April 1, 2010

Tips for leading a practice change

By: OR Manager
Share

A new study provides strong evidence that surgical skin prep with chlorhexidine gluconate (CHG)-alcohol is superior to povidone-iodine scrub in preventing surgical site infections (related article).

What if most of the surgeons in your OR use povidone-iodine? How can you introduce the new evidence to the surgeons and convince them to consider a change?

New England Baptist Hospital in Boston, which performs 10,000 procedures a year for a complex caseload, made the change in 2007.

“Implementing such a change in an orthopedic hospital is no small feat,” says Maureen Spencer, RN, MEd, CIC, the infection control manager, who notes the conversion took about 5 months. At the time, surgeons were using either povidone-iodine scrub and paint or povidone-iodine-alcohol. Spencer shared her tips about making the change.

Start with the evidence

Spencer started by presenting the evidence to the surgeons. A 2007 review in the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery graded the evidence on infection prevention for orthopedic surgery and found the “literature strongly suggests that chlorhexidine gluconate is superior to povidone-iodine for preoperative antisepsis for patients.”

Spencer showed the surgeons the review and discussed with them the conclusions, references, and recommendations.

The discussion was part of an infection prevention effort in surgical services to move to a “chlorhexidine platform,” including the following:

  • All patients would take preoperative showers with 4% CHG (Hibiclens) 2 days before and the morning of surgery.
  • For skin prep in the OR, 2% CHG and 70% isopropyl alcohol (ChloraPrep) would be used.
  • Antimicrobial dressings would be applied postoperatively.

“We didn’t anticipate what we were going to be up against when we introduced the change in skin preparation,” Spencer notes. “The orthopedic surgeons had always used iodine and saw no reason to use anything different.”

To become better acquainted with the orthopedic surgeons, Spencer had already begun attending their monthly staff meetings. At first, she says the surgeons were skeptical about her attendance but now regard her as a colleague and peer.

Have infection prevention support

Having infection prevention support in surgical services is essential, notes Spencer, adding that a perioperative department as large as New England Baptist’s could use a dedicated infection preventionist.

She has been assigned 2 perioperative staff nurses—1 for the total joint service and 1 for spinal surgery—to help implement new initiatives. “It’s great because they know the surgeons and the staff. They also can get the information to me quickly if there’s a problem.”

Spencer adds, “I have been able to show the administration how important it is to integrate infection control into the OR and into surgical practice.”

The evidence plus administrative support are what win the day with new infection prevention initiatives, she notes.

Draw on company expertise

Spencer called on support from company representatives and clinical consultants to assist with the skin-prep product conversion. One key was to have a nurse specialist from the company with a background in critical care nursing and infection control on hand in the OR for 3 weeks. Spencer also spent more than a week in the OR herself, reassuring the staff and addressing surgeon concerns.

“You need to take at least 6 months to a year to implement a change in surgeons’ practice,” Spencer advises. “You have to keep working at it and have consistent follow-up. I have infection control issues on their staff agenda every month.”

Address surgeon concerns

One concern the surgeons had with making the change was that the iodophor-impregnated incise drape wouldn’t stick to the skin after ChloraPrep was applied. The iodophor products they had been using had a polymer that helped the barrier drape adhere to the skin.

The problem was addressed by allowing the ChloraPrep to dry for a minimum of 3 minutes. Then after applying the incise drape, the surgeon or nurse would rub a sterile towel on the adhesive drape to warm up the adhesive. “They were then able to get a nice adhesion, and it made the change much easier to implement,” Spencer says.

She estimates that 70% to 80% of the surgeons at New England Baptist now use the CHG-alcohol prep, and it is used for all total joint procedures. Some neurosurgeons will not switch because of a warning on the ChloraPrep label that it should not have contact with the meninges.

Some orthopedic surgeons take extra measures, Spencer notes. A couple scrub and paint with povidone-iodine and then use ChloraPrep. “We are fine with that. It is not that much more expensive, even though it is probably a waste of product,” she says.

She says the hospital has not seen a difference in its surgical site infection rates since the change to CHG-alcohol more than 2 years ago. The overall orthopedic infection rate was already low at 0.4% in 2007 before the CHG platform was introduced; it is now at 0.2%. The infection rate fell from 0.7% to 0.2% in 6 years following a variety of infection prevention initiatives.

–Judith M. Mathias, RN, MA

References

Darouiche R O, Wall M J, Itani K M F, et al. Chlorhexidine-alcohol versus povidone-iodine for surgical-site antisepsis. N Engl J Med. Jan 7, 2010;362:18-26.

Fletcher N, Sofianos D, Berkes M B, et al. Prevention of perioperative infection. J Bone Joint Surg. 2007; 89:1605-1618.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat