October 28, 2015

Surveyors reveal how to get credit for credentialing

By: Paula DeJohn
Share

Credentialing of physicians and other independent practitioners is facing increased scrutiny from surveyors, professional associations and, in some cases, the public—not necessarily because of compliance failures but because healthcare legislation and technology improvements have made the process a conversation topic.

Thus it may be a good time to review the way ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) handle this function.

Are surgeons certified in their specialties? Are their state licenses up to date? Have there been any malpractice or other adverse reports since you last checked?

Even if you think you know the answers to such questions, state and federal laws require documentation showing periodic verification.

Physicians are responsible for maintaining and renewing their own credentials. Facilities where they practice are likewise responsible for ensuring that no one who is not properly credentialed practices there.

Hospitals generally have human resource departments with staff who are skilled at and dedicated to checking, documenting, and reporting compliance.

ASCs rarely have such luxury; the job is likely to be one of many duties for a nurse or administrator. They may rely on an outside consultant, but they are still responsible.

 

Serious business

“The credentialing and privileging process can never be a ‘wink and a nod,’” says Raymond Grundman, MSN, MPA, FNP-BC, CASC, vice president and general manager of ambulatory accreditation operations for the Accreditation Association for Ambulatory Health Care (AAAHC), Skokie, Illinois. “Properly done, it is the first step in your ASC’s risk management program and lays the groundwork for an emphasis on patient safety and quality of care.”

To illustrate his point, Grundman tells stories of people who have forged credentials and managed to be hired by hospitals and other organizations—even the FBI. “This is why we do credentialing,” he says. “Credentialing exists to protect our patients.”

The objective of credentialing, he explains, is to establish that someone has the specialized professional knowledge that the position requires.

On January 1, 2014, the Joint Commission issued an updated standard in its human resources category, HR 02.01.03, describing how to obtain and evaluate evidence of qualifications. (See www.jointcommission.org/assets.)

“This is the Joint Commission’s most challenging standard,” says Susan Herrold, MN, BSN, FNP-BC, a field representative with the Joint Commission’s ambulatory program.

Essentially, anyone who provides services without direction or supervision must have credentials as well as privileges to work at a specific facility. That means physicians and other specialists such as anesthesiologists, radiologists, nurse practitioners, contract workers who are not on staff, and possibly vendors.

 

How credentialing works

At an ASC, the ultimate responsibility for credentialing begins and ends with the governing board, which establishes minimum training and experience standards for medical staff. The standards, which may vary according to state law as well as ASC policy, are usually published in the medical staff bylaws.

Standards not only include criteria for appointment, renewal, and dismissal, but also specify a process for investigating and verifying qualifications. In addition to the standards, the governing board must establish a process for enforcing those standards, and then be able to demonstrate that staff follow the process.

When a surgeon, anesthesiologist, or other independent practitioner applies for medical staff privileges, evidence of appropriate competence must accompany the application. The medical director recommends approval or disapproval based on the results of the verification process conducted by human resources or other staff, with the governing board making the final decision. That is credentialing.

However, to actually perform procedures at an ASC, the applicant must complete another process: privileging. Is the applicant certified to perform all procedures offered by the ASC, or only certain specialties?

A “delineation of privileges,” as it is known, may authorize exact CPT codes or more general core privileges. In other words, regardless of credentials, privileges will be limited to activities performed at the ASC, and for which the applicant meets requirements set by the governing board.

Grundman uses the example of C-arms: An ASC could—and he recommends this—specify whether a physician must be able to operate the equipment, interpret the results, or both, because each action requires different skills.

 

Performing the biannual checkup

Nearly all states require review and recredentialing of physicians and dentists at least every 2 years.

In 1986, Congress established the National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB) in an effort to reduce fraud and malpractice and promote patient safety. The law requires each state and territory to report to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) actions taken against healthcare practitioners, healthcare organizations, and suppliers.

Such actions include revocation of licenses or certifications, or law enforcement actions. HHS must then release the information to a wide range of recipients, including healthcare organizations, accreditation organizations, professional associations, and licensing authorities.

Practitioners have the right to view their own NPDB files. For an overview of the scope of information and who is eligible to make queries, visit www.npdb.hrsa.gov/resources/tables/reportingQueryAccess.jsp.

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) adopted NPDB as the official reporting vehicle and merged it with the former Healthcare Integrity and Protection Data Bank (HIPDB), effective May 6, 2013.

Agencies must report changes in clinical privileges and medical malpractice payments to both NPDB and the relevant state licensing boards within 30 days of the action (see www.npdb.hrsa.gov/resources/MergerPresentation.pdf).

The NPDB is a big help, but it is not the only avenue of investigation. ASCs are expected to verify credentials by checking with primary sources, ie, people or organizations with direct knowledge of the practitioner’s qualifications. These include medical schools, professional organizations, and state licensing agencies.

According to Herrold, the Joint Commission is looking for direct contact with primary sources, such as documented telephone calls, direct mail correspondence, and secure emails. Primary sources can verify education, training, experience, and current competence, and provide letters of recommendation. A query to the NPDB is also considered a primary source.

Another source of validation is peer review. A professional peer or peer organization covering the same specialty as the applicant formally evaluates medical records and performance data on behalf of the ASC.

Peer review may also include subjective reports, Herrold says. “A peer recommendation reflects their perception of the applicant’s clinical practice, ability to work as part of a team, and ethical behavior,” she says.

There are secondary sources of verification as well, such as consulting firms that specialize in researching credentials. They often specialize in particular professions, such as surgeons or manufacturers’ representatives.

The Joint Commission recognizes them as credentials verification organizations (CVOs). For an ASC with a small staff, hiring a CVO may be the most practical way to track credentials. CVO verification is acceptable to the Joint Commission, Herrold notes.

A typical Joint Commission survey is conducted within an hour, Herrold says. The surveyor takes a sample of practitioner files to review. Among the most common deficiencies, she says, are

• not checking the necessary credentials

• not checking for timely license renewals

• not documenting site-specific privileges

• not including contracted providers (in addition to staff physicians).

 

New technology emerges

Miles Beckett, MD

Miles Beckett, MD

Miles Beckett, MD, was a plastic surgeon in Los Angeles when he noticed how healthcare technology lagged other fields. He recalls, “At the hospital where I completed my surgery internship, the emergency room, intensive care unit, and patient floors all used different information technology systems. When a patient was transferred from one department to another, none of their labs, vitals, or other critical information would go with them. Information was being lost and patients were dying, literally.”

In a career change, he began working on video and software projects. The latest result is an electronic credentialing system called Silversheet, designed specifically for ASCs.

“Credentialing for doctors involves collecting and verifying documents, and renewal of current licenses, which expire every 1 or 2 years. It’s pretty overwhelming,” Dr Beckett explains.

Physicians are responsible for maintaining their credentials, he notes, but administrators are responsible for ensuring that those allowed to practice in the facility are properly credentialed. “The administrator has to keep after the doctors,” he says.

In his practice, Dr Beckett found that surgery centers had mostly paper files, which were time consuming to locate and review.

Silversheet uses the Internet to access the NPDB as well as databases of the Drug Enforcement Agency and states. An ASC can enter a physician’s national provider identifier and download relevant files on applicants and current practitioners.

For $99 per month, Dr Beckett says, an ASC can track up to 50 physicians and either print the documents or store them electronically.

When Silversheet was released in May 2015, about 50 surgery centers were using it in a pilot program. As of early July, about 100 had subscribed.

“There is other software, but most of it is intimidating,” he notes. “I wanted this to have a Turbo-Tax feel.” To demonstrate, he calls up physician files using a smartphone.

 

Next: Vendor credentials

Until now, vendors working in ASCs have been exempt from credentialing requirements, but that may soon change.

Nearly all hospitals—90% to 95%—require vendor credentialing, according to Rhett Suhre, co-chair of the Coalition for Best Practices in Health Care Industry Representative (HCIR) Requirements.

“ASCs could learn from the problems of hospitals,” Suhre says. Because there is no national standard, vendors must often obtain multiple background checks and file different documents with hospitals they do business with.

“The credentialing process that is in place today does not catch the bad guys,” Suhre says.

In an effort to create more fair and consistent rules, the coalition and AdvaMed, a medical device manufacturers association, are working with the Ambulatory Surgery Center Association (ASCA) to develop and test alternative credentialing methods.

Vendor representatives routinely visit healthcare facilities to sell products. In certain specialties, notably orthopedics, they may assist in the use of complex devices during a procedure. They may be long-term members of the surgical team or brand new.

During the past decade, hospital risk managers have led the way in convincing hospitals to establish better control over vendor access. Joining them have been materials managers concerned about representatives attempting to bypass purchasing contracts and work directly with physicians and OR nurses concerned about patient safety implications due to lack of a vendor credentialing policy. The turning point came in the early 2000s, when hospital security personnel began to push for tighter controls.

As policies proliferated, however, vendors complained of burdensome, redundant paperwork. Third-party credentialing services appeared to perform background checks, but there were no overall standards such as those that apply to physicians.

Among organizations calling for national standards were AdvaMed, AORN, the Medical Device Manufacturers Association (MDMA), and the Health Industry Representative Association (HIRA). In March 2009, AORN issued guidelines for vendor access that included the following:

• vendors should not give patient care or be in the sterile field

• vendors should be allowed in the OR to calibrate or adjust their products

• patients should be informed when a vendor representative is present

• hospital policies should incorporate the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act.

Because there are no licensing rules for vendors, AORN, MDMA, AdvaMed, and HIRA proposed a list of suggested requirements, including:

• proof of vaccinations

• proof of insurance

• criminal background check

• completion of training in the hospital’s policies.

Meanwhile, the American College of Surgeons (ACS) has had a detailed policy in place since 2000 (revised in 2005) that mentions ASCs as well as hospitals. It acknowledges that HCIRs “by virtue of their training, knowledge, and expertise, can provide technical assistance to the surgical team.” Echoing the AORN guidelines, the ACS says credentials should be time-limited and vendors in the OR should be supervised by surgeons or nurses. ✥

 

References

American College of Surgeons. Statement on Health Care Industry Representatives in the Operating Room. Bulletin of the American College of Surgeons. Published online May 1, 2000.

DeJohn P. Rules for OR reps. Materials Management in Health Care. 2009(9):16-20.

Grundman R, Herrold S. Proper credentialing and privileging as a risk management process. ASCA Conference, 2015.

Suhre R. Best practices in vendor credentialing/vendor access. ASCA Conference, 2015.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat