Services Office of Inspector General (HHS/OIG). While media attention began fulsomely, coverage soon waned. This left many unanswered questions and a public curious about outcomes.
As an HHS source explained to OR Manager in late June, “Investigations are ongoing.” Another government official predicted “waves [of more] prosecutions” are likely down the road, without suggesting a number or timeline. For now, federal officials are sharing little by way of follow-up information. Details are classified, for reasons of internal security, “sources and methods,” and privacy.
Still, in April it was reported that the criminally bent schools now totaled 10 (up from the original three), and that the government was actively tracing some 2,000 improperly licensed nurse suspects. In New York alone, 900 or so nurses have been asked by state officials to prove their credentials, according to an NPR “All Things Considered” report in late Spring. The names of most are known, and government investigators are honing in on their whereabouts, OR Manager has learned.
Fernando Porras, Florida-based HHS/OIG Special Agent in Charge (SAIC), told OR Manager in early July that, “Subjects in this investigation were charged with either conspiring to commit wire fraud, mail fraud, or wire fraud.” He added,“So far, 28 subjects have been charged in the Southern District of Florida for their alleged participation in a…scheme that created an illegal licensing and employment shortcut for aspiring nurses. This remains an active investigation.”
Of the three subjects sentenced in this case, “each received 27 months of federal incarceration.” Seven subjects have pled guilty, while five await sentencing. Such crimes, Porras noted in an email exchange, may result in 20 years of imprisonment.
To a large degree, the nation’s 50 nursing boards—which the DoJ sometimes investigates—are meant to follow up on data provided to them. On the current tracing of fake credential holders, Porras remarked, “As soon as we identified these individuals and corroborated this information, we immediately provided each individual state board of nursing the necessary information to locate those individuals who fraudulently obtained nursing certifications.”
The work is painstaking. For example, “Our team of investigators carefully reviewed over 10,000 student records—page by page—to find the individuals with fraudulent credentials and [informed state] nursing boards about individuals with fake credentials in their jurisdiction.” These boards “have in turn taken administrative action against individuals in their jurisdiction,” he continued. “Because of this fraud scheme’s threat of possible patient harm and undermining the integrity of the nursing profession, this investigation is a top priority for our agency.”
As to suspects with bogus credentials now working in healthcare at a professional level, Porras was again emphatic on the responsibility of nursing boards to respond forcefully and “take action.” During the multipronged investigation, he said, “we found that hundreds of the individuals who received the fraudulent degrees were already employed in the…industry—we informed nursing boards about these individuals.”
“Thankfully,” he concluded, “to date, we have seen no evidence of patient harm by individuals who purchased fraudulent credentials.” He declined to state how many of the 7,600 false diploma holders have been traced, their licenses annulled, or otherwise sanctioned. Nor did OR Manager learn which boards had “taken action,” or of what those actions consisted.
As probers continue unearthing and assembling evidence, there are signs of disgruntlement in the nation’s nursing community. Though there is to date no polling data reflecting the views of nurses on the unfolding scandal, social media and forums show some near-palpable outrage.
Explanations are several. Most obvious is that thousands of nurse trainees, by all accounts, have engaged in the scam’s innate betrayal of trust and outright dishonesty. Directly related is that culpable fraudsters’ actions dishonor one of the world’s most trustworthy, esteemed, and respected professions.
When the story first broke, the American Nursing Association (ANA) issued a strongly worded statement reflecting shock—and much more. It is attributed to ANA President Jennifer Mensik Kennedy, PhD, MBA, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN:
“This disturbing news of a coordinated conspiracy allowing individuals to circumvent necessary coursework and clinical experiences, as well as critical steps in the nursing licensure and credentialing process, is extremely unsettling. Nursing is without a doubt a highly specialized and ethical profession requiring rigorous and life-long education and training to acquire unmatched clinical expertise. […] There are no shortcuts in nursing—our patients and clients depend on us. […] The accusation that personnel at once accredited nursing schools allegedly participated in this scheme is simply deplorable. This undermines everything the nursing profession represents and stands for and is in direct opposition to the Code of Ethics for Nurses.”
The widespread scam was and remains multidimensional. Initial bombshell headlines notwithstanding, the issues are not cut-and-dry. One investigative challenge in terms of witness availability is the traveler nurse phenomenon of recent years. Legitimate nurses harboring suspicions and seeking to speak with agents likely face a time, bureaucratic, and logistics crunch. Then, there is the fear factor. Waiting to schedule a meeting, some may be tempted to seek something incriminating to share—only to discover the suspect has traveled to another health facility.
Coordination in such circumstances is hard enough, let alone the risks of “outing” a colleague or simply being proved wrong. Published accounts say some proportion of graduates of the disgraced schools are pushing back against accusations. It is claimed that unlike others who merit prosecution, they believed the nursing schools were legitimate and were duped.
According to reporting by The Philadelphia Inquirer in late June, around 100 nurses have “lawyered-up” and are fighting to keep their licenses. Some assert they have received online learning, including hands-on clinical training. But irrespective of some training or none, charging documents indicate that bogus diplomas and transcripts enabled a great many ethically challenged nurse-wannabes in various states to sit for the national nursing board exams.
In approximately 25% of cases, applicants passed the boards, obtained state medical licenses, and accepted nursing jobs in Florida or elsewhere. The exact number of putative graduates of the 10 schools and now employed in healthcare is unknown. Among correctives for honest aspiring nurses to weed out fake schools are guidelines published by the US Department of Education. The department also suggests they contact the Better Business Bureau or the state attorney general’s office; another recommendation is for nurse-aspirants to study its list of nationally recognized school accrediting agencies.
As for helping prevent would-be lawbreakers from gaining healthcare toeholds, document assurance among other antidotes is being proposed. For, at some level, the credentialing process in Florida and elsewhere clearly failed—the fault of exploitable loopholes or security flaws, and lack of vetting due diligence. Consequently, it is likely that many diplomas, transcripts, school transfer papers, and other ephemera were only cursorily examined, then accepted as genuine.
Some nursing board specialists, among them officials in Washington state, urge test givers and monitors to bone up on known credentials. Paula Meyer, head of the state’s Nursing Care Quality Commission, disclosed on NPR’s “All Things Considered” in late April that, “Some [documents] didn’t have the seal. Some of them didn’t have the address of the school. Some…had different fonts.”
The verification method may not only help discourage scammers, it is also likely to bolster honest students’ claims in the event of future misfortunes. The swindle may best be encapsulated in the words of a senior FBI agent closely involved in the complex probe.
Chad Yarbrough, acting special agent in charge with the FBI in Miami, stated in January, “Many scammers see [such hoaxes] a way to earn easy, though illegal, money. What is disturbing…is that there are over 7,600 people around the country with fraudulent nursing credentials who are potentially in critical healthcare roles treating patients.”
Yarborough hailed the hard work put into the case so far, noting that otherwise, “the extent of this fraud may not have been discovered.” Meanwhile, the ongoing legal and criminal processes will continue playing out. At a time when many industries, including healthcare, are bombarded by imposters with fake or “embellished” credentials, vigilance and governance have never been more important.
—David C. Walsh is proprietor of pixwords.com and a onetime US Air Force medic.
Diploma Mills and Accreditation: Diploma Mills. US Department of Education. December 2009.
Statement on Fraudulent Nursing Diploma Scheme. American Nurses Association. January 26, 2023.