September 20, 2017

CMS proposes delay for mandatory implementation of OAS CAHPS Survey

By: Leslie Flowers
Share

Responding to industry concerns, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has proposed a delay in the mandatory implementation of the patient experience of care satisfaction survey requirement known as the Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems Outpatient and Ambulatory Surgery Survey® (OAS CAHPS). CMS announced the proposed delay in the July 20 Federal Register.

Implementation of the survey at ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) is voluntary until CMS announces further rulemaking. CMS designed the OAS CAHPS Survey to measure patient experience at Medicare-certified hospital outpatient departments (HOPDs) and ASCs. According to RTI International, the CMS contractor that developed the survey, the goal is to produce comparable data on the patient experience in both ASCs and HOPDs that:

• allow objective and meaningful comparisons between the two sites of service

• empower consumers to make more informed choices when choosing an HOPD or ASC

• encourage quality improvement initiatives in HOPDs and ASCs by publicly reporting survey results.

Development of the OAS CAHPS Survey has been underway since 2012. This is the first standardized survey instrument to assess patient experience with outpatient surgical care received at HOPDs and ASCs.

CMS originally planned to use the OAS CAHPS Survey data as the basis for five quality measures in its Ambulatory Surgical Center Quality Reporting Program, beginning with the calendar year 2020 payment determination, but this could change in the final rule.

Industry concerns

CMS initiated the voluntary national reporting program for the OAS CAHPS Survey in January 2016. Although the ASC community is highly supportive of quality reporting and patient experience surveys, industry members object to the OAS CAHPS Survey in its current form.

“We are pleased that this proposed survey will be required in both ASCs and HOPDs, which allows for an apples-to-apples comparison across the two outpatient settings so that patients can make a good judgment about which is the appropriate site of service in which to receive their care,” says Bill Prentice, chief executive officer of the Ambulatory Surgery Center Association (ASCA). “However, we want to ensure the survey instrument is as simple, straightforward, and low-cost as possible. Unfortunately, as originally proposed, the OAS CAHPS Survey falls well short of meeting those objectives.”

The ASC Quality Collaboration, which is made up of 19 private and not-for-profit ASC organizations, including ASCA, submitted its concerns to CMS on June 9, 2017. In summary, these concerns are:

• CMS and the Office of Management and Budget have significantly understated the survey costs to be borne by ASCs.

• The survey is too long and must be significantly shortened, focusing more on critical, actionable aspects of patient experience and essential demographic data.

• The survey modes do not take advantage of information technology, which increases costs unnecessarily.

• On-site survey distribution should be permitted to help keep provider costs as low as possible and enhance the collection of more timely and accurate patient responses.

• The minimum number (300) of surveys is too high and affects low-volume ASCs disproportionately.

 

Objections to survey length and mode

ASCA is advocating for a shorter survey and an electronic mode of response, such as email.

The OAS CAHPS Survey includes 37 questions: 24 on patient experience and 13 on patient demographics. ASCs may add 15 of their own survey questions, which could bring the survey to 52 questions. The survey queries patients about:

• Communication and care provided by healthcare providers and office staff

• Preparation for the surgery or procedure

• Postsurgical care coordination and patient-reported outcomes

• Overall rating of the ASC or HOPD

• Whether the patient would recommend the facility to family and friends.

“We strongly believe that, in each of these areas, the questions can be culled to make the survey shorter, easier, and more likely that patients will fill it out, while still collecting valuable data to improve the patient experience,” Prentice says.

“Since most ASCs have been using some kind of patient satisfaction survey that is much shorter, we believe there is a simpler way of doing this than asking 37 questions,” he explains.

Another significant concern is the mode of administering the survey. As proposed, CMS-approved survey vendors will administer the survey on behalf of HOPDs and ASCs by telephone interview, mailed surveys, or mail with telephone follow-up (mixed mode).

Prentice says CMS has objected to electronic surveys because of concerns that certain Medicare demographic groups may be less likely to use email than other groups, which could skew results.

“We have evidence, however, including from early voluntary adopters of the survey, that these concerns are overstated,” Prentice says. “We think that every age group, cohort, and demographic is as likely to use email as they are any other mode.

“We feel confident that this issue is getting serious recognition by the agency and that they will allow for an electronic mode like email.”

Voluntary participation

In January 2016, CMS implemented voluntary national participation and reporting for the OAS CAHPS Survey. CMS-approved survey vendors administer the survey on behalf of HOPDs and ASCs and submit the data to RTI International (sidebar right). A list of approved vendors is available at oascahps.org.

CMS had planned to publicly report survey results from voluntary participation on a CMS website beginning in 2018.

Bill Prentice

“Those centers that have already signed up with a vendor and have been engaged with this in the past year have received a lot of valuable information and found areas on which to improve and provide better care for patients,” Prentice says. “I would never say that money spent to measure how you’re doing and places where you can improve is money misspent.”

Lynne Tipton, MS, BSN, administrator at Glasgow Surgery Center in Newark, Delaware, agrees. Glasgow’s parent company, Regent Surgical Health, contracted with SPH Analytics (Alpharetta, Georgia), ASCA’s affinity-preferred vendor, to implement the OAS CAHPS Survey at its ASCs in fall 2016.

“We knew the survey was coming, and we decided to get in on the voluntary period to learn how to use it ahead of it being required,” Tipton says.

SPH Analytics receives about 25 responses monthly out of approximately 70 patient survey solicitations for Glasgow. Tipton says this is in line with the 30% to 40% response rate of other patient satisfaction surveys.

Although the OAS CAHPS Survey evaluates indicators similar to those of typical patient satisfaction surveys—facility, staff, communication, discharge, and recovery—Tipton says it has been helpful to look at quality and patient satisfaction from a different lens and to compare scores to national standards. Rather than a 1 to 5 scale, the OAS CAHPS Survey responses are evaluated as promoter (positive), passive (neutral), or detractor (negative).

Over several months, the data showed Glasgow needed improvements and modifications in its discharge instructions, specifically adding that symptoms of fever, redness, and swelling are signs of infection, Tipton says. The ASC quickly implemented changes to the discharge instructions.

“This was good feedback,” Tipton says.

On the downside, Tipton adds, the OAS CAHPS Survey is more costly and labor intensive to implement than standard patient satisfaction surveys. She also thinks the survey has too many questions, but her ASC will continue to participate voluntarily until the required implementation date is set.

“My advice to other ASCs is, if you haven’t already signed up with a vendor, you might want to wait until CMS announces a firm date of implementation, and then start using the survey,” Tipton says. “Since we have everything set up, I think we will continue on for now,” she notes. “The more good data we can get, the greater the benefit for all of us in the ambulatory surgical arena and in the industry as whole.”

Lynne Tipton, MS, BSN

Marisol Rivera, director of patient experience for SPH Analytics, says of its 1,300 ASC clients, 200 have voluntarily adopted the OAS CAHPS Survey.

“The greatest challenge for ASCs is onboarding their data,” Rivera says. “The CMS-required data file is cumbersome for many ASCs, especially those that are still manually charting and not using an electronic medical record with CPT codes. Usually our first month with an ASC is focused on data management. But once the survey is up and running, over a few months they begin to see their results.”

Rivera recommends OAS CAHPS participation during the voluntary period, so that ASCs and HOPDs can work through data management challenges and familiarize staff with survey protocols before mandatory implementation.

“The ASCs then have the opportunity to benchmark their results against hundreds of facilities, and implement changes to increase their scores before the required implementation and public reporting of their scores,” Rivera says.

 

Final rule timeline fast approaching

The public comment period for the proposed rule ended September 11, 2017, and the final rule will be published in November 2017. Prentice predicts that with the proposed delay in the OAS CAHPS Survey, the first possible mandatory date of implementation would be January 2019.

“We have a strong sense that the current administration in Health & Human Services has placed a higher priority on addressing regulatory burden than the prior administration,” Prentice says.

“We’ve seen that in a variety of different ways in the past few months, and we have pretty high confidence that the agency is truly interested in trying to do the right thing by creating a survey that works for patients and policymakers and doesn’t negatively impact ASCs and HOPDs. That said, it’s very unlikely that this delay will be permanent,” he adds.

CAHPS Surveys already are mandated for other Medicare providers—inpatient hospitals, home health, hospice, and dialysis centers.

“The likelihood that they leave ASCs and HOPDs out of this permanently is very low,” Prentice says.

“Mandating implementation in 2018 would be unreasonable, and I don’t think this administration is going to do something unreasonable to us and the hospitals,” he projects. ✥

 

Leslie Flowers is president of Flowers Communications.

 

Reference

Prentice, B. OAS CAHPS: Next Steps [Webinar]. August 22, 2017. Ambulatory Surgery Center Association 2017 Webinar Series.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat