February 1, 2011

Tracking data, changing behavior

By: OR Manager
Share

Indiana University Hospital in Indianapolis uses its perioperative dashboard both for monitoring key metrics and for behavior change (illustration, p 11).

“We figure out what we want to measure on a monthly basis,” says Patricia Vassell, MBA, RN, CCRN, CNOR, administrative director of surgical services. The department has 24 ORs. Examples of metrics are:

  • FTE utilization
  • first-case on-time starts
  • case cancellations
  • PACU admission delays (number of patients who cannot leave the OR when surgery is complete because no PACU bed is available)
  • turnover time (patient out to patient in)
  • PACU length of stay
  • OR utilization (7 am to 3:30 pm)
  • total number of cases
  • total number of OR hours.

The color-coded dashboard is shared monthly with the OR’s leaders, physicians, and nursing staff.

“We post it on the bulletin board every month. Everyone knows what the dashboard is,” Vassell says.

Recently, the dashboard helped in addressing late starts for first cases.

“We constantly look to see what is going on,” she says. The top 3 reasons for delays get the attention. Initially, it took some effort to make sure nurses documented the delay codes accurately and consistently.

In tackling the top 3 reasons for delays, they identified some nursing issues involving instrumentation and equipment.

Once those were resolved and no longer appeared in the top 3, physician issues rose to the top.

The OR’s medical director, Eric Wiebke, MD, MBA, FACS, worked with the OR committee to set expectations for the physicians.

Ultimately, one surgeon lost his first-case time for a month, which turned the issue around. The next month, Vassell says, he began arriving as early as 6 am—much to the staff’s surprise.

“Our physician leader has really held the physicians accountable for their performance, and that has made a difference,” Vassell says. “We have had days where 100% of our cases were on time.”

Surgery Dashboard

Achieved target
Target not achieved; however, improvement from previous month
Target not achieved; decreased improvement from previous month
Metric Metric definition Measure Data source/contact Target Aug 10 Sept 10 Oct 10 Status towards target Trend
FTE utilization OR staffing levels exceed the flexed workload levels Comparison between actual and flexed budget Monthly FTE report 1.0% or less 2.0% under flexed budget 4.89% under flex budget 1.72% over flex budget Using more FTEs than flex budget allows but decreased variance % from previous month
First-case starts Patient in room at scheduled time for first case % of cases that patient enters the suite no more than 5 minutes after the scheduled start Cognos 75.0% 95.0% 90.0% 74.0% Decrease in % of first cases started on time
Case cancellation rate (excludes transplant) Number of canceled cases per weekday (excluding transplant) Number of canceled cases per weekday/total number of cases per weekday (excluding transplant) Cerner 2.0% 0.82% 1.17% 0.50% Decreased from previous month
PACU admission delays Total number of occurrences and minutes that patient is held in OR Total number of occurrences and minutes that patient is held in OR for Phase 1 Cerner 0 1 case 32 minutes total 1 case 12 minutes total 3 cases 52 minutes total Increase in number of minutes patients held in OR
Turnover time* Amount of time from when one patient exits an OR until the next patient enters the same OR within 60 minutes % of cases that are turned over in 30 minutes or less Cognos 90.0% 73.2% 80.0% 76.0% Decrease in % of cases turned over in 30 minutes or less
Length of stay in PACU Amount of time from admission to discharge in PACU for Phase 1 Time patient enters PACU until discharged from PACU for Phase 1 Cerner 90 min or less 86 minutes 8 minutes 8 minutes Met target and no change from previous month
Overall OR utilization # of actual OR hours used/# of OR hours available 7:30a-3:30p # of actual OR hours used/# of OR hours available 7:30a-3:30p Cerner 85.0% 65.5% 62.2% 62.8% Increase in hours OR is used between 7:30a-3:30p
# of cases Cognos 1,004 995 1,064
# of surg hours Cognos 3,180 3,016 2,936

* Turnover time excludes pm cases, jump rooms, add-on rooms, bumped cases, and “previous case ended early.”

Source: Indiana University.

She adds: “Everything is driven by the dashboard. I find physicians will respond if you can show them the data.

“Without data, it’s just finger pointing.”

Dashboard summary

Audience: Medical and nursing staffs and perioperative leaders

Metrics: FTE utilization, on-time first-case starts, and other operational metrics

Frequency: Monthly

Software: Dashboard is in Excel. Data source is nurses’ documentation in the perioperative information system.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat