September 1, 2012

Staffing for surgery centers is in a holding pattern

By: OR Manager
PDF
Share

A weak economy continues to affect staffing in ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs), according to the 22nd annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey, with about 80% of nurse managers saying staff turnover stayed the same compared to 12 months ago, similar to 2011 results.

Other staffing parameters are also similar to last year.

ASC managers have responded to economic conditions by reducing overtime (38%), requiring staff to take time off without pay (32%), and eliminating open positions (16%). Only 3 respondents reported direct-care staff layoffs, and 2 reported management layoffs.

More than one-fourth (29%) say economic conditions have caused financial difficulties for their ASCs, most commonly because of changes in third-party reimbursement (71%) and declines in elective surgery (67%).

 

How has the economic downturn affected your ASC’s staffing in the past 6 months?
Overall
2012 2010 2009
Reduced use of overtime 38% 51% 44%
Required staff to take time off without pay 32% 37% 36%
Eliminated open positions 16% 14% 20%
Reduced use of agency personnel 8% 13% 13%
Had layoffs of management 1% 0% 0%
Had layoffs of direct care staff (RNs and STs) 1% 5% 5%
Note: The questions were first asked in 2009.
How many FTE positions are open?
RNs 0.8
STs 0.2
Average number of weeks positions have been open
RNs 9
STs 8

 

About the survey

The OR Manager Salary/Career Survey was mailed in March 2012 to 1,000 nurse managers of ASCs who were either OR Manager subscribers or part of an external list. The survey was closed with 198 usable responses—a 20% response rate. To ensure representation of the target audience, results were filtered to include only the 180 respondents who work full time in an ASC. The margin of error is±6.8 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. This article features the staffing findings from the survey. The rest of the findings will be reported in the October 2012 issue.

As in 2010 and 2011, most respondents (45%) work in physician-owned ASCs, followed by joint venture (26%), corporate or LLC (14%), and hospital-owned (9%) facilities. Nearly two-thirds (64%) of ASCs are multispecialty. The most common types of single-specialty ASCs are ophthalmology (40%) and gastroenterology (21%).

Nearly half (49%) of ASCs are in suburban settings, with 33% in urban and 14% rural locations.

 

Staffing overview

Few ASC managers are rolling out the welcome mat to new staff, with 74% reporting no open FTE RN positions and 85% having no open FTE surgical technologist (ST) positions, results similar to last year.

ASCs are more open than in the past to hiring staff without a perioperative background. More than half—58%—say they will hire RNs without OR experience, and 26% hire new graduates. That’s a jump from 5 years ago, when 47% would employ nurses without OR experience, and 19% would take new grads.

Only 5% of respondents say they have 4 or more open RN positions. ASC managers reported an average of 0.8 RN (slightly up from 0.4 in 2011) and 0.2 ST (comparable to 0.3 from 2011) open positions. Positions stayed open an average of 9 weeks for RNs and 8 weeks for STs.

Compared to 12 months earlier, most respondents—78% for RNs and 86% for STs—said the number of open positions stayed the same. The turnover rate was also stable, with most saying it was about the same as last year for RNs (80%) and STs (85%).

Most respondents (55% for RNs and 58% for STs) say recruiting experienced staff is unchanged from 12 months ago. About a third (37%) have found RN recruitment more difficult, and 29% report more difficulty recruiting STs. Those results are similar to those in 2011 (43% for RNs and 33% for STs), but higher than 2010 (27% for RNs and 21% for STs). ❖

 

Cynthia Saver, president of CLS Development, Inc, is a freelance writer based in Columbia, Maryland.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat