H ealthcare trends come and go, but one that shows no signs of stopping is value-based payment. Just this year, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services launched the Comprehensive Care for Joint Replace-ment (CCJR) model, which mandates bundled payment for two of the most common surgical procedures in the US. The program currently applies to 75 metropolitan areas, but it will likely roll out to all hospitals in the near future (see OR Manager, October 2015, 22-23).
CCJR is just one element of the government’s stated plan to convert 50% of Medicare reimbursement to value-based payment within the next 2 years.
Leaders at some ORs have made critical changes to how they do things and are well positioned to succeed under value-based models. Others have their work cut out for them.
What differentiates a well-prepared surgery department from one that is falling behind? To answer that question, join me on a quick “tour” of two different ORs.
Our first stop is a community hospital with a 15-room OR that handles 9,500 cases per year. Today is starting like most days—with a sense of “controlled chaos.” Nurses are searching for patient charts and frantically hunting down medical clearances. Staff are making heroic efforts to complete missing lab tests, but as many as one out of every 20 cases will end up canceled because the patient is not ready for surgery. In spite of overall low case volumes, the schedule is already running about an hour behind.
Moving inside the core, we observe many well-trained physicians and nurses, but there is a strong sense of disorder. Some surgeons are late, and others are quietly steaming about room turnovers that take an hour or more. Case time is highly variable, with the slowest physicians often taking 50% longer to finish a procedure than the fastest providers.
Material management is also a challenge. Staff must keep track of a huge range of preference items, and they spend significant time returning unused supplies to storage. Logistical snafus frequently bring patient flow to a standstill—as is the case today, when the department’s lone C-arm is needed in three rooms at once.
Finally, we make the rounds of the postoperative units. ICU and inpatient nurses are skilled, but their focus is narrow. Staff have care goals, but few recovery milestones or benchmarks. Length of stay (LOS) for surgery patients is relatively high, as staff contend with many surgical site infections (SSIs) and other complications. Patients leave the hospital with little more than instructions to follow and phone numbers to call. Many will soon be back, as evidenced by the hospital’s high 30-day readmission rates.
The next OR we visit is similar to the first, except it is much busier. In spite of the higher volume, however, the environment is significantly quieter.
Our visit begins in the preanesthesia testing (PAT) department, where staff are conducting phone interviews to screen patients who have recently been scheduled for surgery. PAT staff use a standardized testing matrix to refer patients for presurgical lab tests and imaging. The department also uses protocols for managing patient comorbidities and medications prior to surgery.
The holding area is full but humming efficiently. Thanks to careful preoperative preparation, the vast majority of patients are ready for their procedures. Day-of-surgery cancellations are under 1%, and more than 90% of cases begin within 5 minutes of their scheduled start times.
The OR is not without hiccups and occasional “fires” to put out, but the overall flow is well orchestrated. Surgeons, anesthesiologists, nurses, and support staff communicate well and collaborate smoothly.
Standardization—in processes, supplies, and clinical protocols—removes a lot of friction. Case times are largely predictable, and turnover times are generally under 20 minutes. Although the schedule is brisk, staff make time for preprocedure time-outs and postprocedure debriefs.
In the postanesthesia care unit, nurses follow detailed protocols, complete with benchmarks for pain level, ambulation, and other recovery milestones. On the floor, inpatient nurses use standard order sets for specific procedures, and nurse practitioners perform goal-driven rounds on a daily basis. When a patient falls off a recovery pathway, nurse managers send daily progress emails to the entire care team.
Discharges to skilled nursing facilities are minimized, thanks to planning efforts begun during the PAT process. Readmissions are also rare, as care coordinators follow patients throughout the 90-day postdischarge period.
Which department does your OR resemble more? If your organization is more like the second OR, you are ready for value-based payment. You and your colleagues are controlling all the factors that affect quality and cost. Successful efforts to minimize LOS, prevent readmissions, and optimize patient outcomes will help your department thrive in the new payment environment.
But if your department is more like the first OR, problems in scheduling, patient flow, supply management, and other issues will drive up costs. And lack of collaboration will make it very difficult to improve quality and patient outcomes.
If this exercise makes you think your OR is not ready for value-based payment, you are not alone. Most ORs fall somewhere in the middle. The good news is that a handful of key changes can transform your department into a high-value surgical services organization. To prepare your OR for value-based payment, focus on five priorities:
ORs that are well prepared for value-based payment treat surgical care as a pathway, not just a string of services. They design every step of the perioperative process to achieve the goals of effective treatment and cost-efficiency.
One promising approach is the surgical home model of care (see OR Manager, March 2015, 1, 8-12; April 2015, 15-19). Well-designed surgical homes include care pathways that can be used for up to 90% of patients. Exclusions are determined by pathway criteria, not physician preference. Care pathways include agreed-upon protocols for presurgical testing and presurgical management of diabetes, heart disease, and other risk factors. Surgical homes also establish recovery milestones and benchmarks for postoperative care. Planning for home discharge begins early, which helps control costs by minimizing discharges to nursing facilities. Postdischarge coordinators partner with home care to prevent readmissions by detecting potential complications and providing early intervention.
Value-based payment will require ORs to take advantage of every opportunity to optimize patient outcomes and control costs. Traditional information tools are no longer up to this task. To succeed under new payment models, OR leaders must have access to comprehensive data on department operations, staffing, quality, clinical outcomes, and costs.
The first step is to identify the performance metrics that are key to the OR’s success as a value-driven organization. The second step is to work with nursing, decision support, and the IT department to create systems for capturing, reporting, and monitoring OR performance data.
Transparency is an important element of data-driven management. Leading ORs share clinical, operational, and financial metrics with the entire staff. Some organizations have also developed surgeon scorecards that track surgeon costs and clinical outcomes, allowing physicians to measure themselves against their peers.
Efficiency has always been important in perioperative services, but value-based payment makes it essential for ORs to optimize their use of time and material resources.
OR stakeholders should collaborate to create scheduling and block time systems that maximize utilization. Performance improvement teams should reexamine all department processes to reduce case times and turnover times. In addition, OR leaders should implement systems for ensuring efficient perioperative flow. Many ORs have established a daily huddle as a mechanism for orchestrating patients, staff, rooms, and equipment.
Cost is a key element of the new healthcare value equation (sidebar,below), and OR leaders clearly need to step up efforts to control supply and material costs. However, it is important to understand that value-based payment significantly expands the definition of cost. For example, the CCJR bundled payment is intended to cover the cost of the joint replacement procedure, the inpatient admission, and the 90-day postdischarge period.
Postdischarge expenses can represent up to 40% of the total cost of a surgical episode. OR leaders must partner with inpatient nursing, social work, local nursing facilities, and home care agencies to examine posthospital costs and wring out waste.
Many people think of surgical safety in terms of retained objects and wrong-site surgery. Events like these are destructive and costly, but they do not represent that heart of the safety challenge. Far more numerous are patient complications that can result from suboptimal surgical care and lead to poor outcomes and high costs.
Under value-based payment, safety is a critical competency. Surgical safety checklists have been shown to improve provider communication and can help prevent complications like SSIs and repeat surgery.
In addition, regular staff debriefings can help surgery departments build a culture of continuous improvement. Underlying all of these safety tools is a just culture—the set of policies, habits, and attitudes that treat patient and staff safety as a system issue, not a personal issue.
Surgery departments that make progress in these five areas will lay the groundwork for success under value-based payment. However, significant movement in any of these areas depends on one thing: collaboration.
The transition to value-based payment will require unprecedented levels of teamwork between surgeons, anesthesiologists, OR nursing, ancillary units, and hospital executives.
Many leading departments have found that the only way to achieve this level of collaboration is to create a multidisciplinary surgical services executive committee (SSEC) to govern the OR. An effective, physician-led SSEC enables OR stakeholders to work together to solve the problems that lead to poor quality and high costs.
Just as important, the collaborative spirit of a well-functioning SSEC inevitably spreads to the surgical suite, where it strengthens communication between all team members and helps further the goals of quality, safety, efficiency, and cost control.
Haynes A B, Weiser T G, Berry W R, et al. A surgical safety checklist to reduce morbidity and mortality in a global population. N Engl J Med. 2009;360(5):491-499.
Pugel A E, Simianu V V, Flum D R, et al. Use of the surgical safety checklist to improve communication and reduce complications. J Infect Public Health. 2015;8(3):219-25.