An ambulatory surgery center (ASC) looking to expand its market may want to add new procedures, but only after careful consideration of resource investment versus ultimate benefit. In the first of a three-part series, OR Manager explores surgical specialties that appear to show promise for the outpatient setting.
One of these is women’s health. Adoption of gynecology, however, has been slow for many reasons—notably because opportunities for surgical training and experience are scarce, and Medicare reimbursement for gynecologic procedures is low.
On the plus side, the patient population is likely to use higher-paying private insurance rather than Medicare, and ASCs are beginning to explore innovative ways to bring together the best physicians and most eligible patients.
According to Richard Rosenfield, MD, founder and medical director of Pearl Surgicenter in Portland, Oregon, the next big thing in ASC specialties is likely to be laparoscopic hysterectomies. The procedure has been proven safe, even for women with large uteri or large uterine fibroid tumors.
“Innovation has not only improved the technology,” Dr Rosenfield says, “but we can do laparoscopic hysterectomies more efficiently and at lower cost than hospitals.”
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) has not always seen it that way, however. Many laparoscopic procedures considered to be complex are not reimbursable by Medicare, including removal of uteri larger than 250 g.
Dr Rosenfield tracked outcomes for 502 laparoscopic hysterectomies during a 5-year period ending in 2010. There were 21 adverse events, 18 of which required hospitalization. This is a 4.2% complication rate, far below the national average, he says. There were no mortalities or long-term complications.
Other studies confirm that conclusion: In 2009, the Review of Obstetric Gynecology noted that “vaginal and laparoscopic hysterectomies have been clearly associated with decreased blood loss, shorter hospital stays, speedier return to normal activities, and fewer abdominal wall infections.”
At Georgia Advanced Surgery Center for Women in Cartersville, Georgia, three surgeons perform about 200 hysterectomies each year, as well as many other gynecologic procedures.
According to medical director Hugo Ribot MD, FACOG, a case takes 60 minutes to 90 minutes, and an efficient surgeon can do three or four per day. In January 2006, he began routinely performing both vaginal and laparoscopic hysterectomies with same-day discharge. His two fellow surgeons joined the practice in 2008 and 2012 and adopted the outpatient protocol. He tracked the outcomes of all their hysterectomies through December 2015, a 10-year period. “Of a total of 1,582 cases, 98.6% went home with no complications,” he recalls.
Since 2010, 641 outpatient cases have been performed at the ASC, with no hospital transfers or inpatient admissions. Rates of complications, readmissions, and reoperation remain far below national averages, Dr Ribot says.
OB/GYN is unique as a surgical specialty in that most of its practitioners rarely perform surgery. “They’re doing a lot more of something else,” Dr Rosenfield says. For many, the focus is on pregnancy and maternity care.
About 400,000 hysterectomies are performed each year in the US, but the average volume for a given gynecologist is about 10, Dr Rosenfield estimates, and that is nowhere near enough to gain expertise and confidence. “The biggest cost driver in surgery is complications. Doctors who do more surgery are better at it,” he says.
ASCs are about the least likely venues to gain experience right now; nationally, only 1% of ASC cases are in gynecology, he adds.
Overall, the number of hysterectomies in the US has decreased from a high of about 600,000 in 2008. According to Dr Ribot, the decrease is attributable to hysterectomy alternatives such as endometrial ablation, progesterone-releasing IUDs, and uterine fibroid embolization. “However, there are many conditions for which minimally invasive outpatient hysterectomy remains the best and only definitive treatment,” he says.
In Portland, the Pearl Surgicenter’s experience attracted the attention of a local self-insured company, and Pearl became its provider of gynecologic surgical services for women employees. In other geographic areas, a scarcity of expert surgeons can make it difficult for independent ASCs to add gynecology as a specialty.
Dr Rosenfield became an advocate for ASC-based hysterectomies and looked for ways to serve a wider market. In 2013 he founded Pearl Health Partners (PHP) to help other ASCs find qualified specialists. The group is affiliated with ASCs in five additional states: Illinois, Georgia, Texas, Minnesota, and New York. Among the self-insured companies contracted with PHP are Target, Albertson’s, and State Farm Insurance.
For ASCs considering adding the specialty, PHP can find and evaluate surgeons in its local area. It helps recruit those with high volume, good outcomes, and a willingness to work in ASCs.
For surgeons seeking to improve their experience and competency in the field, PHP offers training through seminars and webinars, and may arrange for them to work in association with veteran performers. Dr Rosenfield characterizes the approach as a kind of fellowship. “What we do is offer a model to overcome all the hurdles I’ve faced over the years,” he says.
PHP is a limited liability company, not a medical society, he notes, so it can freely advocate for talented surgeons while advising others to work toward their potential. “We’re trying to create an easy pathway to connect patients with surgeons,” he says. “There’s an opportunity, as a specialty, to really take control of this.”
Sometimes PHP can bring patients to ASCs. On the outskirts of Minneapolis in Burnsville, Minnesota, Ridges Surgery Center serves residents of the Twin Cities area, but also sees patients from other states. The ASC is multispecialty. Medical director Anthony Shibley, MD, is one of those gynecologists who has gained expertise through experience, and PHP frequently refers patients to him.
According to Ridges administrator Michael Miller, MHA, primary care providers in less well-served places contact PHP, which then refers them to high-performing ASCs such as Ridges.
“They fly in, we put them up in a hotel, they have their surgery, then they fly back,” he explains. “It opens up a whole new market for ambulatory surgery patients.” The setup would be impossible without both a network like PHP and minimally invasive surgery, he notes.
According to the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), hysterectomy is the second most common surgical procedure performed on women, after cesarean section. The most frequent indications are uterine fibroids, menstrual disorders, uterine prolapse, and endometriosis.
Patients tend to be younger (in the Pearl sample, the average age was 43.6 years), so Medicare coverage rarely applies. However, since implementation of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), many more women have become covered under Medicaid. With pressure to reduce costs for both patients and insurers, laparoscopic is the method of choice for many cases.
ACOG recognizes several categories of laparoscopic hysterectomy:
• Total laparoscopic hysterectomy is removal of the uterus and cervix after detaching them from surrounding structures using laparoscopic instruments. The uterus then is removed through the vagina or abdomen.
• Laparoscopic-assisted vaginal hysterectomy uses a combination of laparoscopes and a vaginal approach to detach the structures before removal through the vagina.
• Laparoscopic supracervical hysterectomy is laparoscopic detachment of the uterus from the cervix followed by removal of the uterus through the abdomen.
• Also common is myomectomy, removal of uterine fibroids.
There are many variations within each category, corresponding to a wide array of billing codes.
According to Gladys Tse, MD, assistant professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Washington University School of Medicine in St Louis, laparoscopic hysterectomy is clinically appropriate for nearly every woman, regardless of the size of her fibroid or uterus.
Dr Tse is quoted in WebMD as saying women may choose a traditional abdominal procedure because of other factors, such as availability of skilled surgeons. A laparoscopic procedure generally takes longer and is more expensive to the patient, she says, because of different insurance copay rules.
Insurance status is a consideration in patient selection. In the Pearl study of 502 cases, 57 additional candidates were excluded for not having adequate insurance.
Specific to the specialty is the question of whether the patient has had previous abdominal or laparoscopic surgery that may have left adhesions. Various other pathologies and comorbidities could exclude a patient from the ASC environment.
Under Pearl’s protocol, if the body mass index of a patient exceeds 34 kg/m2, the anesthesiologist must be notified. As with most other surgical procedures using general anesthesia, patients are told to fast for 8 hours and to arrive 1 hour before the surgery.
Patients go home with two prescriptions: Ondansetron for nausea and Norco (hydrocodone and acetaminophen) for pain. They must have an escort and someone to stay with them for 24 hours. After that they can remove the Band-Aid covering the incision. They are encouraged to drink fluids with high sugar content to relieve nausea, avoid spicy foods and alcohol, and use a stool softener. They are told to avoid intercourse and to lift nothing heavier than 20 pounds for 14 days.
One reason expertise is important, Dr Rosenfield notes, is that the risks are greater than with most other ASC procedures. “You’re not likely to hit the vena cava in knee surgery,” he says. “But with hysterectomy, we’re into the peritoneal cavity, so we have to face reality.”
With the small incisions characteristic of less-invasive surgery, larger uteri and fibroids may be bisected or fragmented for easier removal via morcellation.
In 2014, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) issued a recommendation discouraging (but not prohibiting) use of power morcellators after reports of incidents in which cancerous tissue was accidentally detached and left to spread to other organs. The FDA estimates 1 in 350 women is at risk of uterine sarcoma, but Dr Rosenfield says the incidence is closer to 1 in 9,000.
Medicare pays ASCs about half as much as it pays a hospital outpatient department (HOPD) for the same procedure. For example, an average for a total hysterectom is about $3,000, compared with $6,000 in an HOPD. However, depending on contract terms, commercial insurers will pay $3,800 to $6,500 to an ASC for the same procedure.
If gynecology is to be the wave of the future in ASC specialties, the reimbursement system must be overhauled, Dr. Rosenfield believes. He says the current CMS payment rates to ASCs are based on hospital rates that were always inadequate. Hospitals did not challenge the rates because relatively few hysterectomy patents are old enough for Medicare. Hospitals negotiate contracts with commercial insurers who usually pay at least 200% of the Medicare rates.
ASCs need to do the same, as they cannot profitably care for Medicare or Medicaid patients under the current rates. In fact, the dependence on privately insured patients may be the ticket to attracting more surgeons to ASC-based procedures. At Ridges, more than 90% of gynecology patients use commercial insurers.
“It’s another reason to expand into GYN—you have more commercial patients,” Miller says.
Even Medicaid can provide adequate reimbursement, Dr Ribot says, in states where the government has outsourced the program to Medicaid care management organizations that are run like commercial insurers.
“It depends on the surgeon. If you are efficient, it can be profitable,” he says. The key is to negotiate a favorable contract with the insurance company, and then to manage costs through efficiency. For example, he says, “If the surgery center is 60 feet down the hall from my office, instead of driving to the hospital, I save a lot of time. Also, we use very little in the way of expensive disposable instruments.”
Despite obstacles, the field is growing and ASCs should be aware of opportunities, Dr Rosenfield advises. “Keep an eye out for what’s happening in gynecologic surgery. There’s always a new kid on the block, and I believe GYN is going to be one of the next big things,” he says. ✥
DeJohn P. Oregon surgery center is pioneer in outpatient hysterectomy. OR Manager. 2014;30(8):29-31.
Einarsson J, Suzuki Y. Total laparoscopic hysterectomy: 10 steps toward a successful procedure. Rev Obstet Gynecol. 2009;2(1):57-64.
Food and Drug Administration. Laparoscopic uterine power morcellation in hysterectomy and myomectomy: FDA safety communication. November 24, 2014. http://www.fda.gov/MedicalDevices/Safety/AlertsandNotices/ucm393576.htm.
Rosenfield R. Hysterectomy and beyond: Is gynecologic surgery the next big thing? Presented at ASCA 2016.