March 16, 2017

Adding new business to the ASC, one procedure at a time—Part 3

By: Paula DeJohn
Share

Total joint procedures are gradually moving to ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs) as technology, medical expertise, and cost pressures combine to make the ASC an increasingly attractive alternative to an acute care hospital. The key to success for these and other complex procedures, experts say, is a combination of careful planning, adequate resources, well-screened patients, and reliable compensation.

In the final article of a three-part series on emerging trends in ASCs, OR Manager explores the factors to consider when adding total joints to the repertoire of outpatient procedures. Part 1 of this series examined adding a gynecologic service line (OR Manager, February 2017, pp 28-31), and Part 2 focused on spine procedures in the ambulatory setting (OR Manager, March 2017, pp 24-27).

Randall Schultz, MD

“There’s no reason to believe ASCs can’t do more total joints,” according to Randall Schultz, MD, a partner and orthopedic surgeon at Texas Orthopedics Surgery Center in Austin. He believes that, although Medicare currently does not pay for outpatient total joint replacements, there is growing evidence to support the case for reconsidering that policy.

“That’s likely to change soon, as more data continue to show the safety of these procedures being done on properly screened patients,” he says.

Still, outpatient joint surgery has not taken off as quickly as some expected, according to Michael Koppenheffer, executive director of the online healthcare publisher Advisory Board.

After polling 394 US hospitals with significant joint replacement programs, Koppenheffer found that, between 2012 and 2014, the percentage of hospitals performing at least one outpatient total knee replacement each quarter rose from 10% to 24%. “Still, in looking at the raw data, we saw just a handful of centers around the country that perform a significant volume of outpatient knee replacement,” he notes in an online article.

In absolute numbers, he found that of 29,321 knee replacements in the first quarter of 2014, only 470 were done as outpatient procedures. Many fewer outpatient hips were done in that same period: A total of 33 such procedures were performed in 17 hospital outpatient departments.

On the basis of those numbers, Koppenheffer says, “I think we can draw reasonable conclusions that outpatient joint replacement is still a limited phenomenon, though knee procedures in particular seem to be gaining momentum.”

The study looked only at hospital settings, not ASCs, Koppenheffer notes.

 

Expect a major investment

To perform complex orthopedic procedures in an ASC, surgeons and anesthesiologists need expertise in less-invasive techniques and a commitment to the program, including willingness to be on call overnight. The ASC may need to hire additional staff to provide recovery care and initial physical therapy before discharge.

Equipping the OR for such procedures calls for a major investment. The ASC may need to purchase power tools, protective apparel, and adjustable hospital beds for the recovery area.

To establish its hip and knee program in 2007, Mississippi Valley Surgery Center in Davenport, Iowa, spent $200,000 for six sets of power tools. A knee support device costs about $6,000. The air-conditioned protective suits worn by OR staff cost about $1,500 each.

Orthopedic implants and instruments are also expensive, and ASCs rarely have access to the volume discounts available to large hospitals. They may, however (with physician support), be able to apply capitation—that is, determine the maximum price they will pay for certain products, regardless of vendor.

Hospitals developed the policy during the 1990s and early 2000s to help control price increases from technology growth and competing physician preferences.

There are three major vendors of hip implants: DePuy, Inc, and Zimmer Holdings, both in Warsaw, Indiana; and Stryker Corporation in Kalamazoo, Michigan.

As an example of component prices, a femoral head might range from $500 to $750, depending on the model and material. The more expensive femoral stem may cost from $2,000 to nearly $5,000.

Texas Orthopedics purchases implants under contracts negotiated by its owner, the hospital chain Tenet Health, Dallas. According to Dr Schultz, “There’s still enough competition to drive prices down.”

Another major expense is that of instruments and equipment used in orthopedics. TRIA Orthopaedic Center in Bloomington, Minnesota, works with a division of one of its instrument suppliers, Stryker Corporation, to reprocess items designed for single use.

Food and Drug Administration regulations stipulate that reprocessors of single-use devices must obtain 510(K) clearances and meet the same standards as original equipment manufacturers. For this reason, ASCs and other small healthcare facilities rely on third-party reprocessors.

It is important to shop carefully for a reprocessor, according to TRIA’s OR nurse manager Andrea Barrett, BSN, RN. “We considered a local company,” she recalls, “but they did batch testing on items they reprocessed, while Stryker tests every item for compliance with the original manufacturer’s specs.”

Originally, the TRIA program was intended as a way to reduce the ASC’s environmental impact, but it also generated savings of $198,446 in 2016.

Experience showed not all reprocessed items were suitable, Barrett notes. “You should not be able to tell in a clinical situation that this is a reprocessed item—but with shavers and burrs, the surgeons said they could tell a difference in sharpness. So we decided not to buy these back. It became a choice between cost savings and what is best for the patient,” she explains.

 

CMS bundled pay model eludes ASCs

About 800 acute care hospitals in 67 urban areas participate in the Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement Model (CJR) as required under the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid’s (CMS) inpatient prospective payment system (IPPS). The CJR took effect in 2016 and will be implemented over 5 years. Under the CJR, Medicare patients receiving inpatient joint replacements are followed for 90 days post surgery. At first, payment is under the traditional fee-for-service model, but CMS also computes a target price for the bundle of services and products that go into each episode of care. Actual spending for hospital and related services, such as physical therapy, is then compared with the target price.

With quality as an additional factor, the responsible hospital (called the “initiator”) may receive a bonus payment for efficiency, or be charged a penalty for exceeding the target price.

Another program is Bundled Payments for Care Improvement (BPCI). According to CMS, as of April 1, 2016, BPCI had 1,522 participants, including 1,201 initiators. Under two of BPCI’s four models, target prices are compared with actual spending as under the CJR.

“Bundling payment for services that patients receive across a single episode of care—such as a heart bypass surgery or a hip replacement—is one way to encourage doctors, hospitals, and other healthcare providers to work together to better coordinate care for patients, both when they are in the hospital and after they are discharged,” CMS explains in a statement.

Bundled payments are effective in reducing costs for Medicare and private insurers that have adopted them, research shows. A study by the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine examined costs of hip and knee replacements at the Baptist Health System in San Antonio, Texas. After Baptist began a voluntary trial of the CJR model in 2009, the average cost of joint replacement surgery plus 30 days of follow-up care decreased from $26,785 to $21,208. Most of the savings came from lower implant costs—possibly from standardizing with fewer manufacturers—and lower spending on postacute care.

ASCs are not able to participate as initiators under the CJR; only hospitals may do so. With BPCI, physician practices and long-term care facilities may initiate procedures, but because Medicare does not cover outpatient total joints, ASCs are ineligible for now. Some private insurers, however, have begun to adopt the bundling model.

 

Less pain, faster healing

Hip replacements have moved to the outpatient setting primarily because they can now be performed using less-invasive surgical techniques. For example, for qualified patients, surgeons now can place implants through an anterior incision. The front incision is about 4 inches long rather than the usual 8 to 12 inches required for a posterior approach. With the anterior entry, the surgeon is able to separate muscles, rather than cutting them, to reach the hip joint, so healing is faster.

The Campbell Clinic in Memphis, Tennessee, performs hip implants using the anterior approach. According to administrator Cindy Armistad, speaking in an online video, the clinic has a 0% infection rate and a 0% readmission rate. More effective pain management enables patients to stand and walk sooner, so they can stay within the less-than-24-hour discharge limit. Instead of general anesthesia, ASCs administer regional nerve blocks, which are precisely placed using ultrasound imaging.

For total knees, anesthesia may include sciatic, femoral, and spinal blocks. Mississippi Valley Surgery Center uses a combination of blocks for knees and an anterior approach for hips. Oral medication before and after surgery helps patients stay ahead of postoperative pain.

Orthopedic surgeon John Hoffman, MD, credits muscle-sparing surgical techniques and advanced anesthetic and pain management protocols with getting patients out of bed more rapidly. “All of these factors come together, allowing most patients to be walking within a day of their procedure,” he says.

The Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery has supported the transition of additional procedures to the outpatient setting. According to a 2016 report, researchers found that ankle fractures were best treated in outpatient facilities.

Researchers at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine in Chicago reviewed outcomes for patients with closed, non-emergency fractures receiving open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) between 2005 and 2013. “In patients with closed fractures and minimal comorbidities, outpatient ORIF was associated with reduced risk of select 30-day medical morbidity and no difference in surgical morbidity, reoperations, and readmissions relative to inpatient,” they concluded.

 

Finding the right patients

Arthritis is a major reason for joint deterioration in patients age 60 and older. Injury and congenital defects account for many younger patients.

For outpatient status, the ideal patient is generally healthy, younger than 65, able to tolerate regional anesthesia, and motivated to undergo outpatient surgery. The patient must be able to understand and follow home care instructions and to recognize any complications.

A caregiver must be present for at least the first 48 hours following discharge. Home modifications such as shower supports and raised toilet seats may be prescribed. For lower extremity procedures, homes should be cleared of obstacles and loose rugs.

In addition to the usual considerations of weight, diabetes, hypertension, and other physical conditions, Dr Schultz has found that mental health plays a role in determining a patient’s eligibility for surgery. “Psychiatric variables such as anxiety and depression affect outcomes, and as orthopedic surgeons we are not well equipped to deal with them,” he says.

It is difficult to arrange psychiatric evaluations in advance of outpatient surgery. For one thing, there is a shortage of mental health professionals in many communities, and services are expensive. “This is our frontier,” he says. “We’re still working on how to approach it.”

For newcomers to the specialty, Dr Schultz says risk management should be a primary consideration. “I think first of all physicians need to be comfortable and experienced with this; I think there is hesitancy on the part of every physician. You need very close communication between the anesthesiologist and the surgeon.”

Rigorous patient selection is a large part of risk management, he adds.

“Start conservatively at first, with healthier patients. As you gain experience managing the risk, then you can expand your patient population. It’s not for everyone, but certainly the majority of patients could become candidates for this procedure,” he says. ✥

—Paula DeJohn

Read part 2 here.

References

DeJohn P. Capitated hip implant pricing is back. Hospital Materials Management. 2006;31(9):1-5,12-15.

Koppenheffer M. Outpatient joint replacement finally taking off…sort of. Advisory Board. October 8, 2014; www.advisory.com.

Qin C, Dekker R, Blough J, et al. Safety and outcomes of inpatient compared with outpatient surgical procedures for ankle fractures. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2016;20:1699-1705.

University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine. Medicare bundled-payments model cut joint replacement costs by more than 20 percent: Savings seen largely in lower costs of artificial joints and post-surgical rehabilitation. ScienceDaily. January 3, 2017. www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2017/101/170103122336.htm.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat