The healthcare industry as a whole has faced numerous and unprecedented challenges in the last few years. With each challenge compounded by external pressures, these proverbial spotlights illuminated existing vulnerabilities.
The healthcare workforce, particularly nursing, continues to be one of the most impactful vulnerabilities. With the pandemic acting as a pressure event, the US experienced the largest drop in nursing staff in a single year compared to any year in the previous 4 decades. Unlike the many industries that have since returned to prepandemic operations in terms of workforce capacity, the healthcare industry has continued to struggle to rebound.
Vacant nursing and technologist roles are not being filled quickly enough by new entrants to the workforce. Per the American Association of Colleges of Nursing, throughout the next decade, only 195,400 new nurses per year are projected to enter the workforce to cover the annual 203,200 growth of openings projected by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics.
For specialty areas such as the OR, additional external pressures apply to this workforce shortage. Rising surgical procedure volume and the shift to the ambulatory setting is making surgery more accessible and increasing demand. The lack of sufficient supply—nurses and technologists to staff surgical cases—is causing disruptions to standard operating hours and increasing variability in work schedules. Additionally, as operational leaders struggle to balance available OR time with the influx in volume, the surgical schedule is filling up faster, creating longer lead times for elective cases and potential delays to patient care.
Health systems’ effective response to these circumstances is critical not only for patient care, but also to keep levels of attrition at a manageable level. Reduced workforces, when not managed efficiently, can lead to continually increasing labor costs and even further reduced capacity to meet demands for patient care. The remaining members of those workforces, when forced to take on higher workloads or increased or unpredictable hours, experience burnout and cannot give satisfying levels of time and energy to their patients.
Motivated by first mover advantage, some health systems are opting to invest in their staff even in the face of a tough economic environment. This investment demonstrates a shift in incentives and diversifies offerings that will attract and retain team members in a variety of roles. One example is the Gundersen Health System Hospitals & Clinics, a health system with presence in Wisconsin, Minnesota, and Iowa, which began operating a career development center to focus on employee growth and development.
Other organizations are focused on strategic partnerships with higher education to act as feeder programs for nursing and technologist prospects. Another example is the University of Tennessee Health and Science Center College of Nursing, which announced plans to provide a dedicated program for perioperative nursing to improve the pipeline. Exposure to and training for the perioperative specialty prior to entering the workforce is intended to decrease the time new nursing graduates must spend in orientation or residency at hospitals, as well as help to increase retention rates of perioperative nurses.
While the investment in programs is encouraging and has the potential to yield long-term benefits, workforce challenges must also be solved on a more granular level, within the processes of actually assigning staff.
Scheduling and workforce management tools are often used to create OR staff schedules. However, these are typically created several weeks in advance without an understanding of the staff who will truly be needed based on the scheduled case types, specific nuances for those cases that impact staffing requirements, and skills and competencies of individual staff members.
Nurse managers are often pressured to be compliant with staff’s preferred work schedule when making staffing adjustments. This adds further complexity when addressing perioperative staff shortages, especially when laying on variables such as add-on cases and sick call-outs that can result in last minute efforts to get shifts covered. This often results in a day-of scramble to ensure the appropriate staff will be available so that day can run as planned, with staff needing to be called in at the last minute or with higher-cost incentive shifts.
Nurse managers or charge nurses must also assign specific OR nursing and tech staff to ORs for the day—a task that can become extremely time consuming and complex. Data that summarize staff experience and competencies are not always readily available or current, making it difficult to understand who is an appropriate choice for the specific cases or for the surgeons scheduled in a given OR.
Multiple factors are used to make the most appropriate assignments, including competencies in a specific team or specialty area, experience with equipment, training status of orientees, and case complexity that may require additional resources. Awareness of these often depends on tribal knowledge or manual, error prone record-keeping. While charge nurses do typically know their staff and for what they are most suited, this is yet another item for them to track and becomes much more challenging with a larger number of staff, new staff, or new charge nurses—increasing time to perform assignments and resulting in less-than-ideal placements.
Nurse managers thus must spend much of their day adjusting assignments, following up on breaks or relief assignments, and communicating with staff through multiple methods that still include paper and whiteboards to show transparency across perioperative and surgeoun staff. Managing staffing becomes almost a full-time job for charge nurses and nurse managers, which reduces their availability to help the surgical department run smoothly and proactively resolve potential issues.
Working within these constraints can lead to job dissatisfaction due to staff being uncomfortable with performing surgical procedures outside of their experience levels, not seeing opportunities to advance their own skills, or having to overtly rely on experienced staff. This, in turn, hampers their development and leads to overtime or mandated shifts to fill schedule holes.
As staffing leaders alongside educators look to provide orientees with a well-rounded orientation, staffing schedules and assignments have an added layer for which to account. Without the ability to evaluate training opportunities proactively, educators do not have visibility into cases that could help staff achieve their goals. The result is siloed orientation and training processes that take longer to produce cross-trained staff confident in supporting more procedures.
Technology can effectively replace routine, stressful tasks, leaving nurses to do more impactful work.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is emerging as a transformative technology in the healthcare space and shows tremendous potential for revolutionizing OR staffing. By applying AI-powered algorithms, predictive analytics, and automation, hospitals can optimize staff allocation, enhance data-driven decision making, and achieve new levels of OR efficiency.
Tools that display future staffing needs driven by predicted volumes can empower nurse managers and charge nurses to proactively evaluate schedule gaps by staff type that goes beyond default ratios. Machine learning continuously evaluates surgical case participants, cross-referencing future cases to inform recommendation of staffing needs. This directly helps staffing coordinators and nurse managers determine how future assignments will need to be adjusted through shift swaps by time or day of week, as well as on-call staff availability.
When looking to make case and room assignments, intelligent solutions synthesize relevant information in combination with recommendations to better optimize the available staff and capitalize on opportunities to build a broader talent pool. Recommendations offer staff competencies by procedure and working experience with surgeons. With this data readily available at the point of assignment, nursing managers can make informed decisions when assigning team members to complex cases, cases requiring specialized equipment, or when assigning relief.
Additionally, cross-training goals or orientee training gaps that are highlighted early aid in the execution of professional development to expand skill sets, such as identifying shadowing experience needed to satisfy speciality area rotations. AI can support a future state where surgical teams are precisely and intelligently composed with the needs of the staff and the needs of the OR in a fair balance.
In contrast to the long timeline to implement career development programs or strategic partnerships, technology provides a potential near-term solution to the staffing shortage by directly improving the daily operations that impact job satisfaction. Technology is also a relatively low-cost investment, of which return on investment—staff optimization and experience—is immediate.
As healthcare organizations continue to ideate and take action to address staffing shortages, leadership should invest in the teams upon which they are heavily dependent as part of their recruitment and retention strategy. Providing staffing leaders with diverse resources, including technology, can help to sustainably curb the staffing shortage and strike a better balance between supply and demand.
—Kimberly Hamilton, MPH, director, OR Product Operations at LeanTaaS, works across customer and product development teams to expand the perioperative services portfolio and deliver additional intrinsic value to clients. Stacey Leadbeater, senior product manager at LeanTaas, has over 15 years of experience in healthcare IT product development, spanning areas such as perioperative, clinical workflow applications, patient engagement tools, and revenue cycle.
Rosseter R. Nursing Shortage Fact Sheet. American Association of Colleges of Nursing. October 2022.