A spore test strip is now available for the Steris System 1E Liquid Chemical Sterilant Processing System. The Steris Verify Spore Test Strip for S40 was cleared by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in June 2012.
What is the role of this new spore test strip? How is this test method different from using biological indicators (BIs) and chemical indicators (CIs)?
The FDA, the Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI), and the Steris Corporation provide information that can help in using these test methods appropriately.
Liquid chemical sterilization differs from other common sterilization methods that use heat or gas/vapor/plasma, the FDA notes on its website. The FDA recommends that use of liquid chemical sterilants be limited to reprocessing only critical devices that are heat sensitive and incompatible with other sterilization methods.
Though the survival kinetics for microorganisms for thermal sterilization methods, such as steam and dry heat, have been extensively studied and characterized, the FDA says the kinetics of sterilization using liquid chemical sterilants are less well understood.
The FDA’s guidance on liquid chemical sterilants/high-level disinfectants refers to literature suggesting that sterilization processes based on liquid chemical sterilants “in general may not convey the same sterility assurance level (SAL) as sterilization achieved using thermal or physical methods.”
Other points by the FDA about sterilization with liquid chemical sterilants:
• Liquids cannot adequately penetrate barriers such as biofilms, tissue, and blood to attain organism kill as thermal sterilization processes can.
• The viscosity of some liquid chemical sterilants “impedes access to narrow lumens and matted surfaces of devices.”
• Devices cannot be wrapped or adequately contained during processing “to maintain sterility following processing and during storage.”
• Devices require rinsing “with water that typically is not sterile.”
These are reasons why the FDA cleared the System IE as a processor and not as a sterilizer. This means a liquid chemical sterilant process should not be your first choice for items that come in contact with compromised tissue.
It’s important to know that the Verify Spore Test Strip for liquid chemical sterilization is not the same as a BI used for steam sterilization.
In its regulatory documents for the spore test strip, the FDA notes that BIs are not appropriate for monitoring liquid chemical sterilization. The FDA has not cleared any BIs for that purpose because, the agency notes, the literature suggests that “sterilization with a liquid chemical sterilant may not convey the same sterility assurance as other sterilization methods.”
The standard for a terminal sterilization process is an SAL of 10-6, which means there is less than or equal to a 1 in 1 million chance that a single viable microorganism is present on a sterilized item. That is what a BI is intended to measure.
An SAL of 10-6 is appropriate for items intended to come in contact with compromised tissue (that is, tissue that has lost the integrity of the natural body barriers), according to the AAMI steam sterilization guideline (ANSI/AAMI ST79).
The Verify Spore Test Strip contains a known number of bacterial spores (at least 5 log10 or 105 per strip) of known resistance (Geobacillus stearothermophilus) to a liquid chemical sterilant used in a defined processing system. The Verify Spore Test Strip does not demonstrate that conditions were adequate to achieve an SAL of 10-6, but it does tell the user that the sporicidal activity of the S40 sterilant dilution was able to kill at least 5 log10 or 105 spores.
Use of the Verify Spore Test Strip is optional as a means to test the sporicidal activity of the sterilant used in the System 1E, as noted in the Steris instructions for use (IFU).
If the spore test strip was needed for monitoring the System 1E, it would have to have been cleared by the FDA at the same time as the System 1E processor and chemical indicator (CI) were cleared. This is a requirement for steam and low temperature sterilization processes new to the market.
In an e-mail communication, Steris stated, “Steris recommends that the Verify Spore Test Strip be used daily in the first processing cycle of the day.” This means the strip is placed into the processor along with the items to be processed.
The Steris IFU state to incubate the spore test strip at “55-60ºC (131-140ºF) for at least 24 hours.” If the spore test strip shows growth, the IFU say to “follow department procedures for liquid chemical sterilant process failures.”
The purpose of the CI is to measure the level of active ingredient in the liquid chemical sterilant. A CI must be available for a liquid chemical sterilant to be cleared for market.
Several CIs from different manufacturers are available to monitor the System 1E.
The Steris IFU for the Verify CI recommend use of the CI “during each processing cycle to detect the presence of the active ingredient, peracetic acid, in the use dilution of S40 Sterilant Concentrate.” A note states that the Verify CI for the System 1E should be used in each load tested with a spore test strip.
The IFU describe what the CI’s “pass” level means and how to tell if the processed items may be used or not.
The computer-controlled System IE, according to the company’s information, “continually monitors the cycle, including the full time, exposure time, temperature range of the exposure time, and the conductivity of the use dilution.”
AAMI’s chemical sterilization and high-level disinfection standard (ANSI/AAMI ST58) has recommendations for the documentation of chemical sterilant cycles. In highlights:
• Printouts should be checked at the beginning of the cycle to verify that the cycle identification number has been recorded and that the printer is functioning properly.
• At the end of the cycle before items are removed from the processing equipment, the operator should examine and interpret the printout to verify that cycle parameters were met and should initial the printout.
• Printouts should be maintained, as should a record of repairs and preventive maintenance.
Cycle documentation should include: identification of the processing unit, specific contents of the load, patient name, procedure, physician, exposure time, temperature, date and time of cycle, chemical concentration at exposure phase, name or initials of operator, results of CI or spore strip testing, and reports of inconclusive or nonresponsive CIs.
ANSI/AAMI ST58 recommends maintaining full traceability to the patient. This includes recording the load identifier on the patient chart or recording the patient name or other identifier on the load record.
For facilities that wanted a spore test when the System 1E entered the market, your wish has come true. But remember to run a CI in each load and document the results according to the recommendations in ANSI/AAMI ST58. ❖
Martha Young is an independent consultant with long experience in medical device sterilization and disinfection.
Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation. Chemical sterilization and high-level disinfection in health care facilities. ANSI/AAMI ST58(R):2005. This document is undergoing revision.
Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation. Comprehensive guide to steam sterilization and sterility assurance in health care facilities. ANSI/AAMI ST79:2010 & A1:2010 & A2:2011.
Evaluation of Automatic Class III Designation (DeNovo) for Steris Verify Spore Test Strip for S40. www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_docs/reviews/K100049.pdf
Food and Drug Administration. Liquid chemical disinfection. www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/ProductsandMedicalProcedures/GeneralHospitalDevicesandSupplies/ucm208018.htm
Food and Drug Administration. Guidance Document: Guidance for Industry and FDA Reviewers: Content and Format of Premarket Notification [510(k)] Submissions for Liquid Chemical Sterilants/High Level Disinfectants. January 3, 2000. www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/DeviceRegulationandGuidance/GuidanceDocuments/ucm073773.htm
Steris. Personal communications by email with Rosemary Niewolak, director, low temperature sterilization, Steris Corporation. August 16, 2012.
Steris. Verify Spore Test Strip for S40 Instructions, 10005723 Rev B. Received by email from sales representative. August 14, 2012.
Steris. Verify Chemical Indicator for SYSTEM 1E Processor, LCC016-20r03. Received by mail from sales representative. August 14, 2012.