Nearly two-thirds (60%) of employees who leave a position do so because of their relationship with their direct supervisor, according to the Studer Group, a health care consulting organization.
“Satisfaction is about relationship,” says Marcus Erb, senior research partner at the Great Place to Work Institute, which helps organizations become better places to work.
“What makes employees happy is the quality of interactions with their managers. As a leader, you need to establish that relationship.”
Staff satisfaction has a ripple effect.
“With more satisfied, more engaged staff, you see better service to patients,” Erb says. “If team members aren’t engaged, patients will pick up on that.”
Surgical services directors also have a financial incentive to focus on staff satisfaction. Medicare plans to factor patient experience scores into its new value-based purchasing program, which affects reimbursement beginning in October 2012.
Evidence of the payoff for staff satisfaction is in the numbers. Fortune magazine’s 100 Best Companies to Work For performed 3 times better in the general stock market and had at least 50% less voluntary turnover compared to national averages, according to Great Place to Work. In fact, the 100 best companies in the health care and social assistance category averaged 7.2% turnover compared to the national average of 17.4%.
“There is a direct correlation between engagement and quality, safety, and productivity. Engaged employees take ownership of what they do,” says Kathy Becker, MBA, RN, of the Studer Group.
Here’s expert advice on developing a strategy for staff satisfaction.
As with a preop surgical patient, staff satisfaction needs to be assessed. Experts say a formal assessment should be done at 12- to 18-month intervals.
It’s best to “have a variety of ways to measure satisfaction,” says Lil LeBlanc, MBA, SPHR, assistant vice president of HR strategy and culture at Baptist Health South Florida.
The organization has been widely recognized for its quality work environment, including being named to the 100 Best Companies for Working Mothers and Working Mother Hall of Fame by Working Mother magazine and landing on Fortune’s 100 Best Companies to Work For list many times.
Baptist Health annually administers the Gallup Employee Engagement Survey, which asks 12 core questions and 18 customized questions for Baptist Health employees.
Three years ago, Baptist Health added the Employee Opinion Poll, developed with the Corporate Leadership Council, Washington, DC. This poll asks about manager effectiveness, intent to stay, and how the organization delivers on the employee experience. It also measures discretionary effort—the degree to which someone is willing to go “over and above” job requirements without additional incentives such as extra pay.
Other hospitals collaborate with Great Place to Work and use the institute’s tools such as the Trust Index© Employee Survey, the Workplace Culture Assessment, and the 360 Management Trust Appraisal. Erb says managers can also use free websites like SurveyMonkey to collect data. Informal assessment through casual conversation should be ongoing, he adds. For example, each quarter, a manager can ask employees, “How are we doing? What is the organizational climate like?”
“Managers have a responsibility for creating an environment that is healthy for people,” says Jo Manion, PhD, RN, NEA-BC, FAAN, author of The Engaged Workforce and 7 other books. But she understands that’s not easy.
“Manager’s jobs are extraordinarily difficult,” she says. “There are so many distracters that it is easy for us to take our eyes off the ball.
“Some managers think, ‘I pay them, isn’t that enough? Do I have to make them happy, too?’ The truth is, you can’t make someone else happy.”
Erb says communication and collaboration are essential for establishing a trust, the essence of the relationship between managers and employees, and that boosts satisfaction.
“Trust is built on how they see their manager: if the manager is credible, whether they feel a level of respect, and whether there is a fair playing field,” he says.
Have the right mindset for each employee interaction, Erb advises. “Ask, how am I going to build trust with my employees? How will I assign schedules to build trust?” Questions like these allow managers to integrate trust into each interaction every day.
Becker recommends “purposeful rounding,” where the direct supervisor has a planned, one-on-one interaction with every employee at least monthly.
This is more focused than “management by wandering around,” she notes.
For example, instead of simply asking, “How are you?” ask questions such as, “What is going well? Who do you like to work with? Do you have the tools you need to do your job? What processes aren’t working?”
Such questions help build the manager-employee relationship and help address other factors important to employees, such as efficient work systems, tools and equipment to do the job, and appreciation.
Proactive, purposeful rounding can extend to the director’s other customers, including physicians, patients, families, and contacts in other departments.
Track your rounding to ensure you complete all of your contacts and to document results, Becker suggests.
Another source of focused communication is to seek employee input for decision making.
Be aware that your perceptions on input may differ from the staff’s. You might feel you have received employees’ input, but they might not understand they have given it.
Be specific when asking for input and explain how it will be used, Erb advises.
Senior hospital leaders also need to interact with OR staff, asking them similar types of questions, says Becker. “Visibility and approachability let employees know their leaders are listening to them.”
Quarterly forums are useful to keep staff informed and help them understand organizational goals. “It’s the job of leadership to translate goals to what they mean to the staff,” says Becker.
Staff should know results of quality metrics they are responsible for, such as the time-out before surgery. “It reinforces why what they do is so important on a daily basis.”
Baptist Health relies on employee advisory groups as a pipeline for feedback and ideas.
Managers nominate staff, who serve for 1 year or more.
“For example, if we want to roll out a new benefit, we show them the communication plan to be sure it’s clear,” LeBlanc says. These committees fall under the human resources department.
Inform staff of how employee survey results are used and report on progress in addressing identified problems.
Becker suggests a “stoplight report”: Green represents resolution of an item, yellow refers to “in progress,” and red is, “Those things I would like to be able to change but can’t, and here is why.” Post reports where staff can see them, discuss them in staff meetings, and update them monthly.
Closing the loop includes providing feedback for the staff. That’s challenging when the feedback is negative.
“You aren’t trying to get people to like you; you’re trying to get people to trust you,” Erb notes.
Employees need the “whole picture,” both positive and negative. And employees consistently say they want to know how they are doing.
Set aside time to give feedback.
“Build time into your schedule, whether it’s weekly, monthly, quarterly, by project, or some other schedule that works for you,” Erb says.
“Any place can be a great place to work,” Erb says. “You don’t have to have a budget, just take a sincere interest in your employees.”
Start having individual and group meetings with employees or even “take employees to lunch or dinner. That’s a powerful way to get information and build trust,” he advises.
Staff satisfaction benefits managers on a personal level, too. “If your staff is happier, you are happier,” says Erb. ❖
Cynthia Saver, a freelance writer, is president, CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland.
Great Place to Work. What are the benefits? www.greatplacetowork.com/our-approach/what-are-the-benefits-great-workplaces.