OR leaders continue to face increases in volume and staffing mobility, according to the 2016 annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey.
The volume of surgical procedures in the past 12 months increased for slightly more than half of respondents (51%), compared to 43% in 2015. In terms of staffing, respondents noted that, compared with 12 months ago, the percentage of open positions increased for both RNs and surgical technologists (STs): 41% (vs 32% in 2015) for RNs and 39% (vs 28% in 2015) for STs.
The percentage of those who say turnover rate has increased in the past 12 months was 39% for RNs and 28% for STs, both slightly higher than in 2015. And when asked how staffing had changed during the past year, more than half (51%) of respondents reported hiring more staff.
Recruiting difficulties for experienced RNs remain a challenge, with 70% of respondents saying it’s more difficult, comparable to the 69% from 2015, although this year nearly half (47%) say it’s more difficult to recruit STs, compared to 38% last year.
As one respondent noted, “I am in a rural area, and it is very difficult to find certified surgical technologists or staff that have previous experience scrubbing. This is a huge issue for a very progressive rural hospital.”
The survey also asked about bundling payments for specific procedures. See the results in the infographic on p 11, and watch for a related story on bundling in our October 2016 issue.
Other key findings of the survey include:
• 26% of respondents report no open positions for RNs, comparable to 28% last year, but about one-third (32%) reported no open positions for STs, down from 43% last year and 54% in 2014.
• Comanagment agreements with surgeons remain rare; only 21% of OR leaders say they have them, comparable to last year’s 23%. Teaching hospitals are slightly less likely than community hospitals (14% vs 23%) to pursue this option.
• More than half (54%) of respondents say they are trying to reduce or eliminate the presence of vendors in the OR during surgery, similar to last year’s 53%. Only 2% report complete elimination. Efforts in this area are similar among both teaching and community hospitals.
When asked how staffing had changed in the past year, OR leaders in teaching hospitals were much more likely than those in community hospitals to report hiring more staff (70% vs 47%). Only 9% of respondents said they hired more managers.
Fewer than half (45%) reported that the number of open positions had stayed the same for RNs, and 48% reported the number had stayed the same for STs. Most respondents had at least one open RN position, with 3% reporting 15 or more, the same as last year. For those respondents, the range was 17 to 90, with a mean of 33.67. The high end may reflect an organization opening a new facility.
Most respondents also had at least one open ST position, with 6% reporting 5 or more, comparable to last year’s 5%; the range was 5 to 35, with a mean of 13.
The RN to ST ratio was 63:36, similar to previous years.
Strategies related to staffing actions continued last year’s trends and likely reflect a tightening job market. About a quarter (24%) of respondents reduced overtime during the past year, compared with 36% in 2015. Only 16% reduced the use of agency or travel RNs and STs, slightly less than the 20% reported last year, and 23% reported an increase. In addition, 31% of respondents reported more use of overtime, whereas 24% said they had decreased overtime (down from 36% in 2015).
The average staff turnover rate (defined as the percentage of staff who have left and been replaced in the past 12 months) was 9% for RNs and 8% for STs, the same percentages as reported in 2015.
Recruitment difficulties were similar to last year. Only 4% of respondents said it is easier to recruit experienced RNs, and 14% said it is easier to recruit experienced STs. More than half (56%) said recruiting new or inexperienced OR nurses was unchanged, and 26% reported it was easier.
George S. Patton once said, “Accept the challenge so that you can feel the exhilaration of victory.” If that’s true, then OR leaders can expect to feel highly exhilarated given the number of challenges they face. More than 175 respondents shared comments; here is a representative sample of their remarks.
Capital budget problems.Respondents said funds have decreased or don’t exist, and obtaining approval for high-ticket items is difficult.
Costs. Keeping costs down was a theme, and respondents cited increased supply costs, lower reimbursement, increased technology, and higher labor costs as factors that make it hard to meet budget goals.
“The general sense is that suppliers are presenting more items that are more expensive,” said one respondent. “For a period from 2008 to 2014, suppliers were offering options and solutions that lowered total cost. Now suppliers seem to be offering very expensive advanced products with the promise of improved quality, increased patient satisfaction, future referral generation, potential for decreased length of stay, etc—all with limited supporting data.”
Reimbursement. Several respondents reported lower reimbursement as a problem, with one noting, “Reimbursement is approximately 35% of billed amounts and decreasing.”
General finance. Respondents reported several other types of financial conundrums, including reduced volume, bundled payments, pressure to meet Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services targets, marketing technology to a smaller community, and competition issues, such as losing orthopedics to a newly built surgery center owned by orthopedic surgeons.
Insufficient, inexperienced staff. The most common staffing-related comment was not having enough staff, particularly experienced staff, even though volume and case complexity have increased. Difficulty in finding travelers and good leaders for management positions, as well as being able to flex staff based on volume, were also noted. Unfortunately, not all OR leaders are supported in their staffing issues, as evidenced by these comments:
• “We do not have the correct staffing and are unable to get this changed, even with statistics.”
• “Leadership sees that my positions are full, but they are not taking into account that orientation is 6 months—so staffing in my eyes is still short, but not in the eyes of administration.”
Education. Educating new staff, including finding funds to run OR training orientation programs, and providing education to keep staff up to date with the technology were among the reported challenges.
One respondent noted, “Our education department was reduced to one OR educator for the system. This puts the onus on our nurses, who should be focusing on the surgery and patient, rather than the brand new nurse, who needs total attention not to break sterile barriers. Infection rates increase, OR competencies decrease. I’ve been an OR nurse for 20 years, and I see a problem I cannot fight effectively.”
Two respondents commented on their desire to help staff achieve certification.
Engagement and satisfaction. Several respondents noted concerns about staff engagement and satisfaction—especially low morale. One OR leader said, “Morale is extremely low. Staff engagement is becoming more elusive and challenging.”
Age. Some respondents are apprehensive about an aging workforce, as many baby boomers near retirement age. “Many RNs will retire or be on some kind of FMLA [Family and Medical Leave Act],” one OR leader noted. “[We have an] average of six people out per day related to illness or FMLA.” On the other hand, a few respondents expressed concern about the work ethic of younger nurses and the lack of support for training younger staff.
Retention. One respondent noted that rewarding staff who choose to stay is a challenge. Another describes the challenge as, “Keeping staff to stay in one nursing area; they seem to be more mobile and not stay in one place even if happy with career choice.” Part of the problem may be increased expectations of work environment by staff, which was reported by one respondent.
Throughput. Improving on-time first case starts, turnover time, utilization, efficiency, productivity, and block time management are common concerns. One respondent cited this problem: “Finding surgeons willing to schedule other than the most popular hours per day or day per week. For example, block time is difficult to obtain on Thursdays but wide open on Fridays.”
Another respondent noted the desire to “reduce variance to become more efficient in cost and processes.”
Physicians. Respondents reported the need to engage physicians, recruit new surgeons, find a medical director, and to “keep surgeons satisfied while keeping staffing tight and capital costs low.”
Physical changes. A few respondents reported construction or renovation projects for the OR or sterile processing department and the need for more OR rooms.
Other challenges. Additional challenges included implementation of an electronic health record (EHR) and documentation compliance with EHRs.
Legislation and reporting requirements. Respondents cited the Affordable Care Act, the Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement program, the Physician Quality Reporting System, core measures, and patient safety goals.
Competition. Competition-related challenges included a new hospital being built in close proximity, the need to grow and add service lines, and becoming affiliated with a large system.
Other challenges. Completing systemwide initiatives and keeping up with the expectations of the senior leadership team were noted, and one respondent lamented that nursing is becoming a financial model rather than a patient care model.
Most respondents work in a community hospital (66%) rather than a teaching hospital (21%), and about one-quarter (26%) work in a hospital with a union. In most cases (70%), the union is for both nurses and other staff.
More teaching hospitals than community hospitals have Magnet designation, and overall just 22% of respondents say their organization has Magnet status.
OR leaders are continuing to cope with increased volume and staffing mobility. A significant challenge is retaining staff. As one respondent succinctly explains, “The training requirements for the OR are extensive. As soon as you get them trained, the staff leave for more money, no call, no holidays, no weekends. We can’t seem to get ahead of the game.”
This is one game that OR leaders can’t afford to lose if surgical patients are to continue receiving quality care. ✥
Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.
Data for the OR Manager Salary/Career Survey were collected from March 23 to April 30, 2016. The survey list comprised OR directors, managers, or similar positions within hospital ORs. The survey was closed with 298 usable responses. The margin of error is ±5 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. This article features the staffing findings from the survey. Other findings, including compensation and management responsibilities, will be reported in the October 2016 issue.
OR Manager thanks those who generously took time to complete this year’s survey. We appreciate your part in gathering this information, which will be useful to your colleagues around the country.