Each year, advances in medical technologies offer new ways to improve the quality of patient care. But some also create new opportunities for harm. Medical technology is intended to improve patient care, but even the best of technology—if configured, used, or maintained improperly—can lead to problems. Hospitals must regularly examine their hazard control priorities in order to remain focused on the most pressing risks.
ECRI Institute’s newly released Top 10 Health Technology Hazards is a comprehensive report published annually to raise awareness of the potential dangers associated with the use of medical devices and systems. When prioritizing your 2017 patient safety efforts, this is a smart place to start. The guidance that accompanies the list provides practical strategies for reducing the risks, making the report a practical tool for both establishing priorities and enacting solutions.
“Technology safety can often be overlooked when hospital leaders are dealing with so many other issues,” says David T. Jamison, executive director of ECRI’s Health Devices Group, which produces the report. “As an independent medical device testing laboratory and investigator of technology-related incidents, we know what can go wrong and what steps hospitals can take to reduce patient harm related to specific technologies and processes.”
The following excerpt from ECRI Institute’s report describes the 10 hazards on the 2017 list.
1. Infusion errors can be deadly if simple safety steps are overlooked
Most large-volume infusion pumps incorporate safety mechanisms for reducing the risks of potentially deadly intravenous (IV) infusion errors. These mechanisms have greatly improved infusion safety, but can’t eliminate all potential errors. And the mechanisms themselves have been known to fail.
ECRI Institute continues to learn about and investigate incidents of infusion errors involving pump or administration set failures, staff unknowingly defeating a safety mechanism, or incorrect infusion programming. Such errors—particularly those that result in the uncontrolled flow of medication to the patient, known as “IV free flow”—can lead to patient harm and even death.
Simple safety steps that can help prevent harm are now often overlooked—perhaps because staff implicitly trust the pump’s advanced safety features.
2. Inadequate cleaning of complex reusable instruments can lead to infections
The use of contaminated medical instruments can lead to disabling or deadly patient infections or instrument malfunctions.
Outbreaks associated with the use of contaminated duodenoscopes—such as those that caused headlines in recent years—illustrate the severity of this issue.
But duodenoscopes are not the only devices that warrant attention. ECRI Institute has received reports involving a variety of contaminated medical instruments that have been used, or almost used, on patients.
Complex, reusable instruments—such as endoscopes, cannulated drills, and arthroscopic shavers—are of particular concern. They can be difficult to clean and then disinfect or sterilize (ie, reprocess) between uses, and the presence of any lingering contamination on, or in, the instrument can be difficult to detect.
3. Missed ventilator alarms can lead to patient harm
Ventilator alarm management challenges complicate efforts to prevent patient harm resulting from missed alarms. Ventilators deliver life-sustaining therapy, and a missed alarm could be deadly. Concerns include:
• Alarm fatigue—in which staff become overwhelmed by, distracted by, or desensitized to the number of alarms that activate.
• Alarm notification failures—in which alarms are not effectively communicated to staff.
These concerns, and the ways to manage them, are similar to those that exist with physiologic monitoring systems, which ECRI Institute has addressed in previous Top 10 Health Technology Hazards lists. Ventilators, however, pose some unique challenges, and thus will require different methods for studying the problem and different strategies for addressing it.
4. Undetected opioid-induced respiratory depression
Patients receiving opioids—such as morphine, hydromorphone, or fentanyl—are at risk for drug-induced respiratory depression. If not detected, this condition can quickly lead to anoxic brain injury or death. Thus, spot checks every few hours of a patient’s oxygenation and ventilation are inadequate.
Drug-induced respiratory depression is of particular concern for patients receiving parenteral and neuraxial opioids in medical-surgical and general care areas. However, it is also of concern for hospital or ambulatory surgery/endoscopy facility patients receiving opioids during procedural sedation and while in the postanesthesia care unit.
5. Infection risks with heater-cooler devices used in cardiothoracic surgery
Heater-cooler systems have been identified as a potential source of nontuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) infections in heart surgery. The likelihood of infection during surgery is not fully understood. However, these infections can be life-threatening and have resulted in patient deaths.
Heater-cooler systems are used in cardiothoracic surgeries to warm or cool the patient by extracorporeal heat exchange with the patient’s blood during heart-lung bypass procedures. These devices circulate warm or cold water through a closed circuit. Water in the circuit is not intended to come into direct contact with the patient or the patient’s circulating blood. However, aerosolized water carried by air from the exhaust vents of contaminated heater-coolers has been suggested as a cause of NTM infections.
Initial reports focused on one specific model of heater-cooler, but models from other suppliers could likewise become contaminated under certain circumstances and if appropriate precautions are not taken.
6. Software management gaps put patients and patient data at risk
Inadequate medical device software management can delay a facility’s responses to safety alerts, allow cybersecurity vulnerabilities to be exploited, and impact patient safety.
Maintaining a central repository of up-to-date and easily retrievable information about the software versions used in a healthcare facility’s medical devices is challenging. But failure to do so leaves the facility ill prepared to effectively manage software updates and alerts—including those that address safety concerns.
Mismanagement of software updates and alerts can adversely affect patient care or impact patient and staff safety.
7. Occupational radiation hazards in hybrid ORs
Clinicians working in hybrid ORs—operating suites that include built-in x-ray imaging systems—are at risk of unnecessary occupational exposures to ionizing radiation if appropriate precautions are not consistently followed.
Particular concern exists in this environment because hybrid OR staff may be less knowledgeable than radiology and interventional radiology staff about the risks of radiation exposure, and they may be less experienced at taking appropriate precautions.
In addition, with the increasing reliance on x-ray imaging systems during complex OR procedures, an increasing number of specialists and staff members who previously would have had little exposure to ionizing radiation during surgeries are now participating in these procedures.
8. Automated dispensing cabinet setup and use errors may cause medication mishaps
Poor choices made when setting up automated dispensing cabinets (ADCs), as well as mistakes made during use, can lead to harmful medication errors.
Medication errors and near misses associated with ADCs have been traced to insufficient planning when setting up medication drawers, as well as errors made when stocking them. Incidents reported to ECRI Institute include: the presence of the wrong drug or dose in an ADC pocket, the availability of high-alert drugs in unsecured areas of the cabinet, and the unavailability of needed drugs.
Problems such as these have resulted in delays in patient care and the administration of incorrect drugs or drug concentrations, leading in some cases to severe patient injury.
9. Surgical stapler misuse and malfunctions
Surgical staplers require meticulous technique to operate, and problems during use are not uncommon. The US Food and Drug Administration receives thousands of adverse event reports related to surgical staplers each year, and ECRI Institute likewise consistently receives reports of surgical stapler problems. Although severe injuries are infrequent, they do occur: We have investigated fatalities and other cases of serious patient harm.
Commonly reported problems include: misfiring or difficulty in firing, misapplied staples, unusual sounds during firing (which can indicate a damaged or malfunctioning mechanism), and tissue becoming jammed in the mechanism.
10. Device failures caused by cleaning products and practices
The use of cleaning agents or cleaning practices that are incompatible with the materials used in a medical device’s construction, or that are otherwise inappropriate for the device’s design, can cause the device to malfunction or to fail prematurely, possibly affecting patient care. Specifically:
• Repeated use of incompatible cleaning agents can damage equipment surfaces and degrade plastics, often resulting in device breakage—possibly with no visible warning signs.
• The use of improper cleaning practices can damage seals, degrade lubricants, and cause fluid intrusion. This can result in damage to electronics, power supplies, and motors. ✥
1. Infusion errors can be deadly if simple safety steps are overlooked
2. Inadequate cleaning of complex reusable instruments can lead to infections
3. Missed ventilator alarms can lead to patient harm
4. Undetected opioid-induced respiratory depression
5. Infection risks with heater-cooler devices used in cardiothoracic surgery
6. Software management gaps put patients and patient data at risk
7. Occupational radiation hazards in hybrid ORs
8. Automated dispensing cabinet setup and use errors may cause medication mishaps
9. Surgical stapler misuse and malfunctions
10. Device failures caused by cleaning products and practices