Cancellation of surgical cases, especially prescheduled elective surgeries, is a pervasive problem that reduces OR utilization and hospital revenue. The estimated direct and indirect annual cost of such cancellations across the US is approximately $39 billion per year, with an average OR cost between $20 and $65 per minute.
Facilities use different metrics to measure themselves against like facilities. At the Veterans Healthcare Administration (VHA), scheduled surgery cancellations are measured within the 48-hour window before the scheduled surgery with the goal of keeping cancellations within that window to under 8%.
The overall surgery cancellation rate within the 48-hour window was found to be 24% at the Central Arkansas Veterans Healthcare System in Little Rock for fiscal year 2015 (October 1, 2014 to September 30, 2015). Administrators asked the OR staff to reduce cancellations to < 8% for all surgical services. A surgery cancellation project team was formed to reduce surgery cancellation rates, and by May 2016, cancellation rates for several surgical subspecialties fell below the 8% national benchmark. Here’s how those reduced rates were achieved.

The authors are with the Central Arkansas Veterans Healthcare System in Little Rock. Front row (left to right): Sandra Kitchens, BSN, RN, nurse manager, PACU/ASU/5BRA; Sonya Jackson, BSN, RN, OR nurse educator. Back row (left to right): Patti Thornton, BSN, RN, surgery coordinator; Lana Brown, PhD, RN, NEA-BC associate nurse executive for research; Felicia Weatherly, MSA, Lead MSA Surgery Service; Jotis Lee, MSNEd, RN health promotion and disease prevention program manager; and Dawn Moore, MSHS, BSN, RN, NEA-BC, associate nurse executive for surgery and anesthesia service.
The project team began by reviewing the previous 6 months’ worth of data in the electronic medical record to determine the most common reasons for surgery cancellations. The project team consisted of the OR scheduler, nurse educator, surgery coordinator-RN, associate nurse executive for research, associate nurse executive for surgery, ambulatory surgery nurse manager, and assistant nurse manager.
Initially, the meetings were held daily, but over time they changed to weekly and then monthly. Approximately 500 charts were reviewed to determine the most common reasons for surgery cancellations.
A template was developed to capture surgery cancellation information that included:
The most common reason for surgery cancellations was “patient action,” which included variables such as failure of the patient to follow preoperative instructions, inability to find transportation, or forgetting the scheduled surgery date.
A literature review revealed the following recommendations for reducing surgery cancellations: History and physicals (H&Ps) should be completed by a licensed provider before the scheduled surgery date, and patients should be called 48 to 72 hours before surgery.
Although the H&Ps were being completed 5 days before the surgery, it turned out that preoperative nursing staff were contacting most patients the evening before the scheduled surgery to tell them their arrival time, and not all surgery services provided a preoperative telephone call.
The project team decided to pilot a preoperative phone call 72 hours before the surgery date and developed a telephone script for that purpose.
The expected benefits of the cancellation pilot program were to streamline the preoperative process to reduce surgery cancellations. Other potential benefits also were identified:
These goals were presented to administration to gain support for an initial 30-day pilot project beginning with one service. The pilot began with urology, and after just 2 weeks it was so successful that ophthalmology was added. Eventually, ENT and pain neuro were added, and the pilot was extended to 6 months.
During the pilot, 76 patients with the urology service were called 72 hours in advance; of the 76 patients, 2 cancelled. This brought the cancellation rate down to 2.6%—a vast improvement. The services were chosen based on surgery cancellation rates, caseload level of complexity, and service agreement to participate in the pilot project.
One RN with OR experience was assigned to make preoperative telephone calls during routine business hours, 72 hours prior to the surgery date. The RN was expected to introduce herself, state the name of the facility, address the patient with respect, and explain that the purpose of the call was to remind the patient about surgery or to review any perioperative concerns.
Information addressed in the phone call included, but was not limited to, location of the facility, current health status, NPO status, medications to take the morning of surgery, patient contact number, name of the driver for the day of surgery, and surgery arrival time.
The RN gave patients the opportunity to ask questions and addressed additional concerns at this time. Some patients were unclear about the meaning of NPO status and the importance of stopping their anticoagulation therapy. The importance of something as simple as these two items was reinforced to the patients during these preoperative phone calls.
A scheduling template is being developed that the advanced practice RN will use when scheduling patients for surgery in any service so that all patients receive appropriate information.
Project outcomesThe pilot project phone calls began in August 2015. By February 2016, surgery cancellation rates for the four services were greatly reduced, and by May 2016, cancellation rates were as follows: Urology—4.76%, pain neuro—3.96%, ophthalmology—6.17%, and ENT—6.89% (sidebar right). All rates are below the national VHA benchmark of < 8%.
Other beneficial outcomes of this project were improved OR utilization because fewer cases were cancelled. This project improved and continues to improve surgery cancellation rates. One full-time RN has been hired as a surgery coordinator to make preoperative phone calls. Two additional positions have been requested so that all surgical services can be added to the call rotation.
A simple change in practice has provided patients with a better understanding of what to expect upon arrival for surgery, alerts the healthcare team before problems occur, improves OR utilization by alerting scheduling personnel of cancellations, and—most importantly—provides benefits and access to the patient. ✥
Firm policies and the right procedures tip the cost-benefit balance toward flip rooms. OR Manager. 2014;30(4), 19-21.
Gaucher S, Boutron I, Marchand-Maillet F, et al. Assessment of a standardized preoperative telephone checklist designed to avoid late cancellation of ambulatory surgery: The AMBUPROG multicenter randomized controlled trial. PLOS One. Published online February 1, 2016. http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0147194
Olson R P, Dhakal I B. Day of surgery cancellation rate after perioperative telephone nurse screening or comprehensive optimization visit. Perioper Med. 2015;4, 12.