Financial challenges may have eased slightly for ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs), according to the 22nd annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. Only 29% of ASC managers report financial difficulties because of current economic conditions, much lower than the 43% in 2010.
Reasons cited for those financial difficulties have changed in the past 2 years. About two-thirds (67%) say elective surgery has declined, fewer than the 81% of respondents who said the same in 2010. More managers attribute their financial challenges to changes in reimbursement (71%) and a lack of available credit (16%).
Other key findings of the survey include:
• Only 19% of respondents say surgical volume has decreased over the past 6 months, much lower than 2010’s 34% and close to 2007’s prerecession 14%. More than a quarter (26%) say their volume has increased.
• Only 9% of respondents say their annual operating budget decreased in the past 6 months.
• Only 5% of respondents lost benefits, half of the number in 2010’s report.
• The average salary of an ASC manager is $89,300, slightly higher than 2011’s $88,500.

The OR Manager Salary/Career Survey was mailed in March 2012 to 1,000 nurse managers of ASCs who were either OR Manager subscribers or part of an external list. The survey was closed with 198 usable responses—a 20% response rate. To ensure representation of the target audience, results were filtered to include only the 180 respondents who work full time in an ASC. The margin of error is±6.8 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. This article features the compensation and management findings from the survey. Results from the staffing portion of the survey appeared in the September OR Manager.
Most respondents (65%) work in multispecialty ASCs, with 35% in single-specialty centers. The most common types of single-specialty ASCs are ophthalmology (40%), gastroenterology (21%), and orthopedics (14%).
Most facilities (45%) are owned by physicians, followed by joint venture (26%), corporate-owned (14%), and hospital-owned (9%) arrangements. About half (51%) of ASCs are located in suburban areas, 34% are in urban areas, and only 15% are in rural locations. The average annual case volume is 4,530.
| ASC managers’ purchasing power | |
| Do you influence the selection and purchase of… | |
| OR supplies/equipment | 92% |
| OR capital equipment | 82% |
| What best describes your involvement in purchasing decisions? | |
| Member of committee | 48% |
| Primary decision maker | 39% |
| Advisory capacity | 32% |
ASC managers earn an average salary of $89,300, compared with $80,100 in 2007. That’s more than $30,000 less than the $120,000 average earned by their hospital counterparts. The largest group (25%) of ASC respondents earns between $80,000 and $89,999.
Average total compensation, which includes benefits and bonuses, for ASC managers is $106,000, $39,000 less than the average $145,000 that hospital-based OR leaders earn. About a quarter (27%) of ASC respondents have a total compensation package between $100,000 and $124,999.
ASC managers who work in corporate-owned facilities earn more, both in salary and total compensation, than their counterparts in physician-owned and joint venture ASCs. Managers in the West earn the most of all regions, and those in multispecialty centers earn more than those who work in single-specialty facilities. Respondents who hold the title of administrator or administrative director earn more than those with the title of nurse manager. As expected, respondents who oversee 5 or more ORs earn more than those responsible for fewer ORs.
Raises and bonuses. When it comes to raises and bonuses, ASC managers come out ahead of their hospital counterparts.
ASC respondents received an average salary increase of 4.1% this year, much higher than the 2.8% for hospital leaders, and gaining on 2007’s 5.1%, which was before the recession hit. Only 10% of ASC respondents received their raise as part of a promotion or change in job responsibilities.
Far more ASC managers (70%) than hospital leaders (49%) received bonuses in the past year. The average bonus was $7,700 compared to $9,590 for hospital OR leaders.
Benefits. Consistent with past results, ASC managers receive fewer benefits than their colleagues who work in hospitals. Discrepancies in life, dental, and disability insurance, as well as lower pensions and tuition reimbursement are particularly noteworthy.
ASCHospital
Paid time off 99% 98%
Health insurance 86% 94%
401(k) plan 86% 88%
Bonuses/ profit sharing 76% 56%
Life insurance 76% 95%
Dental insurance 71% 91%
Eye care 60% 74%
Disability ins 54% 81%
Educ benefits 49% 54%
Depend health insurance 47% 70%
Tuition reimb 29% 77%
Pensions 18% 41%
Incentive pay 9% 14%
Only 5% of respondents say they have lost benefits in the past 5%, half of what was reported in 2010. ASC managers receive an average of 25.7 days of paid time off.
| Respondents to hospital survey | |
| Region | Response |
| Northeast | 15% |
| Midwest | 24% |
| South | 34% |
| West | 26% |

| In the past 6 months, the ASC’s volume has… | |||
| 2012 | 2010 | 2007 | |
| Increased | 26% | 21% | 46% |
| Decreased | 19% | 34% | 14% |
| Remained about the same | 55% | 45% | 39% |
Survey results provide insight into the work environment of ASC managers.
Number of ORs managed. Respondents oversee an average of 3.9 ORs, similar to 3.8 in 2007. Respondents in joint venture facilities oversee an average of 5 ORs, those in corporate-owned facilities oversee an average of 4 ORs, while those in physician-owned facilities are responsible for an average of 3.0 ORs. As in past surveys, managers in multispecialty ASCs oversee more ORs than those in single specialty facilities, managing 4.4 and 2.9 respectively.
Manager scope and role. ASC managers oversee 24.6 full-time equivalents (FTEs)—an average of 20.9 clinical FTEs and 3.7 nonclinical FTEs. That compares to a total average of 138.0 FTEs for hospital leaders—an average of 111.0 clinical and 26.5 nonclinical FTEs.
In all, 29% of respondents hold the title of director of nursing, followed by 26% for administrator or administrative director, 22% for nurse managers, and 19% for clinical directors, with 4% having another title.
More than half (53%) of ASC managers report to administration. Reporting structures receiving more than 30% responses are physician owners (39%), board of directors (38%), and medical director (32%). Only 9% of respondents report to a corporate office. Some gave multiple answers.
Budget. The average ASC annual operating budget is $6.0 million, but only 1 in 5 managers responded to this question with a number, making analysis difficult. In 2010, the average operating budget was $4.7 million. ASC managers in joint venture facilities have the highest budget ($7.9 million), followed by physician-owned ($4.9 million), and corporate owned ($3.7 million) centers. Last year, corporate-owned ASCs had the highest operating budget.
Of those who answered the question, slightly over half (69%) say their budgets stayed the same in the past 6 months, and 19% say they have increased.
Purchasing power. ASC managers have significant influence over the selection and purchase of OR supplies and equipment (92%) and OR capital equipment (82%). Nearly half (48%) say they use that influence as a committee member, 39% say they are the primary decision makers, and 32% serve in an advisory capacity.
Work hours. Like their hospital counterparts, ASC managers rarely have a 40-hour workweek, clocking an average of 48 hours. More than a third (36%) work 50 to 54 hours, 27% work 45 to 49 hours, and 20% work 40 to 44 hours. A few (2%) work 65 or more hours a week.
Satisfaction. Again like their hospital counterparts, ASC managers are satisfied with their positions, reporting an average of 4.2 on a 5-point scale (with 5 being “very satisfied,” and 1 being “not satisfied at all”). Overall, 39% of respondents say they are very satisfied, and 43% rate their satisfaction as 4. Only 7 respondents rate their satisfaction as 2 or 1.
| Average annual salary and total compensation | ||
| Annual salary | Total compensation | |
| By number of ORs | ||
| <5 ORs | $86,700 | $96,200 |
| 5+ ORs | $96,200 | $117,000 |
| By ownership | ||
| Physician owned | $87,400 | $105,000 |
| Corporate owned | $94,600 | $110,000 |
| Joint venture | $83,900 | $102,000 |
| By title | ||
| Administrator/admin director | $98,100 | $122,000 |
| Nurse manager | $85,300 | $103,000 |

| ASC managers’ span of control | |
| Clinical FTEs | 20.9 |
| Nonclinical FTEs | 3.7 |
| Total FTEs | 24.6 |
Most ASC managers are women (91%) who are RNs (94%). The largest group of respondents (34%) lives in the South, followed by 26% in the West, 24% in the Midwest, and 15% in the Northeast.
Age and experience. The median age of respondents is 53 years, significantly higher than the median age of all RNs (46), according to the 2008 National Sample Survey of Registered Nurses.
Respondents have an average 26.9 years of experience in nursing (11% of respondents have 40 or more years of experience), and they have held their current position an average of 9.4 years.
Education. Overall, 43% of respondents have a bachelor’s as their highest degree. Only 15% have a master’s degree, and 30% list an associate degree as their highest level of education. In contrast, hospital leaders have higher education levels—48% have a master’s as their highest degree.
About half (52%) of employers require a specific degree for respondents’ positions, compared with 80% for OR leaders. Of those who require a degree, 68% stipulate a bachelor’s degree, 12% specify a master’s degree, and 13% require an associate degree.
This year’s survey seems to indicate an easing of financial hardship, but the many dynamics that affect the economy make conclusions difficult. ❖