Lexington Medical Center in West Columbia, South Carolina, has had an annual average 3% growth in surgical volume since 2011 and is planning to add six ORs over the next 3 years. That’s a good position to be in. However, the ability of the organization to support continued surgical growth before adding operating rooms has required changes in operations to meet the surgical volume demand.
One area in need of improvement has been day-of-surgery cancellations. Changes in healthcare reimbursement challenge hospital leaders to deliver efficient, high-quality care at flat to minimally increasing rates—a goal that is not uncommon in today’s healthcare environment.
Through a project focused on redesigning the preoperative screening clinic (PSC), the cancellation rate for avoidable causes dropped from 15 cases per month in December 2014 to just two during the last 5 months of data collection. Keys to success included a new staffing design that changed the reporting structure in the PSC and standardizing practice among the anesthesia providers.
More than 15,000 surgical procedures are performed annually in Lexington’s 23 ORs. With cases increasing by 3% to 5% per year over a 3-year period and plans to expand operating space, it was imperative to avoid canceling cases. The literature shows that case cancellations increase costs, reduce potential revenue, impact patient safety, and negatively impact the patient’s experience.
Before the restructuring, the OR manager supervised prescreening, which consisted of an average of 50 calls per day made by ancillary, non-licensed staff. The prescreening phone call questionnaire included just two questions about patients’ comorbidities: a history of high blood pressure and diabetes.
Patients who answered yes to those questions received a second phone call from a nurse, but the information gathered did not always pertain to anesthesia, and medications were not discussed.
In addition, patients’ presurgical screening visits took place just 1 or 2 days before surgery, which did not allow enough time for additional clearances to be obtained, medications to be changed or stopped, or diagnostic tests to be interpreted for further recommendations.
To restructure the PSC, we first had to identify the goals of the clinic and figure out how to meet those objectives. The best approach, we found, was to analyze our patient population, the types of procedures performed, and the surgical volume.
One goal was to see patients and process diagnostic tests at least 5 days before the scheduled procedure.
Standardization helps meet many goals and can occur at many levels—including performance of assessments and testing, organization of the patient chart, system checks throughout the process to make sure nothing is missed, and team-to-team communication. Using research-based evidence to capture a goal of standardizing practice, we sought to create a staffing design in which all registered nurses would run the PSC under the leadership of anesthesia providers.
As part of the PSC redesign, we developed a process using a sequential assembly of patients’ medical information several days in advance of the scheduled surgery.
The new staffing design, using all RNs, incorporated the patient screening call, patient visit, and compilation of medical information, which was analyzed by the anesthesia provider.
The RN was able to complete the screening call, make the appointment for the patient to come to the PSC for a visit, and then assess the patient at the clinic. The RN compiled the patient information and looked for abnormal test results. The anesthesia provider then used this information to best optimize the patient before the scheduled day of surgery.
Implementation of an electronic health record was a key resource for tracking patient information and outcomes. Changing the PSC reporting structure and standardizing practice among anesthesia providers allowed the nursing staff to focus on the required anesthetic needs related to the patient’s comorbid condition.
The nursing staff learned what anesthesia information was required through department meetings led by the anesthesia providers. This change shifted the priority from the type of surgery the patient was having to the patient’s health condition.
The restructured PSC program design reflects the efficiency of an improved workflow that allows time to complete steps that otherwise could result in a delay or cancellation (sidebar above).
The PSC changes demonstrate improvement in operational efficiency and patient satisfaction. The changes in clinic operations have led to:
The value of reducing day-of-surgery cancellations is supported in the literature—a 2012 Tulane study cites the cost per cancelled case at $4,550. Using that number to calculate the cost of 15 cancellations per month at our facility translates into a monthly cost of $68,250. After we changed our PSC processes and reporting structure, the cancellation rate fell to 0.4 canceled cases per month.
Although these changes were significant, the statistical analysis does not differentiate which single change may have had the most impact. Rather, the results suggest that the collective changes made to the PSC were necessary to achieve the level of significance in producing the outcomes. ✥
Timothy Flint, DrAP, CRNA, formerly with Lexington Medical Center, is now director of surgery, anesthesia & business operations at Beaumont Hospital-Taylor, Taylor, Michigan. Throughout his career, he has been involved in project improvement initiatives leading to reduced surgical turnover times and case cancellations, and increasing on-time starts.
Balk E. Routine perioperative testing: Comparative testing review. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. May 14, 2013;1-12.
Kumar A, Srivastava U. Role of routine laboratory investigations in preoperative evaluation. J Anesth Clin Pharmacol. 2011;27(2):174-179.
Gupta A, Gupta N. Setting up and functioning of a preanesthetic clinic. Indian J Anesth. 2010;54(6):504-507.
Correll D, Bader A, Hull M, et al. Value of preoperative clinic visits in identifying issues with potential impact on operating room efficiency. Anesthesiology. 2006;105:1254-1259.
Starsnic M, Guarnieri D, Norris M. Efficacy and financial benefit of an anesthesiologist-directed university preadmission evaluation center. J Clin Anesth. 1997;9:299-305.
Fischer S. Development and effectiveness of an anesthesia preoperative evaluation clinic in a teaching hospital. Anesthesiology. 1996;85:196-206.
Parker B, Tetzlaff J, Litaker D, et al. Redefining the preoperative evaluation process and the role of the anesthesiologist. J Clin Anesth. 2000;12:350-356.
Bader A, Sweitzer B, Kumar A. Nuts and bolts of preoperative clinics: The view from three institutions. Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine. 2009:76(4):104-111.
Ryan J, Lewis C, Doster B, et al. Evaluating and improving the perioperative process: Benchmarking and redesign of preoperative patient evaluations. IEEE Computer Society. 2012;2991-3000.
Bent S, Mora A, Russo S, et al. The financial burden of cancelled surgeries: Implications for performance improvement. American Society of Anesthesiology Practice Management Conference, 2012.