February 17, 2017

Adding new business to the ASC, one procedure at a time—Part 2

By: Paula DeJohn
Share

Aging and active Americans are refusing to let back problems slow them down—the number of these patients is increasing, and they prefer the less invasive outpatient methods offered in ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs). So do their physicians.

As a result, ASCs seeking to adopt new procedures are looking more closely than ever at the opportunities offered in spine surgery. In the second of a three-part series, OR Manager examines the emerging technology associated with spine procedures and the likely future of performing them in the outpatient setting.

Part 1, which explored gynecologic procedures, was published in the February 2017 issue (pp 28-31).

 

Opportunities and obstacles

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), nationally, 100 million adults suffer from back pain, but 60% of those referred for surgery choose not to have it. However, the number of spinal fusion cases performed in ASCs grew 70% between 2001 and 2011, according to the Dartmouth Atlas of Health Care. The Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality predicts ASC spine volume will grow by 20% in the next 3 years.

As with any emerging technology, less invasive spine surgery requires careful planning and awareness of challenges. For example, although Medicare continues to approve new spine procedures for ASC reimbursement, not every patient is appropriate for this setting.

Spinal cages are expensive and highly subject to physician preference, so vendors may be reluctant to negotiate discounts. On the other hand, the procedures are often considered device intensive and thus are eligible for more generous Medicare reimbursement, so costs may be easier to recoup.

Surgical expertise is critical for good outcomes, and staff training is essential for proper patient selection, scheduling, and coding.

 

Communication is key

Laser Spine Institute (LSI), based in Tampa, Florida, owns six other spine ASCs located in the central US. Since 2005, LSI surgeons have performed spine surgery on about 60,000 patients. The majority of patients travel from out of state to LSI’s seven ASCs and stay in local hotels. LSI connects them with local caregivers if they do not have escorts available for the first 24 hours after surgery.

The key to a successful patient experience is communication, not only about their medical conditions, but also about their expectations regarding treatment, LSI has found.

LSI performs a variety of less invasive spine procedures for neck and back pain caused by spinal stenosis, degenerative disc disease, pinched nerves, bone spurs, bulging or herniated discs, sciatica, and other chronic conditions.

If screening indicates a patient is suited for such a procedure, the next step is explaining the options to the patient. In addition to the usual considerations of weight, age, comorbidities, and available home care, spine patients need to understand, accept, and comply with pre- and postoperative instructions and communicate their concerns and questions.

Another component of patient selection for surgery is the financial arrangement. Medicare has recently approved payment for more complex spine procedures, but because LSI does not accept Medicare, their patients must have private insurance or some other means of paying the full amount.

 

The golden patient

Karen Reiter, RN, CASC, CNOR

Karen Reiter, RN, CASC, CNOR

Karen Reiter, RN, CASC, CNOR, administrator of the two-campus DISC Sports and Spine Center in Newport Beach and Marina del Rey, California, says it is important to consider a patient’s family, social surroundings, and home environment when assessing eligibility for outpatient spine surgery.

“The patient should have realistic expectations and an engaged family,” she says. She describes “the golden patient” as having these characteristics:

  • overall good health
  • openness to education about the procedure
  • motivation

Among considerations are the patient’s age, weight, and mobility, and whether the patient has experienced sleep apnea. Nurses and anesthesia providers should develop a pain management plan ahead of time.

Also consider their social situation, she adds. “If the patient doesn’t have a supportive family, the outpatient option may not be appropriate.”

The patient’s education should include pain management, infection control, and safety, with detailed discharge instructions. The family should be involved at every stage.

ORM_0317_pg25_sidebar

Less invasive, more effective

Less invasive spine surgery is not simply more convenient than open surgery, according to Stefan Prada, MD, of LSI, who presented a webinar on the topic. “It is a muscle-sparing approach,” he explains, describing the use of endoscopic procedures where muscle is separated, rather than cut, through a 1-inch incision. The result is more rapid healing and improved mobility, he adds.

Like other procedures, spine surgery has a much lower surgical site infection rate when performed in an ASC, according to CDC data. The specialty received added attention in 2015 when the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) approved 10 additional current procedural terminology (CPT) codes for ASC reimbursement:

  • 22551: neck spine fuse & remove below c2
  • 22554: neck spine fusion
  • 22612: lumbar spine fusion
  • 22614: spine fusion extra segment
  • 63020: neck spine disc surgery
  • 63030: low back disc surgery
  • 63042: laminotomy single lumbar
  • 63045: removal of spinal lamina-cervical
  • 63047: removal of spinal lamina-lumbar
  • 63056: decompress spinal cord.

 

High tech, high price

Spinal cage contracting reached a milestone around 2002, when major group purchasing organizations began negotiating discounts on spine surgery supplies. Until then, manufacturers had been reluctant to give in on pricing, even with large hospital groups, because physicians remained loyal to specific brands. That may be changing as the market becomes more competitive and ASC owners seek ways to contain costs while embracing new technology.

Prices were inflexible also because technology was improving rapidly, including the move to less invasive devices and the emergence of bone products that could mimic or improve on metal. Dominant manufacturers include Medtronic Sofamor Danek (Memphis) and DePuy AcroMed (Raynham, Massachusetts).

Bone products, besides being more expensive, rely on donated bone. According to some reports, mixed results have kept bone use from expanding. Primary sources of bone include Regeneration Technologies (Alachua, Florida) and Synthes (West Chester, Pennsylvania).

Spinal implants—which may have many components—may be more expensive than what the physician and facility fees cover. Spine procedures in which the price of the implant exceeds 40% of the case cost are designated “device intensive” and are reimbursed separately by Medicare and many private insurers.

Among device-intensive procedures approved under the 2017 CMS payment rule are:

CPT 228X1: Insertion of interlaminar/interspinous process stabilization/distraction device, without fusion, including image guidance when performed, with open decompression, lumbar, single level (CPT 228X2, the same procedure at the second level, is not paid separately)

CPT 228X4: Insertion of interlaminar/interspinous process stabilization/distraction device, without open decompression or fusion, including image guidance when performed, lumbar, single level

CPT 630X1: Endoscopic decompression of spinal cord, nerve root, including laminotomy, partial facetectomy, foraminotomy, discectomy and/or excision of herniated intervertebral disc, 1 interspace, lumbar.

 

A winning strategy

The ASC management company Regent Surgical Health, in Westchester, Illinois, and the physician group West End Partners have begun construction of the Oregon Surgical Institute in Beaverton. When it opens later in 2017, it will be the first ASC designed specifically for spine and joint surgery.

This partnership reflects an effort to join the move toward value-based care and the growing outpatient spine and joint markets. According to a Regent statement, “In order for the strategy to be effective for spine procedures, physicians must deliver the data to demonstrate not only the clinical effectiveness of performing these surgeries in an ASC setting, but also the operational efficiencies and cost savings involved.”

Anne Roberts, BSN, RN

Anne Roberts, BSN, RN

Anne Roberts, BSN, RN, Regent’s vice president of operations, says the Beaverton facility illustrates the principle of using a defined focus on spine, total joints, orthopedics, and pain management to serve a fast-growing elderly population in a geographic area.

Regent took the opposite approach and serves a more diverse population with the Surgery Center of Wasilla, Alaska, which opened in February and features multiple specialties, including spine.

The fact that CMS is approving more outpatient spine procedures is encouraging, Roberts notes. “We acknowledge that medical comorbidities present in the Medicare population often prescribe that inpatient care is most appropriate. Yet the power to offer additional outpatient spine and joint services to even a small portion of this population has the potential to significantly impact volume in the ASC environment,” she explains.

The most common outpatient spine procedures today are laminectomy, laminotomy, anterior cervical discectomy and fusion, and microdiscectomy, Roberts says. “With new technology, we are going to see more spinal fusion in ASCs,” she predicts. Improved pain management also will help, she adds, as non-narcotic methods become available.

The key to making spine surgery work financially is to align the efforts of all participants, Roberts notes. Physician preference may conflict with contract provisions that reward standardization, or loyalty to a particular vendor.

“Work with your physicians to find out what their preferences are, and strategize to limit the number of choices,” she says. At the same time, be sure that contracts with insurance companies include “carve-out” provisions for separate payments for devices.

Vendors also need to understand the importance of keeping costs down if their ASC customers are going to continue using their products, she notes. “To make these cases work in the outpatient setting, you have to have your goals aligned with both the physician’s and the supplier’s,” she says.

Meanwhile, competition for the growing spine market is helping Regent’s 23 ASCs minimize price increases, Roberts adds. “There is increasing competition in the market, so pricing is pretty competitive. I don’t see it going up dramatically,” she says.

 

A gradual approach

Reiter’s advice to ASCs new to the specialty is to “start small and systematically expand.”

Among the challenges are adjustments in scheduling. “Have a gatekeeper that knows your physicians’ strengths and weaknesses,” she says. Scheduling should account for the surgeon’s preferences, room turnover time, and availability of equipment.

The ideal surgeon for ASC spine procedures is one who is experienced with minimally invasive techniques, including use of a microscope, works well in a team environment, and is confident but careful, Reiter says.

The board of governors must support the effort and be willing to invest in talent and equipment. The medical director must be a champion of the program. And ongoing staff education should support and reinforce strict guidelines and protocols. Reiter recommends twice-daily team huddles.

Even with the best planning, teamwork, and patients, always proceed with caution. “Be willing to say ‘no’ to cases,” she says. ✥

—Paula DeJohn

Read part 1 here.

References

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. CMS issues 2017 proposed hospital outpatient and ASC rule: A summary for spine surgeons. Final rule: CMS-1656-FC/IFC 260. www.cms.gov.

Reiter K. Spine procedures in the ASC. Presented at ASCA 2016.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat