Implementation of crew resource management training at a large academic medical center led to statistically significant improvements in 10 out of 12 dimensions of safety culture, according to surveys conducted before and after training took place.
Crew resource management (CRM) is a systematic approach adapted from the airline industry to help train teams in interpersonal communication, leadership, and decision-making practices. Previous research has linked CRM with improved safety at individual hospitals, but researchers wanted to examine its impact on a multihospital system.
Using the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Hospital Survey on Patient Safety Culture (HSOPS), they gauged the impact of using CRM at the Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, which includes six hospitals and two campuses. The survey looked at 12 dimensions of safety culture:
• teamwork within units
• supervisor expectations/actions
• promoting patient safety
• organizational learning
• management support for patient safety
• overall perceptions of patient safety
• feedback and communication about error
• communication openness
• frequency of events reported
• teamwork across units
• staffing, handoffs, and transitions
• nonpunitive response to errors.
CRM training consisted of facilitated retreats focusing on safety tools such as checklists, standard protocols, and communication, and training internal facilitators, risk assessors, and a steering committee to monitor adoption and compliance of safety tool use.
Across departments, a total of 784 and 667 employees, respectively, completed the HSOPS before and after CRM training for a response rate of slightly more than 50%. A statistically significant increase in the post CRM composite score was found for 10 of the 12 HSOPS dimensions ( P <.05), according to the authors.
Domains with the most consistently positive score increases after CRM training were organizational learning, overall perceptions of patient safety, feedback and communication about error, and communication openness. Those with the fewest statistically significant positive changes in scores were staffing, supervisor expectations/actions, and management support for patient safety.
“These findings indicate that the teamwork and communication dimensions of patient safety culture may be more highly influenced by CRM training than supervisor and management factors,” the authors say.
They attribute the improved safety scores to the dedicated time for training, staff development of unit-specific safety tools, and creation of a systemwide steering committee.
The ultimate success of a large-scale program of patient safety culture transformation depends on leadership engagement and measurement of the program’s effectiveness, which includes giving feedback to frontline teams, the authors conclude. ✥
—Elizabeth Wood
Hefner J L, Hilligoss B, Knupp A, et al. Cultural transformation after implementation of Crew Resource Management: Is it really possible? Am J Med Qual. Published online July 15, 2016.