November 1, 2008

Study to focus on OR staffing, relation to patient outcomes

By: OR Manager
PDF
Share

Arecount of surgical sponges may prolong a case, but does it affect the patient’s outcome? Do patients fare better if an OR uses a certain staffing pattern? How does OR staff experience relate to outcomes?

AkkeNeel Talsma, RN, PhD

These are examples of questions a nurse researcher at the University of Michigan (UM), Ann Arbor, plans to investigate in a study funded by a 3-year $350,000 grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF).

“There is not much information published on OR nursing. We don’t know whether that’s because no one has looked at this or because there is no link,” says the researcher, AkkeNeel Talsma, RN, PhD, assistant professor of nursing at UM. She earlier participated in a key study on failure to rescue, which refers to caregivers’ failure to respond to preventable patient complications that later lead to a fatality.

OR staffing and outcomes

The new study will focus on testing the relationship between OR staffing characteristics and patient outcomes. Data sources will include the OR nursing record and the database from the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP), which captures data about surgery and patient outcomes.

The study has 2 major components:

  • To capture OR staffing patterns, such as what types of personnel are in the room, their experience, and whether there were interruptions or a shift change during a case.
  • To evaluate the relation between these OR nursing factors and patient outcomes. These may include immediate outcomes, such as the need to take an x-ray to confirm a count, and more distant outcomes, such as bleeding or wound problems.

OR staffing is based on 1 RN circulator and 1 surgical technologist as the scrub person. Traditionally, staff members have been assigned and rewarded based on their knowledge and skill and length of service in the OR.

“In the current OR environment, this formula has limited success,” Talsma says. Surgical procedures are more complex with the need for more technical skill with equipment, greater specialization, and sometimes more than 2 staff members assigned to a case. The generalist staff member cannot keep up with all of the changes and innovation in each specialty.”

Data for better decisions

There is also the issue of staffing costs.

“Some states are looking at having surgical technologists circulate for cases and have 1 RN to cover charting for several ORs,” she notes. “RNs are necessary for excellent, quality patient care with positive patient outcomes.” For example, nurses are aware of the rationale for preoperative antibiotics, normothermia, grounding pad placement, positioning, estimated blood loss, and expedited surgical processes.

“This study should be able to capture some of the information needed to understand staffing concerns and patient outcomes,” Talsma says. “The findings would help OR nursing management and leadership make informed decisions for better outcomes.”

The study will be conducted in several phases. The first phase this fall will be to develop the OR nursing measures. Talsma has worked with OR management at UM and AORN members to define measures. A pilot study to test the measures will be conducted at UM. Then in 2009, the plan is for the study to be expanded to 6 or 7 other Michigan hospitals. Talsma plans to include some hospitals with Magnet recognition for nursing excellence as well as union and nonunion facilities.

More information is at www.ns.umich.edu/htdocs/releases/story.php?id=6694.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat