The pace of increased surgical volume has slowed, but continues to trend upward, according to the 2017 annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. The volume of surgical procedures in the past 12 months increased for 43% of respondents, the same as in 2015, but was down from the 51% reported last year.
Along with rising surgical volume, OR leaders continue to face staffing challenges, with 73% saying it’s harder to recruit experienced RNs compared with 12 months ago, similar to the 70% who reported this in 2016. And 47% say it’s harder to recruit surgical technologists (STs), the same percentage as last year.
Slight improvements in staffing levels have occurred: just 33% said open positions for RNs had increased, similar to the 32% level in 2016 and well below the 41% of respondents in 2016.
About a fourth (26%) reported that open positions for STs have increased, returning to near 2015 levels (28%) after rising to 39% last year.
Despite these glimmers of hope, survey findings show that OR leaders continue to have difficulty with recruiting and retaining experienced staff in a time of continued increased surgical volume at many organizations and an uncertain healthcare environment for all.
Other key findings of the survey include:
• The penetration of models of care and bundled payment is lower than expected. Less than a third of respondents said their hospitals have a perioperative surgical home (sidebar, p 13).
• 30% of respondents reported no open positions for RNs (vs 26% in 2016), and 38% had no open position for STs, slightly higher than the 32% reported last year.
• The percentage of respondents citing co-management agreements with surgeons dropped from 21% in 2016 to 12% this year, with community hospitals more likely than teaching hospitals to have these agreements.
Recruiting may be a challenge, but OR leaders are hiring. When asked how staffing had changed in the past year, about a third (34%) reported they had hired more direct care staff, although this is far lower than the 51% reported in 2016.
As was the case last year, teaching hospitals were much more likely than community hospitals to report hiring more staff (50% vs 25%, respectively).
At the same time, however, leaders are feeling the pinch of financial demands. In all, 31% have eliminated open positions (vs 22% in 2016), 43% have reduced overtime usage, 24% have required staff to take time off without pay (vs 16% in 2016), and 29% have decreased use of agency staff (vs 23% in 2016).
Interestingly, 22% increased the use of agency staff, similar to the 23% reported last year.
When it comes to open positions, the percentages for 2017 are remarkably stable compared with those for 2016: 46% for RNs (vs 45%) and 54% for STs (vs 48%).
About 38% had 1 to 3 RN positions open, with 14% reporting 5 to 9 and 4% reporting 10 to 14. In the case of STs, 45% had 1 to 3 ST positions open, with 9% reporting 5 or more.
The average staff turnover rate (defined as the percentage of staff who have left and been replaced in the past 12 months) was 9.7% for RNs and 8.2% for STs. Those rates are similar to the past 2 years.
More than a third (35%) reported that turnover rate for RNs had increased in the past 12 months, and 28% reported an increase for STs. These results are likely to make OR leaders yearn for 2014, when the percentage reporting an increase was 20% for RNs and 21% for STs.
Only 25% said recruitment of experienced RNs had not changed in the past 12 months, although 57% reported no change in recruiting new or inexperienced OR nurses. In all, 42% of respondents reported no change in recruiting STs.
“Difficult roads often lead to beautiful destinations.” The source of this quote isn’t known, but that doesn’t stop it from being meaningful to OR leaders. Certainly leaders must be on their way to especially beautiful locales, given they are walking roads fraught with difficulty. More than 175 of respondents shared what they viewed as their current challenges. Here is a representative sample of their comments.

Costs. Many respondents reported that cost containment as well as operating and capital budget issues posed significant challenges. Leaders often are expected to grow volume while reducing costs. Common solutions mentioned were adding new procedures, service lines, or surgeons.
Reimbursement. It’s not surprising that payment was top of mind for many respondents.
“We’ve seen an increase in Medicaid payer mix, which causes bills to be unpaid for longer periods of time than with private payers,” said one respondent. “This creates a situation where the bills are posted, but revenue is not coming in.”
Others cited the reduction in Medicare reimbursement. “Our reimbursement with Medicare has dropped 50%,” one leader said.
Staffing was a recurrent theme among comments, with one respondent summing up the biggest challenge as, “staffing, staffing, staffing.”
Recruitment. One respondent said, “There are not experienced OR RNs out there.” That might be overstating the situation, but clearly finding talent is difficult. Some respondents are training nurses who lack OR experience, but admit the process takes time.
Retention. The current healthcare environment makes it hard to retain staff. “Everyone is being asked to do more with less,” one respondent said. “We are asking people to change work schedules and still striving to keep or maximize engagement.”
Some respondents commented on the difficulty of having competitors in the marketplace who offer better pay. Many respondents are focused on strategies to improve engagement while maintaining productivity. One noted, “right-sizing our staffing models to meet the increased demands of volumes within our existing resources.”
Leadership. A few respondents mentioned they are struggling with succession planning and finding new leaders.
Daily operations are an important consideration for OR leaders.
Volume. Several respondents felt that increasing case volume was a significant business challenge, especially in a rural setting.
Standardization. Some respondents felt that standardizing supplies is one of their biggest hurdles, as they struggle to reduce costs. As one person commented: “Bring supplies under control and do a better job of inventory.”
Physical environment. A few respondents are facing construction projects, a challenge that might be welcomed by those in older facilities.
Several respondents mentioned concerns such as quality, patient satisfaction, and meeting regulatory and mandated program requirements.
Physician relations. “Changing a culture of doctors who run to administration with every problem” was a challenge noted by one respondent. A few respondents noted they’ve had trouble recruiting surgeons and anesthesiologists. This is particularly difficult for leaders seeking to expand service lines. A few respondents mentioned they were working on engaging physicians.
Technology. Keeping up with the latest technology, from both cost and training perspectives, is difficult for some respondents.
Most respondents (59%) work in community hospitals, and 31% call a teaching hospital their work home. The most common title was director (41%), followed by nurse manager (33%). About 11% held the title of administrator or administrative director. Watch for more information about respondents, including salary, job satisfaction, and certification, in the October issue of OR Manager. ✥