OR leaders face an increasing number of stresses, ranging from pressure to trim already lean budgets to searching for staff who could potentially replace them as they contemplate retirement. At the same time, OR leaders’ salaries remain flat, according to results from the 2016 annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. Respondents earned an average salary of $114,648, on par with $115,986 from last year and down from $123,000 in 2014. Yet more than half of leaders (51%) reported increased volume in their facilities.
The flat salaries may reflect an economy where the overall growth is not strong. The Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U) increased by only 1.0% (compared to 0.1% last year) for the year ending in June 2016, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
On the positive side, nearly two-thirds (65%) of respondents plan to stay with their current employer until they retire. However, 24% anticipate retiring by 2020, which isn’t too far in the future.
Satisfaction of OR leaders is mixed. In all, 78% report favorable satisfaction with both their current position and patient satisfaction with OR services, but, not surprisingly, just over half (54%) view their total compensation as favorable.
When it comes to engagement, however, OR leaders score high. On a scale of 1 to 10, with 1 being “not engaged at all” and 10 being “totally engaged,” the average was 8.98, comparable to 9.06 from 2015. Half of respondents say they are totally engaged.
Other findings from the survey include:
• As with salary, average total compensation was flat at $135,506, compared to $136,069 in 2015.
• The average raise was 3.38%, compared to 3.4% in 2015.
• The gap between teaching and community hospital earnings remains.

CompensationHalf of survey respondents earned an annual salary less than $110,000; the top 10% earned more than $165,000.
OR leaders in the West earned the highest average annual salary ($137,000), followed by the Northeast ($113,000), South ($110,000), and Midwest ($103,000), the same pattern as last year.
The salary gap between OR leaders in teaching and community hospitals was $19,504, in favor of those who work in teaching hospitals, comparable to the $18,712 reported last year. The difference in total compensation between teaching and community hospitals was $22,099, compared with $30,350 in 2015.
Consistent with past surveys, OR leaders with the title of administrator/administrative director earn the highest average salary ($147,769) and average total compensation ($171,975), followed by directors (average salary, $124,196; average total compensation, $145,556) and nurse managers (average salary, $101,340; average total compensation, $119,748).
Nearly all respondents report their benefits include paid time off (95%) and health insurance (94%). Several other benefits remain stable compared to last year, including dental insurance (86%), retirement plan (85%), disability insurance (77%), tuition reimbursement (70%), and educational benefits (41%).
Compared with last year, a higher percentage of respondents reported receiving these benefits: life insurance (87%, up from 78%), eye care (75%, up from 68%), and health insurance for dependents (64%, up from 55%). These differences may not indicate a trend.
Similar to 2015, only 29% of respondents report pensions or bonuses/profit sharing as benefits, and only 15% are eligible for incentive pay.
As past surveys have shown, teaching hospitals offer more benefits than their community counterparts. As expected, educational benefits and tuition reimbursement are higher in teaching hospitals. Other benefits found much more commonly in teaching hospitals are pensions (46% vs 23%) and bonus/profit sharing (41% vs 24%).
The percentage of the last raise was similar for OR leaders in teaching and community hospitals (3.56% vs 3.33%). As in 2015, only 9% have not received a raise in the past year.

OR leaders continue to invest significant time in their jobs, reporting an average work week of 51 hours, the same as reported in 2015. Only 14% work 40 hours or less.
Most respondents clock those hours at a community hospital (66%) as opposed to a teaching hospital (21%). Those who responded to the survey were split between nurse manager (41%) and director (39%) titles, with 9% reporting administrator or administrative director as their titles.
The market penetration of the OR business manager role remains relatively low, with 33% of respondents reporting the position, compared to 29% in 2015, according to the 2016 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. Business managers continue to be far more likely to work in teaching than community hospitals. In all, 70% of OR leaders in teaching hospitals have a business manager, compared to only 24% in community hospitals.
Qualifications
• Only 31% of OR leaders require the business manager to have a clinical background.
• Most hospitals require the business manager to have a master’s degree.
Salary
• More than one-fourth (26%) of business managers earn more than $100,000, and only 3% earn less than $60,000.
Scope of responsibility
• Nearly a third (31%) of business managers have five to nine direct reports, 20% have three to four, 19% have none, and 15% have one to two.
• An additional 15% have 10 or more direct reports, with a range of 12 to 30 and a mean of 16.22.
• The most frequently reported area of responsibility was financial analysis/reporting.
OR leaders are responsible for an average of 5.71 departments, similar to the 6 reported in 2015; 90% have fewer than 11 departments reporting to them.
In addition to the OR, the most common areas supervised are the postanesthesia care unit (64%), central sterile processing (59%), outpatient/same-day surgery (53%), preoperative unit (53%), and gastrointestinal/endoscopy (53%).
Other departments that received multiple mentions include OR scheduling (5), interventional radiology (2), and outpatient infusion center (2).
This year, respondents reported that they oversee an average of 95.4 employees, similar to the 94 reported last year. The total number breaks down into an average of 79.05 clinical employees (half of respondents reported fewer than 55 employees, and 10% reported 198 or more), and an average of 16.37 nonclinical employees (half having 6 or fewer reporting to them, and 10% having 40 or more). Only 33% report having a business manager (see sidebar, p 10).
Most respondents manage an annual operating budget of less than $2.5 million (24%). In all, 22% manage a capital budget of $2.0 to $4.9 million, with 23% reporting less than $250,000. Most (29%) manage a personnel budget of less than $1.0 million, with 26% reporting $2.0 to $4.9 million and 20% reporting $1.0 to $1.9 million.
For the second year, we asked OR leaders about their level of engagement, which represents a person’s willingness to work hard, contribute fully, and be a valued contributor. Engagement was slightly higher among those who work in community hospitals than in teaching hospitals (9.02% vs 8.85%).
The 78% favorable satisfaction level that OR leaders reported for their current position is comparable to the 76% reported overall for those working in health services and healthcare. Interestingly, similar results are reported for those in other professions such as financial services (76%) and insurance (75%).
Patient satisfaction with OR services also drew a high favorable satisfaction level at 78%, comparable to last year’s 80%.
Respondents reported lower favorable satisfaction rates for benefits provided (65%), support provided by the boss (63%), top leadership of the organization (58%), total compensation (54%), and physician engagement (42%).
Satisfaction with physician engagement was higher among OR leaders who work in community hospitals (44%, compared to 33% in teaching hospitals).
The satisfaction rates for benefits and top leadership, at 61% and 57%, respectively, again were similar to others working in healthcare. Other professions have similar rates, for example, those in financial services have a 63% favorable rating for benefits and 59% favorability toward top leadership.
The highest unfavorable satisfaction (17%) was for top leadership of the organization, followed by 16% for both other support provided by the boss and engagement level of physicians.
Only 14% of respondents said they expect to leave their current employer in 2 years. The distribution of how long respondents plan to stay with their current employer is similar for OR leaders in both teaching and community hospitals.
When asked why they were leaving within 2 years, respondents frequently cited reasons such as “dissatisfaction with the way the hospital is currently being managed,” “lack of administrative support,” and “too much work.” However, some said they were leaving to seek career advancement.
Overall demographics are listed in the infographic (Meet the OR leader, p 8). Most respondents have earned a master’s degree, with 24% having a master’s in nursing (MSN), closely followed by 41% with a bachelor’s degree. Only two respondents had a doctoral degree, and only 16 had an associate degree in nursing.
An MSN was more common among respondents working in teaching than community hospitals (31% vs 23%), and administrators or administrative directors are more likely to have an MSN (42%) than directors (25%) or nurse managers (21%).
OR leaders are experienced and, for the most part, satisfied with their jobs. They will need to call on their expertise as they are challenged by developments that could affect their satisfaction level, such as bundled payments (see related story on p 1). ✥
Data for the OR Manager Salary/Career Survey were collected from March 23 to April 30, 2016. The survey list comprised OR directors, managers, or similar positions within hospital ORs. The survey was closed with 298 usable responses. The margin of error is ±5 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. This article features the compensation and management findings from the survey. Results of the staffing portion of the survey appeared in the September 2016 issue.
OR Manager thanks those who generously took time to complete this year’s survey. We appreciate your part in gathering this information, which will be useful to your colleagues around the country.