Who assists at surgery in your OR? If not physicians, most commonly they are RN first assistants (RNFAs) and physician assistants, OR Manager subscribers report in a new survey.
Only 15% of respondents say they do not use nonphysicians as assistants.
Not surprisingly, more community hospitals (89%) use nonphysicians in this role than do teaching hospitals (79%), which have residents to assist.
The vast majority—nearly 9 in 10—say their assistants are credentialed or privileged to practice in the OR. But for about one-third, not all of the assistants have specialized qualifications in surgical assisting, though that is recommended by major associations (charts).
The first assistant responses are part of the 2012 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey mailed in March 2012 to a sample of OR Manager subscribers who are directors of hospital operating rooms. The response rate was 24%. The margin of error is +/-6.3 percentage points at the 95% confidence level.
Surgical assisting by nonphysicians has become common in the past 15 to 20 years as insurance reimbursement has declined for physicians who assist.
The high percentage of respondents (87%) who say their nonphysician assistants are credentialed or privileged is a gain over 15 years ago when an OR Manager survey found that 78% credentialed RNFAs, and 76% credentialed other nonphysician assistants.
In the 2012 survey, the smallest facilities (1-4 ORs) were the least likely to say that they credential assistants (75%) and to say that their assistants have specialized education and training (52%).
| Which categories of nonphysician assistants at surgery does your OR use? | |
| Physician assistants (PAs) | 69% |
| RNFAs/CRNFAs | 54% |
| Certified surgical first assistants | 29% |
| Surgical technologists (not specifically trained as first assistants) | 28% |
| RNs (not trained as first assistants) | 24% |
| Certified surgical assistants (CSA, SA-C) | 21% |
| Other | 9% |
| By number of ORs | |||
| 1-4 | 5-9 | 10+ | |
| Yes | 75% | 90% | 89% |
| No | 25% | 10% | 11% |
| By number of ORs | |||
| 1-4 | 5-9 | 10+ | |
| Yes | 52% | 73% | 72% |
| No | 48% | 27% | 27% |
Employment arrangements are mixed. For 34% of respondents, assistants are hospital employees, for 21% they are not, and for 30%, it is a combination. Teaching hospitals (43%) are more likely to employ assistants than community hospitals (33%).
Employment arrangements for assistants are driven by the individual market and region, note directors of surgical services.
In some markets, surgeons expect the hospitals to provide first assistants, and hospitals provide them for competitive reasons. But in other markets, surgeons do not have that expectation.
Market forces also play a role in the types of practitioners used to assist.
Having assistants is nice for turnover between surgical cases, some directors say, because there are 3 individuals to help with the process instead of only the scrub person and circulating nurse.
Though PAs and RNFAs are the most common assistants reported in the survey, respondents use a variety of other personnel in the assisting role: RNs and STs without specialized training, certified surgical first assistants (CSFA), certified surgical assistants (CSA and SA-C), and others. ❖
ORs turn to non-MDs, but reimbursement lags. OR Manager. 1997;13(9): 1, 16, 18.