November 1, 2008

When a staff member needs to improve

By: OR Manager
PDF
Share

Sixth and final article in a series on performance management.

This article completes the series on performance management, published monthly since June 2008. The first article gave an overview of the performance management process. The next 4 articles covered the job description, initial competencies, orientation, goal setting, on-going competencies, coaching and mentoring, and the performance evaluation. This article discusses performance improvement and gives a summary of the entire process.

Sometimes, despite our best efforts including coaching and support, a staff member may not meet the requirements of the job. When this happens, as managers we need to assist these staff members to understand where they need to improve. We need to set realistic goals for them to improve their performance. Then we need either to reward them for improving or move them to a job more suited to their skills and talents, or we need to move them out of the organization. This can give them the opportunity to be successful elsewhere.

Setting the stage

Discussing the positive aspects of a performance appraisal can be easy. A good introduction to the performance appraisal meeting may be something like, “I’d like to discuss the points of your performance on which we agree first. Then we’ll talk about areas where we don’t agree. I’ll ask for your perspective on both of these areas so we can learn from each other throughout this process.” Referring to the performance log you’ve kept all year gives you details about positive and negative aspects of performance that need to be discussed. (See July 2008 OR Manager, p 20.)

To have a productive performance review, discuss the positive aspects in detail so the staff member and you both learn from the successes achieved. A question like, “What was it about this part of the job that made you successful?” encourages the staff member to share with the manager. The manager can then share thoughts on the reasons for success.

Addressing problem areas

This positive interaction sets the stage for discussion of areas where performance has not been positive. This discussion usually takes longer than the discussion about successes. Managers experienced in giving performance evaluations review the staff member’s viewpoints on each job function prior to the actual review. They consider points of disagreement that will be easy to resolve and points that will take additional time to come to agreement about the future course of action.

The result may be the need for a performance improvement plan for specific aspects of the job where the staff member is not meeting expectations. The need for a performance improvement plan may also be identified at other times during the performance year.

Performance improvement is defined by nurse author and consultant Jo Manion, RN, PhD, FAAN, as “a rigorous feedback and documentation process that generally spans 60 to 90 days, depending on the nature of the problem.” (See sidebar for Manion’s model of a positive discipline process.)

Documenting the process

Most organizations have a form for documenting and tracking the performance improvement process. (A sample is in the OR Manager Toolbox at www.ormanager.com.)

The form should include the following areas:

  • Space for identifying the exact performance area where there is a gap between expectations and performance.

    Example: “Policy states that patients will not be moved from the holding area into the OR (except in an emergency) until all preop requirements, including signed, dated, and timed consents, and updated H&P are on the chart. In the last 3 months, you have taken 6 patients to the OR without this requirement completed.”

  • Documentation of what is expected in the future.

    Example: “No patients who are under your care will be transported to the OR (except in an emergency) until all preop requirements, including consents and H&P, have been completed.”

  • Notes on how manager will assist staff member with meeting expectations.

    Example: “If you are placed in a situation where the surgeon or anesthesiologist is requesting that you move the patient into the OR inappropriately, you will page me or the medical director of the OR for assistance with enforcing the policy.”

  • Timelines.

    Example: “Results will be reviewed monthly for 6 months.”

  • Outcome.

    Example: “If any instances of taking a patient into the OR without policy being followed occur, we will proceed to level 3 of corrective action (final warning). An additional instance after that will result in termination.”

It’s important to align the reasons for improved behavior with the staff member’s values, skills, and reason for doing a good job.

The example above is extreme because it refers to a specific policy requirement that must be followed. Many other performance improvement aspects are less extreme but need to be improved to make the staff member more effective. An example is a plan to improve the performance of a staff member who does not help others during down time but tends to go to the lounge. In this instance, the reason for improvement should be based on the staff member’s values and/or personal reasons for wanting to do a good job. This reason might be something like, “Fellow staff members will be less likely to help you in the future when you may need help,” or “Fellow staff members are seeing you as not being a team player.”

Involve HR

It’s also important to include a representative from Human Resources (HR) in this process. HR professionals work with these situations more frequently than an individual manager. They can guide the manager in appropriate actions to take as well as ensure that the process is consistent throughout the organization. Though it’s uncomfortable to give a staff member negative feedback and to create a performance improvement plan, it’s even more uncomfortable to sit before an arbitrator or lawyer and hear that no other manager in your organization used the corrective action steps the same way you did. HR professionals can also help in conducting difficult face-to-face meetings with staff members.

Managing problem performers is not at the top of the list of ways most managers achieve job satisfaction. It is, however, a necessary part of managing people. If handled proactively and with skill, it can be less daunting and more fulfilling than allowing problem performers to continue in their current mode of operation. Solving the issues of problem performers leads to a more productive work force with staff members who are able to focus on quality patient care.

—Kathy Shaneberger, RN, MSN, CNOR

Director of Surgical Services

Holland Hospital, Holland, Michigan

References

Manion, J. Create a Positive Health Care Workplace! Practical Strategies to Retain Today’s Workforce and Find Tomorrow’s. Chicago: Health Forum, 2005.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat