January 19, 2023

Assessing options for post-warranty equipment maintenance

By: David Cotriss
Share

When making decisions about technology and equipment, there is a tendency to focus on immediate productivity increases—or perhaps, practical aspects such as carrying out an implementation or training staff. But here is another major issue: how to maintain OR equipment once the warranty runs out.

This is more complex than it sounds. For one, extending a contract with the original manufacturer is not always possible. Even worse, the environment is fraught with risks because of malpractice and a lack of knowledge about relevant regulations. Medical providers must ensure they understand the applicable regulations, their options, and how to vet solutions providers.

 

The maintenance dilemma

It is no secret that the OR is home to all kinds of equipment, including imaging, IT, lab, surgical, and more. When these apparatuses require repairs or maintenance, the often high costs associated with those issues may not be visible because of the warranties in place, but warranties that come with the purchases do not last forever.

At that point, medical providers have four main options:

• an extended service contract with the original equipment manufacturer (OEM)

• the same contract but with an independent service organization (ISO) vendor

• self-funding the cost of any repairs or maintenance

• acquiring third-party insurance.

Each of these options comes with its own set of pros and cons. Let us take a closer look at what to expect from extended service contracts, the current state of regulation, and what to consider when making this decision.

 

Understanding extended service contracts

An extended service contract (ESC) is an agreement that provides additional coverage for the repair, maintenance, or replacement of equipment or machinery. In the medical equipment industry, it generally lasts between 3 and 5 years.

ESCs offer peace of mind for many medical providers, but they still face various issues such as the possibility of a vendor failing or not complying with regulations properly. The regulation of ESCs in the US is largely handled by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), which developed the Service Contracts Model Act #685 to provide a legal framework for the definition and sale of service contracts.

This requires ESC vendors to show a reimbursement insurance policy to back their contracts, maintain a financial security deposit with the insurance commissioner as well as a funded reserve account, and have a net worth of at least $100 million. They must also file 10Ks (annual financial reports) with the insurance office.

Andy R. Gastley

Currently, 38 states have adopted the Model Act, and some states have supplemented the Model Act with their own versions—for example, the Model Act only addresses business-to-consumer contracts, but some states have extended it to include business-to-business (B2B) contracts as well.

To make matters even more complex, many vendors of ESCs are unaware of these regulatory requirements and many fly under the radar.

“Most states have overlooked B2B service contracts and have therefore overlooked the insurance component,” points out Andy R. Gastley, president of A.G. Roth Insurance and national sales director of FaciliGuard, a medical equipment supplier in Savannah, Georgia.

 

How to choose

The rest of this article will run through the maintenance options for medical providers in further detail. But first, let’s briefly run through the core considerations.

Mike Van Derveer

Mike Van Derveer, vice president of supplier solutions and services at PartsSource Health, an online healthcare marketplace, believes there are four main areas to weigh: cost, quality, availability, and flexibility.

“Cost and quality are obvious, but availability and flexibility are equally important,” says Van Derveer. “Flexibility can be defined as the ability to pivot away from the decision as markets and price points change. Availability refers to access to multiple qualified service technicians and options to ensure there is a primary, plus several backup options.” He also believes that skills should be considered and says they ultimately affect the whole experience.

Pete Reilly

Pete Reilly, practice leader and chief sales officer of insurance brokerage Hub International’s North American healthcare practice, puts more emphasis on costs and believes a straightforward cost analysis is often the most effective way to choose the right root. “Given the rising costs of both products and services at this time, ensuring that the value of the insured equipment is sufficient and accurate is key,” he says. “The challenge faced at the moment is an environment of rising rates that will increase premiums.”

 

OEM contracts

The most straightforward and obvious choice for equipment maintenance is to opt for a contract with an OEM. These tend to be huge companies, which often means greater financial stability.

They are also likely to have more credibility and be knowledgeable about the relevant equipment, making them seem like a reliable choice. Gastley points out that manufacturers should have the necessary parts and a decent response time.

Yet, it is essential to proceed with caution before committing to a contract. This includes:

• asking if they have a reimbursement insurance policy (and obtaining a copy for proof)

• checking with the relevant state insurance commissioner that they’re complying with regulations

• asking to see financial reserves.

When working with an independent or small manufacturer, this process is even more crucial because they are more likely to encounter problems.

Another potential issue is the need for more flexibility. On this point, “OEM contracts are historically not cancellable without a hefty penalty,” Van Derveer explains. “In addition, OEM contracts do not allow the removal of an asset unless it is salvaged or replaced with a new model from the same OEM. This can be challenging because the options in the market are always changing. If you’re locked into a multiyear agreement, you can’t participate in any other options or take advantage of the savings until they expire.”

 

Contracts with ISO vendors

A similar yet alternative option is to take out an ESC with an ISO vendor instead of the OEM.

Some providers turn to ISO vendors due to lower prices when compared to OEMs. Gastley says the difference can be as significant as a 15% to 20% reduction.

However, they come with their fair share of risks. ISO vendors are unlikely to be filed with the insurance commissioner’s department, and many lack sufficient reserves to protect their clients.

“It is key to understand the ability to cancel, as the turnover of local technicians will lead to the need to explore alternatives,” says Van Derveer. “The legality of the offerings is typically reviewed by in-house legal counsel prior to signing. Like any small to midsize business, you must feel comfortable with the organization’s financial stability and ability to perform quality service.”

Reilly, on the other hand, is slightly more optimistic. “In most instances, these arrangements are perfectly legitimate and perform as planned when needed,” he adds.

 

Self-funding, no contracts

Another straightforward option is to forgo any contracts or insurance policies and shoulder the costs instead. The control this offers can be appealing, yet it may only be suitable in some cases.

Self-funding is mostly favored by larger hospitals with significant in-house teams and funding, or it is used for individual, less expensive equipment.

Gastley has found that self-funding can offer the same cost savings as ISO vendors compared to OEM contracts while also allowing facilities to change vendors as needed. “As with any insurance or warranty product, it is best to absorb small expenses yourself to the best of your ability,” he explains. “Does your facility have a competent biomed team? What can you repair in-house? Typically, the more expensive the machine, the more expensive the parts and labor are. I see radiology ESCs more often than contracts on autoclaves, for example.”

 

Third-party insurance

The last option for extended service coverage is to buy an ESC from a third-party insurance company. In this case, instead of paying the OEM or an ISO vendor directly, you would pay an insurance company, which would then assume the role of the OEM or ISO and bear the risk of parts failure.

This option can offer added protection because insurance companies are regulated by the state insurance commissioner’s department and graded by companies that publish their financial information. They are also generally “vendor-neutral,” meaning you can switch vendors during the policy period if needed—unlike the limited flexibility of OEM or ISO contracts.

According to Reilly, insurance options available may offer cost savings over typical maintenance agreements, and he has not found that they increase delays. “Like most insurance, a careful analysis of the policy is warranted,” he adds. “The insurance company should always have a strong financial rating of A– or better. Too often, insurance companies with lesser financial strength offer competitive pricing. But if they are unable to pay claims, those ‘short-term savings’ are a fool’s errand.”

Van Derveer advises that insurance contracts are most suitable for non-mission critical assets, equipment with redundancy, and equipment that your internal team or local ISO is able to service.

Overall, there is no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to choosing between extended service contracts with OEMs or ISOs, self-funding, or opting for an insurance policy. Depending on your priorities, capabilities, and the type of equipment your facility carries, you may choose any of the laid-out options or even find that a mixture of the options outlined above is the optimal solution.

Whichever route chosen, be aware of the relevant regulations, such as the Model Act #685, and properly vet all vendors and providers.

—David Cotriss is a healthcare freelance writer based in California.

 

Resource

Service Contracts Model Act, National Association of Insurance Commissioners 685-1. NAIC Model Laws, Regulations, Guidelines and Other Resources. January 1997.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat