June 28, 2022

Succession planning post-COVID: Identifying the right people

By: Jennifer Lubell
Share

When Donna Doyle, DNP, RN, CNOR, NE-BC, perioperative consultant with DJD Consulting Services in Columbus, Ohio, thinks of succession planning, the British royal family comes to mind.

“That is the epitome of succession planning,” she says. “You know exactly who’s in what position, who is next up, and who is learning in that role. And it’s changing constantly.”

Managers of perioperative nurses need to be thinking about these metrics when establishing leadership in their ORs, she emphasizes. Identifying future leaders means identifying who is ready to take on these roles, not just in a year but several years down the road.

Doyle will address this topic with Stephanie Davis, MSHA, RN, CNOR, CSSM, vice president of surgical services, operations, and service lines at HCA Healthcare Tennessee, and Carol Pehotsky, DNP, RN, NEA-BC, ACNS-BC, CPAN, associate chief nursing officer for surgical services at Cleveland Clinic Health System, in a two-part workshop at the OR Manager Conference, October 17–19, in Denver, Colorado.

The workshop will drive home the importance of having a succession plan and devoting resources to it. Succession planning is resource, cost, and time intensive. It is also extremely important because perioperative is a multimillion-dollar enterprise from where most of a hospital’s net revenue comes, Doyle stresses.

 

Today versus pre-COVID

Identifying good leaders is a challenge. Even before COVID-19 was a household name, a perfect storm was developing in the perioperative nursing world: a global nursing shortage and a dearth of succession planning in the industry.

The World Health Organization in April 2020 projected a worldwide shortage of 5.7 million nurses by 2030. The shortage has since gotten worse, says Doyle.

Most leaders come from the OR nurse staff. However, literature in Becker’s Hospital Review, Harvard Business Review, and other sources points to a shortage in the perioperative specialty, says Doyle. “Individuals in perioperative leadership positions have decreased by virtue of the fact that they are generally older, have greater than 20 years of experience, and are in that segment of nurses who are retired or are in target ranges of retiring.”

As a result of that shortage, managers are having difficulty recruiting, she adds. The 2021 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey reported that 75% of OR leaders are finding it difficult to recruit experienced RNs, an increase from 63% in 2020.

Other factors such as burnout are at play. Managers are tired of orienting individuals who stay only a few years and move on. Millennials in particular are prone to say, “This isn’t for me,” before moving out of perioperative. They are not like the baby boomers who devoted their lives to one job, says Doyle.

“Because of this constant churn, you don’t have the mentoring or the succession planning that’s occurring. Then you put the intersection of COVID—which took a big chunk out of the nursing profession–with all of this. Leaders don’t have time to identify those individuals to be mentored and succession plan to move them into those vacant positions,” adds Doyle.

COVID-19 has also scared away potentials who may have once considered a leadership position, says Pehotsky.

“Now we’re in a place where there are a lot of patients we want to serve, and we’re trying to make up for lost time,” she adds. Strong leaders are needed now more than ever to maintain the financial health of institutions and OR units. But the pandemic has made people more hesitant. “Some people who might have been curious are seeing what their managers are going through and saying no for now.”

COVID-19 has also encouraged procrastination, and that is not good, Pehotsky continues. There are always good intentions around succession planning, but there are also always competing priorities. People might say they will get to it when COVID’s over or there’s more staff. “There’s always a reason to put it off, but things may never settle down. It’s more important than ever. Filling vacant leadership positions are very impactful to deliver patient care.” It is important to carve out time, to make succession planning a priority, says Pehotsky.

 

The wrong person for the job

The workshop will go into detail about the importance of succession planning and how to recognize high potential individuals who can be identified to go into leadership roles.

Many times, the wrong person gets recruited for leadership positions, says Doyle. With fewer perioperative nurses on staff, sometimes a person with business expertise gets promoted. But clinical experience does not always translate into a good leader, either. Someone who is competent in the OR may not have natural leadership skills.

Doyle estimates that 80% of the people managers focus on are usually the wrong people to recruit. “Why? Because the OR is a high-efficiency, very complex, and stressful unit. And guess what, the squeaky wheel usually gets the oil. Managers often focus on those individuals, and they aren’t necessarily the correct individuals to go into those roles,” she says.

Recruiting the wrong person has a price. “You’re just going to ‘churn and turn’ them, and that’s going to cost your organization time and money and frustrate the individuals mentoring them,” says Doyle.

The key is to identify those individuals who want to develop and become leaders. “We can educate on how to identify the right people and how to utilize career planning strategies to develop individual plans,” Doyle says of the workshop’s agenda.

 

A three-part workshop

The workshop, “Succession planning, don’t let your high potentials die on the vine,” will take place in two phases, with the three speakers focusing on a different objective.

Doyle will start off by discussing the importance of succession planning. Her presentation will include a demographic look on the rise of millennials and the need to connect with them. These are the people replacing the Baby Boomers, which is why organizations have to prioritize them. “As a general rule, I don’t think they have,” she adds.

Davis will handle the second objective: recognizing and mentoring high potentials and assessing what qualities to look for. One of Davis’ favorite quotes is from Mahatma Gandhi: “A sign of a good leader is not how many followers you have, but how many leaders you create.”

“As a leader, it is our job to identify the talented folks in our workplace,” says Davis. “We need to encourage them to pursue certification and advanced degrees to better prepare themselves for future roles. Having those important conversations with our high performers and being sure they know that they are one, is critical.”

Working on a strategic plan to help people advance to their next leadership role or get that first entry-level leadership job can put them on a good path for future success, says Davis. “All too often, we may not express our appreciation or tell staff how much we value them as part of our team. Doing this consistently and making sure those who want to progress see the path clearly is what great leaders do.”

Pehotsky will wrap things up with strategies for individualized plans.

“Based on the objectives, we want participants to go back to their organizations and assess if they have succession planning strategies. We hope they take some of the ideas we’re presenting and work with ‘next up’ leaders to embellish or develop a plan for succession planning,” says Doyle.

 

Value of real-time experience

While it is important to talk about individual plans and specific commitments of those plans, Pehotsky stresses that “in the moment” succession plan opportunities are also invaluable.

Pehotsky recalls one impactful moment she had with a supervisor, who saw potential in her and used the setting of a meeting as a development opportunity.

“The supervisor said, ‘I don’t want you to say anything. I want you to listen and watch why I said what I said and when I said it.’ I sat quietly and listened. She was going into a challenging situation. I watched how she debriefed people and took emotional intelligence to the next level, commanding a very politically charged situation.”

Succession planning plays a dual role: showing people what skills they will need in their next role and mentoring them to help them grow. Classes are great, but helping people grow in the moment with on-the-fly coaching and teaching is also important.

“If I never apply what I learn in a class, it’s not a good use of my time,” says Pehotsky. If succession planning is nursing based, it is important to work with mentees in classes and talk about how to apply strategies in the perioperative setting. “We need to create opportunities to apply those skills,” she emphasizes. Managers for example can recruit people to serve on a committee so that they can develop skills they learned in class.

COVID-19 may have disrupted plans, employment metrics and patient care. But amid all this chaos, Pehotsky saw some incredible leadership emerge among the most unlikely individuals.

“What’s been interesting as we hopefully get to a different phase of COVID, is watching some people really rise to the occasion of what we’re looking for in a leader, either leading during a pandemic or in the perioperative space,” she says.

People who were not interested in leadership several years ago suddenly wanted to make things better. “I’ve been delighted to see leaders that didn’t present as leaders before COVID stepping forward. And we’re like, wow, this is someone who has got fantastic leadership potential that wasn’t necessarily obvious to us.”

It is important to watch for people who may not raise their hands and say, “I want to be a nurse manager someday,” but nevertheless demonstrate great leadership qualities.

The workshop will include resources for those who are interested in further development, and tools and ideas to help managers identify and develop those ideal for succession planning.

There are lots of different ways to approach succession planning, says Pehotsky. “There’s no fixed time or resources. It’s about giving people some tools and resources, and offer a dialogue so they can talk about what’s worked or not worked.”

 

—Jennifer Lubell is a freelance medical and health policy writer based in Rockville, Maryland.

 

References

Saver C. Survey: COVID-19 pandemic takes toll on staffing. OR Manager. 2021;37(9):1, 7-11.

Saver C. Pandemic raises OR nurse recruitment, management challenges. OR Manager. 2020;36(9):1, 15-19.

Lubell J. Think ahead: Plan today for tomorrow’s staffing gaps. OR Manager. 2021;37(7):24-27.

State of the World’s Nursing report 2020. World Health Organization.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat