It is easy to overlook the sizable effort required to ensure that instrumentation and supplies are available to surgeons in the OR when needed, in the right amount, and in the right condition. Though sterile processing may not be the most glamorous element of a hospital or surgery center, it is certainly a crucial one. The relative success of any surgical facility lies squarely in the effectiveness and efficiency of the sterile processing department (SPD).
Planning, designing, and constructing a space to house such an operation is challenging and oftentimes overwhelming. Frequently, regard for the department is oversimplified, or even overlooked, when compared to the clinical areas it supports.
When designing new facilities or renovating existing ones, the design team has a unique opportunity to make physical and operational changes that can improve the function of the SPD and thus the delivery of surgical care.
Taking advantage of such an opportunity requires considering an approach that combines traditional industrial engineering concepts with contemporary healthcare trends. It involves just three steps: adopt systems thinking, quantify design criteria, and operationalize the plan.
Executing these steps ensures the long-term success of a sterile processing system—one that is capable of efficient operations in an appropriately sized footprint.
The concept of systems thinking originated in the early 20th century within the fields of biology, engineering, and the social sciences. Peter Senge, an American systems scientist who wrote the influential book The Fifth Discipline, defines systems thinking as “…a way of thinking about, and a language for describing, the forces and interrelationships that shape the behavior of systems.”
Systems thinking is not simply examining the “bigger picture.” It involves deep understanding of the interactions and relationships between elements of the bigger picture.
Systems thinking fundamentally differs from traditional forms of analysis. Traditional analysis focuses on separating the elements of a system and studying each one individually (in fact, the origin of the word “analysis” means “to loosen up” or “break apart”). A systems thinking approach considers how the elements being studied interact with other elements of the system.
Systems thinkers focus on interactions and relationships between processes and operations. This focus makes a systems thinking approach extremely effective when solving complex, multilayer problems, such as designing, planning, and constructing a SPD.
A systems thinker asks questions such as:
• How does instrument washing capacity affect the throughput of manual assembly operations or of the required sterilizer capacity?
• How will the route of sterile instrumentation on the surgical floor determine the optimal location of the decontamination area?
• How does cart washing capacity affect the amount of staging space required in the decontamination area or in the sterile storage area?
Matters concerning processing capacity, flow of materials, and staging requirements are often addressed individually throughout the design process. However, an optimal solution can only be derived when considering the system as a whole, to include the interactions and relationships between each element.
Systems thinking allows for efficient allocation of space, Lean operations, cost-effective equipment plans, and ultimately a SPD capable of performing at a high level.
Prior to kicking off a design or procurement project, it is crucial that all involved can accurately describe and quantify the flow of clean and soiled materials, as well as the methods used to process and transport them, through the SPD to the point of care.
The complex, highly specialized nature of sterile processing operations makes them inherently hard to describe and measure. However, quantifiable design criteria are one way to understand the relative function, or dysfunction, of a department and design for optimal efficiency and effectiveness.
In many cases, quantifiable data allow decision makers to more quickly and easily identify the relationships and interactions between system elements. When such data are combined with a systems thinking approach, trends can be spotted quickly, the meaning behind operational methods can be uncovered, and the relationship between process, function, and space can be easily understood.
Quantifiable design criteria start with quantitative, as well as qualitative, data. Both data types play a crucial role. Generally, quantitative data describe the “what” (volume, magnitude) and qualitative data describe the “how” (methodology, process).
Interviews with technicians, nurses, and surgeons are a great source of qualitative data such as the flow of sterile and soiled material, the use of materials and instrumentation, and methods used to manage emergent cases. After collecting qualitative data, the design team should have a thorough understanding of features such as:
• location and distribution of demand points (building, floor, etc)
• type of demand generated at each demand point (OR vs procedure room vs clinic)
• horizontal and vertical route taken to each demand point (corridors and elevators)
• timing of service to each demand point (am, pm, 24/7)
• operational methodology used to serve each demand point (case cart, bulk delivery, exchange, replenish to par levels, etc).
Surgical case history and doctor preference cards are a great source of quantitative data such as daily cases per OR, trays per case, and mix of cases by service or specialty.
Applying quantitative tools such as modeling, simulation, and applied statistics to quantitative data allows stakeholders to derive design criteria that encapsulate unique processes, methodologies, and environmental factors for their organization rather than a generic benchmark.
Design criteria can include, but are not limited to:
• soiled instrument trays returning per hour
• case carts movements by hour
• sterilization demand by hour by method
• FTE (full-time equivalent) requirements
• sterile tray demand by room type by hour.
Tools like modeling and simulation allow designers to modify operational methods and physical layout of the SPD to inform planning and programming decisions and ensure optimal function before any money is spent on construction.
For instance, calculating the number of case carts required to serve a surgical suite each day allows for right-sizing of the case cart staging area within the SPD. In turn, this right-size design ensures optimal function and the efficient use of space.
Processing soiled instrumentation for reuse involves an array of specialized equipment, including washer/disinfectors and sterilizers as well as manual cleaning and assembly. When designing the SPD, it is essential to balance the processing capacity, whether human or machine, with cost and space.
Traditional analysis would suggest the design team consider the input and output of each processing element (eg, instrument washer or assembly station) individually to plan and size the department. However, a systems thinking approach encourages a closer examination of the relationships and interactions between each process.
Consider each process or piece of processing equipment as a valve that allows materials, in this case surgical instruments, to flow from state to state (clean/soiled, assembled/unassembled).
Opening or closing one valve directly affects flow through the others, as well as the amount of space necessary to hold excess flow until it reaches the next valve in the system. The total capacity of each process should be determined only when considering its impact on the entire system.
For example, if it is determined that three instrument washers are required to mechanically clean incoming soiled instrumentation, then the design team must consider the throughput of the washers when determining the number of assembly workstations required.
If capacity to assemble instrument kits is less than the throughput of the washers, the team must plan the appropriate staging space for clean instruments to queue before assembly (backlog).
The design team must balance capacity requirements, equipment cost, and allowable backlog in order to optimally design the SPD.
In some cases, backlog is acceptable and results in major cost savings, but in other situations backlog is a major cost in terms of the space required to house it. Employing a systems thinking approach and quantifying the design criteria allows the equipment, space, and labor plan to be optimized—often resulting in cost reduction and a right-sized department.
Undoubtedly, the design team will face a multitude of challenges (cost, footprint, etc) during the design and procurement process. Luckily, most challenges can be overcome through thoughtful operations. In general, design constraints can be mitigated by considering three operational variables:
• equipment capacity—how much can I process?
• staffing plan—how many hours can I process?
• inventory profile—how quickly must I process?
For example, if capital cost constraints prohibit the purchase of additional equipment (capacity), then the resulting constraints can be dealt with by either adding staff (increasing equipment utilization by adding processing hours) or by adding inventory (increasing instrument inventory to relieve the need to quickly turnover kits).
If labor costs must be limited, adding equipment and/or adding inventory can again provide relief and ensure efficient operations. Adjusting these variables may not always be the solution, but doing so often alleviates some aspect of challenges faced during design.
Balancing operational variables with thoughtful design is a crucial step toward designing an efficient and effective sterile processing system. Designing with this balance in mind and incorporating a systems approach with quantifiable data can lead to a truly superior system.
In healthcare facilities whose leaders are willing to think differently and take three steps forward, it’s possible to create a sterile processing system capable of delivering world-class, affordable, patient-centered care. ✥
Derrick Bransby is a project engineer at St. Onge Company (www.stonge.com) York, Pennsylvania. He specializes in applied industrial engineering within healthcare systems. His focus remains on designing support systems and supply chains with an eye toward efficiency and quality. He has worked with Johns Hopkins Medicine, Duke University Medical Center, and Boston Children’s Hospital. He received his BS in industrial engineering from the University of Pittsburgh.
Aronson D. (1996). Overview of systems thinking. http://www.thinking.net/Systems_Thinking/OverviewSTarticle.pdf.
Senge P M. The fifth discipline fieldbook: Strategies and tools for building a learning organization. 1994. New York: Doubleday/Currency.