In 2001, the ORs at Banner Baywood Medical Center were struggling—physicians were dissatisfied, case volume was down, and 13 staff positions were vacant. “There was a general lack of urgency. There just was no culture of efficiency,” says Christine Halowell, RN, MS-HSA, CNOR, director of perioperative services for the Mesa, Arizona, hospital.
Seven years later, things are looking up. Surgical case volumes have risen from under 8,000 a year to close to 10,000. Gross revenue is up by 62%. Staff retention rose to 94% in 2007, up from 90% in 2004. The 10 ORs perform about 10,000 cases a year, with about two-thirds of those in general surgery and orthopedics.
Banner Baywood’s ORs are now considered to be among the most productive in Banner Health’s network of 20 hospitals. The improvement project was described in a poster abstract at the 2008 AORN Congress in Anaheim, California.
When Halowell took her position 6 years ago, she knew changes were needed. These are steps she and her team took to turn the culture around.
Soon after she arrived, Halowell began forming relationships with the physicians and staff.
“I would ask, ‘How can we better serve you and your patients?'” she recalls. She found they were eager to talk. “I don’t know that anyone had ever asked them before.”
From the most vocal physicians, she enlisted volunteers and formed the OR Logistics Committee.
“We are a multidisciplinary operational team. We handle things the Surgery Committee doesn’t have time for,” she explains. Members include 2 surgeons, an anesthesiologist, an administrator, Halowell, and staff from the preoperative area, OR, postanesthesia care unit (PACU), and sterile processing department (SPD).
The committee started by developing a list of issues it wanted to tackle.
“We looked at everything from turnover times to late starts to block utilization,” she says. “We looked at how the H&Ps (histories and physicals) were getting on the charts.”
Early on, the committee was assisted by a management engineer in flow charting some processes it wanted to improve.
“This was a tremendous help,” Halowell says. “It allowed us to have a critical eye for flaws and make improvements.”
The next step was to prioritize the problems.
“We looked at what we could fix immediately—the low-hanging fruit—and what needed medium-term and long-term fixes,” Halowell says.
One of the easier fixes was improving the preadmission testing (PAT) process and getting the H&Ps into the patients’ charts before surgery.
The PAT staff and management team started by inviting surgeons’ office personnel to a hospital-sponsored “lunch and learn.” They requested that H&Ps be faxed to a specific number.

“Once the H&Ps arrived, they were placed on patients’ charts by PAT staff, and this issue was resolved,” she says.
About 90% of surgical patients are seen 3 to 7 days prior to surgery by nurses in the PAT department. The remainder receives at least a phone call, which has minimized cancellations on the day of surgery.
For H&Ps that are not on the chart by the day of surgery, a short form was developed, which is placed on the chart with the original H&P. This form satisfies the Joint Commission’s requirement to document an update to the patient’s condition prior to surgery or within 24 hours for inpatients.
A more complex problem was tightening up turnover time, which in 2001 averaged 35 minutes from patient out to patient in for to-follow cases. A key step was defining and choreographing roles of team members, including a new “kamikaze squad” of OR assistants and housekeepers.
This is the way a turnover is conducted now:
As soon as a case ends, a housekeeper does the heavy cleaning while the OR assistant cleans the flat surfaces. The OR assistant then brings in the case cart, spreads the supplies, and begins opening them. The ST joins in the setup and counts with the circulator. The circulator then helps the anesthesiologist bring the patient to the OR, and the case is ready to begin.
When Halowell introduced the idea of OR assistants opening sterile supplies, she got some pushback from the RNs.
“Then I had the nurses teach them so they would feel comfortable,” she says. “Once they saw that the OR assistants learned well, everybody was fine with it.”

It’s also a plus for OR assistants’ job satisfaction. “They feel more like part of the team. It promotes teamwork in the OR, and you have the right person doing the right job,” she says.
Turnover time statistics are shared with the staff monthly. Initially, Halowell says teams were recognized and rewarded for short turnover times when no corners were cut. Teams and individuals that did not comply with turnover expectations were coached, and some were disciplined for noncompliance.
“In this way, the staff realized we held everyone accountable to our standards,” she says. “Now good turnover times are part of our culture.”
Turnover times for 2007 averaged 22.6 minutes from patient out to patient in for to-follow cases, including total joint replacements, which average about 25 to 30 minutes between cases.
Another major focus was improving on-time starts for the first case of the day, which Halowell says was “really bad” at 21% and affected the rest of the day’s schedule.
The first step was to define an on-time start. The OR Logistics Committee consulted the surgeons and decided to define “start time” as the time the patient enters the OR. The committee decided surgeons and anesthesiologists would be considered late if they had not seen the patient at least 15 minutes before the scheduled start time.
In the beginning, a patient entering the OR even a minute past the scheduled time was considered late. Now there is a 5-minute grace period.
Preop nurses record when surgeons and anesthesiologists arrive, and the time is correlated with the time the patient enters the OR. Data showed lateness by physicians was the major issue. Staff lateness was not a problem, Halowell says.
Steps to improve on-time starts included:
Physician lateness is defined as the patient in the room 4 or more minutes late, averaged over 4 cases in a quarter. Physicians who exceed this criterion receive a warning letter telling them their 7 am and 7:30 am case-scheduling privileges may be rescinded for 3 months. If a physician exceeds the lateness criterion for 2 consecutive quarters, the data is shared with the surgery committee with a recommendation to rescind early-case scheduling privileges for 3 months. This policy is carried out at the discretion of the chairman of surgery and/or the OR director.
Together, these steps have raised on-time starts to 70% to 75%.
How was Halowell able to change the culture among the nursing staff? Recogni-tion is part of the answer, she notes.
“One thing I do every day is to recognize and build up the staff,” she says. “I tell them how good they are.”
She sent the staff a survey to ask how they want to be recognized. Interestingly, while some liked to be recognized in front of their peers, others weren’t comfortable with that, so she plans recognition accordingly (sidebar).
Time is provided before every staff meeting and report for staff to recognize peers.
“That’s built into our culture now,” she says. “Even if you don’t ask at report, they’ll raise their hands and say, ‘I just want to say thank you to this person who did this for me yesterday.'”
If the OR’s performance is slipping, she shares that, too.
“Our dashboard and financials are posted,” she says. “I find if I share that data with the staff, they are more in tune and ready to work for you.”
Staff also participate in the OR’s efforts to improve quality and operations. An example is peer review meetings to discuss root cause analyses and near misses. The group discusses the near miss, analyzes what parts of the system or process failed, and proposes improvements.
Halowell finds positive reinforcement goes a long way in building morale.
“If you continually tell the staff they’re the best and celebrate your accomplishments, one day it just clicks for them. They realize they are good and strive to be better,” she says.
Ideas from Banner Baywood Medical Center, Mesa, Arizona: