Video integration expert Keith Mignault looks at technology that’s here now and what’s on the horizon.
High-definition (HD) is available in most surgical scope systems and routing systems. HD has several levels, and they are not the same. For example, HD room cameras and surgical light cameras may have 720 or 1080 lines of resolution. Both are HD and will display a video, but a 1080 image has significantly more information. 1080 has multiple levels as well (1080i and 1080p).
If an HD television is 1080p at 60 Hz, it shows a full picture frame, every line, 60 times per second.
Does this difference matter? Yes. When objects move, such as a heartbeat, the image that refreshes slower can have pixel movement in between the cycles resulting in a slightly blurry image. Most integration systems are standardizing on 1080p displays and scaling all signals to that display.
Another aspect to high definition is how vendors route the signals. My belief is that the integration system should be vendor neutral (as much as possible), designed to accommodate emerging technologies, and able to route any device that rolls into the room without down-scaling that device’s highest output.
The latter is important in routing signals because the bandwidth capability of the router reveals its capability. Bandwidth illustrates the amount of video information a router can handle per second.
The various digital video signal formats are represented in gigabits per-second (Gbit/s). Analog signals are being replaced by the higher-performance digital options. If the router is 1080i, for example, then a DVI source, such as a computer displaying PACS images or most video scope processors, would be downscaled to 1080i before it is routed to the display. Some may argue this is not a discernable loss, but this conversion removes about 62% of the original signal before sending it to the display. I would argue that routing systems should never downscale because physicians should always have the best possible images to view.
A related note: Many integration systems on the market will install a system that downscales a source device if a high-resolution input is not available. For example, if the DVI port is taken, these systems would use the available S-video. That is a troubling alternative because, using your home TV as example, it essentially would turn your home HD-TV station into the non-HD version. Most would agree that the image quality has a discernable difference.

An OR dashboard integrates data at New York-Presbyterian Hospital, New York City. Courtesy of LiveData.
3D video currently is a specialized technology but should become more widespread over the next few years. Applications might include having routers render the video from 2 HD cameras on a microscope to a surgical display to simulate looking through the microscope. Observers would need to wear 3D glasses. Like HD, emerging 3D products should not be assumed to be the same. The technology is hardware intensive, and most current products on the market do not have the processing power to accommodate true 3D technology without replacement or upgrade.
Device identification, becoming more widespread, is like “plug and play” for your computer. For example, an ultrasound system with device identification has a permanent integration box attached and can plug into any open video integration port. The integration system automatically recognizes what is attached, and the buttons activate automatically. The circulating nurse no longer needs to know what is connected where. All input ports are also standardized, further simplifying the design.
In 2011, at least 4 integration vendors intend to offer device identification technology. Integration systems will eventually be capable of automatically recording what devices were used on the patient.
Information sharing in the surgical suite will accelerate over the next several years. Current systems can offer physician and case presets, ability to capture and record video and still images, and the ability to link to existing patient information systems and surgery tracking systems. But the software programming to integrate those systems and to comply with HIPAA and hospital protocols is lagging and should be considered a work in progress for all integration vendors.
As software and security protocols become more developed, many benefits are on the horizon. These might include streaming live video and patient status information to any hospital PC or mobile phone, configuring status displays of multiple rooms to enable the staff to multitask easier, and conveniently reviewing recorded case information.
A hybrid suite integrates surgery with interventional radiology, for example, in cardiology. Some integration vendors can now replace the traditional bank of overhead displays with integrated displays that have superior performance and flexibility.
Note, however, that the hybrid OR still needs 2 imaging-system vendor displays (wall mounted, for example) that are viewable and directly connected to the imaging system to calibrate and certify the system. But the sterile field displays can have any signal placed on any display. Banks of 2 or 3 integrated displays can be on either side of the patient to accommodate hybrid cases.
Another emerging solution is to have one ultra-high resolution display suspended from ceiling mounts in lieu of the bank of traditional displays. This is sometimes called an “8K” display for its resolution capability (8,192 by 3,420 pixels). In this configuration, the one large display is capable of handling 4 simultaneous 1080p HD signals. This permits surgeons to place any signal they want on the large display, choosing the location on the display. They will eventually be able to zoom or resize signals independently. Some may not find this technology necessary, but a hospital that wants a hybrid suite with maximum flexibility can consider modifying the traditional bulky and fixed image display bank into a single and flexible solution.
Here’s what you can expect to see:
Keith Mignault is president, Mignault Planning, Inc, Baldwinsville, New York. mignaultplanning@gmail.com