September 26, 2023

Survey: Compensation rises slightly for ASC leaders amid on-going pressures

By: Cynthia Saver, MS, RN
Share

Compensation is trending slightly higher for ambulatory surgery center (ASC) leaders, according to the 2023 OR Manager Salary/Career Survey, with 68% of respondents reporting a total annual compensation of $120,000 or more, up from 50% in 2022 and 40% in 2021.

However, higher wages are unlikely to sufficiently offset the stressors ASC leaders are experiencing. For example, those who responded they are planning to leave their current employer within the next year most commonly cite burnout (22%) as the reason, which is comparable to the 25% who cited this factor in 2022.

In addition, ASC leaders are seeing their responsibilities continue to grow. For example, they now supervise an average of 40 employees, compared to 36 in 2022 and up from 32 in 2019, the last survey before the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite the challenges of the current environment, satisfaction levels are generally on par with prepandemic levels. For instance, 73% view their current job or position favorably, compared to 74% in 2019.

Other highlights from the survey include:

  • More respondents received a raise in the past 12 months compared to 2022 (74% vs 66%). The average raise was 5.1% (4.8% when the single 30% response is omitted), higher than last year’s 4.24%, but still lower than the 2022 consumer price index of 6.5%.
  • More than half (54%) of respondents plan to retire in 2024 or later, with 10% planning to head for the work exit by the end of 2025.
  • Half of respondents plan to stay with their current employer 5 years or more (vs 55% in 2022), but 28% (vs 24% in 2022) plan to stay 2 years or less; 22% plan on staying 3 to 5 years.

Here is a more detailed look at some of the key findings. (Percentages may not add up to 100% due to rounding.) For results related to staffing, see “ASC volumes continue to rise amid staffing challenges,” OR Manager, September 2023, pp 30–31, 33.

 

Financial details

The survey included questions about salary and total compensation.

Salary. More than three-quarters (77%) of respondents reported earning an average annual salary of $100,000 or more, up from 58% in 2022 and 51% in 2021. The most common salary ranges were $100,000 to $119,999 (32% vs 23% in 2022) and $120,000 to $149,999 (28% vs 22% in 2022). The percentage of those earning $150,000 or more was 17%, nearly three times higher than the 2021’s 6%.

As expected, salary range varied by job title. The few (2%) respondents who have vice president or chief nurse executive as their title earn $150,000 or more. Most directors and assistant directors earn between $100,000 and $119,999 (34%), followed by $120,000 to $149,999 (25%). Those ranges are the same for administrators and administrative directors, with percentages of 39% and 34%, respectively. Most nurse managers chose either the $120,000 to $149,999 (26%) or $100,000 to $119,999 range (24%).

Salary also varied by region. Most ASC leaders in the West (35%) reported earning a salary of $150,000 or more, and most leaders in the Midwest (31%) earn $120,000 to $149,999. The most common range for respondents in the South and Northeast was $100,000 to $119,999 (52% and 44%, respectively).

The most common salary ranges were the same for leaders in multispecialty and single specialty ASCs. Nearly a third (31%) of multispecialty respondents earn between $100,000 and $119,999, similar to the 33% reported by single specialty respondents, and 28% of both groups reported earning between $120,000 to $149,999.

When broken down by services offered, the top two salary ranges for leaders in both single and multispecialty ASCs were $100,000 to $119,999 (33% for single specialty and 31% for multispecialty) and 120,000 to $149,999 (28% for each group).

Total compensation. Most respondents (37%, the same as 2022) reported they fell into the total compensation range of $120,000 to $149,999. Only 14% earn less than $100,000.

As with salary, the most common total compensation range varied by title. Vice president or chief nurse executive respondents earn $200,000 or more annually in total compensation. The most common range for other job titles was $120,000 to $149,999: 42% for nurse managers, 39% for administrators or administrative directors, and 31% for directors or assistant directors.

Respondents in all four regions most commonly reported a total compensation range of $120,000 to $149,999: 56% for the Northeast, 45% for the South, 35% for the West, and 28% for the Midwest.

Leaders in multispecialty ASCs generally earn more in total compensation than those in single specialty centers. Half of leaders in single specialty centers earn $120,000 or more, compared to 82% of those in multispecialty centers. Both groups most commonly chose the range of $120,000 to $149,999 (30% of single specialty leaders and 42% of multispecialty leaders).

 

Span of control

ASC leaders’ increasing level of responsibility is reflected in the number of people they oversee. As noted earlier, respondents supervise an average of 40 full-time equivalent (FTE) positions, up from 32 in 2019, the year before the COVID-19 pandemic. This year, the average was 32 for clinical and 8 for nonclinical positions.

Many ASC leaders (44%) reported they did not know the amount of their operating budget. Of those who did know, most (14%) are responsible for an operating budget of $10 million to $14.9 million, closely followed by $5 million to $9.9 million and $3 million to $4.9 million (13% for each). As a comparison, in 2022, the most common range was $1 million to $1.9 million (13%), followed by $10 million to $14.9 million (12%).

Similar to 2022, nearly half (48% vs 47% last year) of respondents reported that their operating budget had increased in the past 12 months. Only 12% reported a decrease.

OR leaders who responded were asked how many ORs they managed, and they could choose from one to 10 or more. Most choose four ORs (26%), followed by two (23%). Overall, 79% of respondents oversee one to five ORs, which is comparable to last year’s 80%. Only 6% are responsible for 10 or more ORs.

 

Satisfaction outlook

Changes in satisfaction compared to 2022 mostly trended slightly downward. Drops in satisfaction were seen in total compensation (52% vs 55%), top leadership of the organization (58% vs 62%), support provided by the respondent’s boss (63% vs 70%), and physician engagement level (64% vs 71%).

On the other hand, satisfaction with staff engagement rose from 69% to 73%. As in previous years, respondents were most pleased with patient satisfaction with OR services (92% vs 88% in 2022).

Comparing these results to prepandemic (2019) satisfaction levels reveal some interesting patterns. For the most part, levels are relatively similar. For instance, job satisfaction was 74% in 2019, compared to 70% this year, and satisfaction with support provided by respondent’s boss was 62%, comparable to this year’s 63%. However, satisfaction with the organization’s top leadership was 63% in 2019, several percentage points higher than this year’s 58%. Patient satisfaction with OR services has risen from 72% in 2019 to 92% this year.

Nearly two-thirds (62% vs 58% in 2022) do not plan to leave their employer within the next year. Burnout and dissatisfaction with compensation and/or benefits topped the list of reasons for those who were planning to leave (22% and 21%, respectively; respondents could choose more than one option). Other common reasons were dissatisfaction with management (14%) or with the current work culture (13%).

Benefits can be a powerful retention tool, so we asked respondents to select from a list the benefits they would like to receive if they did not currently have them. Consistent with past years’ surveys, money-related benefits topped the list: profit sharing (35%), bonus (35%), tuition/education reimbursement (30%), and pension plan (26%). These are the same as the top four in 2022. Sixteen respondents provided other suggested benefits, including flexibility in work schedule, 4-day work week, remote workdays for administrative work, and health insurance for dependents.

 

About ASC leaders

Overall demographics are listed in the infographic (p 26). The average age of respondents was 51 years (vs 48 in 2022 and 51 in 2021). The average age of an RN is 46, according to The 2022 National Nursing Workforce Survey.

Most respondents (36%) chose administrator/administrative director as their title, and 31% chose nurse manager. These were followed by 27% for director/assistant director and 2% for vice president/chief nurse executive. No matter their title, ASC leaders are working hard. Most (39%) spend 46 to 50 hours a week at work, with another 28% reporting 41 to 45 hours; 8% spend 57 hours or more.

One fourth of respondents have 5 years or less of experience as a perioperative manager, compared to 29% in 2022. The results highlight the importance of succession planning, with 41% of respondents reporting 16 years or more of perioperative management experience. In addition, 26% plan to retire by 2028, a mere 5 years away.

Diversity remains limited among ASC leaders, with most respondents (86%) choosing White as their race or ethnicity. The next highest response was Asian (4%), followed by African American/Black (3%), and Hispanic/Latinx (1%). None chose American Indian/Alaska Native or Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific Islander.

Congruent with surveys in recent years, the baccalaureate degree in nursing is the highest degree held by ASC leader respondents (35% vs 32% in 2022 and 42% in 2021). More than one-fourth (27% vs 26% in 2022 and 20% in 2021) hold a master’s degree, and 17% hold an associate degree in nursing.

More than a third (36%) of respondents live in the Midwest, 28% in the South, 21% in the West, and 15% in the Northeast.

 

Dangerous waters ahead

We received 101 responses to the question, “What issue facing perioperative leaders do you feel isn’t getting enough attention?” Although staffing receives daily attention in the field, most respondents still identified it as an issue needing more, with many pointing to burnout and staffing shortages.

Additional comments from respondents included:

  • “Lack of pipeline of OR nurses, no opportunity to experience in nursing school, no clinical exposure.”
  • “The amount of time and resources that it takes to fully train perioperative staff is a drain on the financial system and on the experienced staff.”
  • “The new grads who have come out through COVID are not normal new grads. Many have not had sufficient clinical experience but are looking for fast track success. Many had options to take bonuses during COVID and feel their worth is more than tenured nurses who are burning out after training extremely inexperienced new grads.”
  • “The landscape of nursing is changing rapidly. Employees want more time off and flexible schedules. I don’t disagree but it is hard to staff for the fluctuating census that we have.”

Many respondents also noted challenges affecting nurse leaders more directly. Sample comments related to this leadership-focused issue included:

  • “Burnout is a real issue. I am struggling with my own mental health trying to balance ‘business as usual’ and assume the responsibilities of vacant positions, manage increased volumes, increased patient demand with reduced access, increased patient complaints r/t access, maintaining high dept. morale (especially working short staffed and increased case load).”
  • “Nurse leaders don’t have the ability to make big decisions for their staff. They are told how it will be and have to almost sell it to the staff. Hard to be the middleman without authority.”
  • “…[L]ack of support from upper leadership with regard to stopping excessive bookings outside of block.”
  • “Ancillary support staff to allow managers to work at the top of their license; scope of responsibility is large but span of control is narrow. Must follow up on many items that you don’t have control of but affects the day to day operations of your ASC.”
  • “There is a lack of leadership training for novice leaders.”

Other issues identified by respondents included supply chain and medication shortages, more regulations, and budget constraints.

One respondent summed up several of these issues: “Nursing shortage is VERY real. We need to think and act differently and adapt to [this] new reality. Financial component of nursing salaries needs to be removed from institutions and other avenues explored (ie, fee for service and reimbursement). Also, competition between hospital systems and free-standing centers is increasing. Nurse leaders need to have more control to incorporate innovative methods and collaborate with surgeons to change the present environment.”

 

Ongoing pressures

Although this year’s survey showed a slight increase in salary, the increase has failed to keep pace with inflation, leaving many ASC leaders inadequately compensated. This despite the fact that their span of control has increased, and they are facing enormous staffing pressures. In addition, many leaders will be retiring in the near future, creating a leadership gap. Although job satisfaction is still high, it remains to be seen how long this can be maintained given the current healthcare environment.

 

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.

 

Reference

Smiley R A, Allgeyer R L, Shobo Y, et al. The 2022 national nursing workforce survey. J Nurs Reg. 2023;14(1):S1-S90.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat