Over my 40-year career—after starting at the bedside in surgical intensive care, moving to emergency medicine, and then to perioperative services—I have been fortunate to progress into executive leadership positions in academic medical center health systems and community hospitals, consult with a top global advisory firm, and now work in healthcare software technology. I have seen remarkable advances in surgical technology such as minimally invasive surgery, robotic-assisted procedures, and computer-aided surgery, leading to delivery of safer, quality care, improved outcomes, less pain, and faster recovery.
Just a few years ago, these advances would have seemed futuristic.
During this same period, I had also seen little in the way of technological advances to transform the business side of OR management, even though adding as little as one case each day or improving room utilization by 1% can significantly impact a health system’s bottom line. While perioperative leaders are always looking for ways to improve performance and maximize primetime OR utilization, difficulty to access data, limited analytics, and manual processes mean that balancing the supply and demand has remained stagnant and difficult. Effectively utilizing ORs is complex, multifaceted, and at a minimum requires:
• finding and filling available OR time
• having perioperative staff and specialized equipment available to meet that demand.
Open scheduling in the OR—the model of first-come, first-served scheduling—was the standard for years. However, perioperative leaders continually struggled with the unpredictable chaos of scheduling, rescheduling or canceling cases, and communicating updates clearly and in a timely manner. The end result was underutilized rooms, misaligned staffing and resources, and dissatisfied surgeons.
Today, block scheduling is a common approach in the OR. It has particular value in addressing the complexities involved with case variability across multiple surgeons and service lines, and it delivers a number of benefits, including predictability and better management.
The benefits to surgeons, perioperative leaders, and health systems are clear:
• Surgeons have confidence they can book a procedure on a given day using one of their recurring blocks, and that the necessary staff and resources will be available.
• Perioperative leaders can align block allocation by surgeon or service line and have some measure of future cases predictability, allowing them to better schedule and assign resource needs, such as an anesthesiologist and specialized equipment.
• Health systems can have their biggest revenue generating resource— the OR—operating optimally.
Although block allocation certainly has its benefits, there remains a disconnect when the most technologically advanced and profitable department in the hospital is being scheduled with antiquated and manual processes. Managing the block schedule is a high-profile, high-stakes task, but rigid and burdensome procedures continue to prevent significant changes to the status quo. With most of the day centered around entering surgical bookings into the electronic health record (EHR) along with the time-consuming work of communicating updates and confirmations across multiple parties, the tracking and management of release and block time requests often takes a back seat.
It is understandable that this is the case, as the process around managing block releases and requests consists of receiving requests via phone call or email, tracking requests on Post-It notes or personal spreadsheets, and making phone calls to identify potential recipients of released time.
To complicate matters, creating OR time, scheduling staff, allocating surgical blocks, and making other critical resource decisions, are typically done far in advance of booking cases. When block releases happen late and/or auto-release policies create open time with little to no lead time, perioperative leaders still scramble to fit in cases at the last minute, which often leaves unused time. In my experience, it is not uncommon to find ORs with over 90% of prime-time allocated, but less than 60% of utilization.
In the last few years, I have been fortunate enough to experience digital transformation on the logistics side of OR management. New technology-enabled platforms are improving the way perioperative leaders create, find, and fill OR time in ways that would have seemed impossible just a few years ago. There is a lot to unpack about how digitally transforming OR room management allows perioperative leaders to eliminate the traditional hurdles that impede maximum OR utilization.
By predicting and pinpointing scheduling inefficiencies, digitizing visibility into available OR time, and enhancing transparency and communication across all stakeholders, perioperative leaders are using technology to dynamically manage capacity through the inevitable ebb and flow of case volume. Using an operational management platform puts all relevant data and analytics at the fingertips of perioperative leaders so they can easily manage OR time, provide transparency and access to surgeons, and align staffing and equipment needs.
With automated insights such as predictions of which blocks are most likely to go unused and automated prompting to blockholders to release them weeks in advance, these technology-enabled platforms give surgeons/services sufficient time to fill those valuable primetime slots. These platforms even provide a “marketplace” to help surgeons and their staff directly manage and book OR time that best fits their and their patients’ schedules.
It is a pretty remarkable time to be in perioperative leadership; technology advancements are taking perioperative department performance to the next level by:
• enabling prescriptive recommendations for optimizing the block schedule so that understanding performance and block reallocation become automated and routine
• releasing time well in advance so blockholders can improve their performance metrics and increase the probability that time will be filled
• equipping schedulers with more accurate case length predictions that are unique to each case, using AI and patient/case-specific data vs an EHR rolling average; and, by using this data, enabling predictions for the total case length for multiprocedure cases rather than separate case lengths for each procedure
• providing access to an open marketplace of time so surgeons can easily find and request time, giving them the ability to build or maintain their practice and bring them a measure of steady predictability
• automating OR scheduler workflows and enabling streamlined communication with practices and service lines to improve engagement
• aligning OR staff and specialized equipment to true surgical demand without having them sit idle
• simplifying the governance process through transparency.
By modernizing OR scheduling management, health systems that are investing in digital transformation are much more resilient to disruptions. This allows health systems to maximize their overall financial performance throughout the fluidity of case volume, whether operating in a resilience, recovery, or routine mode.
• Resilience: When “weathering the storm” during constrained capacity and OR operating hours, it is vital to maximize every minute of OR time and staff resources to make available time and staff as productive as possible.
• Recovery: In periods of building back the business, finding time to prioritize and maximize the backlog of cases is key.
• Routine: During typical operations, maximizing OR utilization requires managing block time to drive access, increase utilization, and make sure the right staff and specialty equipment are available and scheduled for each case.
If all of this seems futuristic, I can tell you the future is now. I have worked with numerous healthcare organizations over the years that have seen the benefits digital transformation delivers to their OR utilization and have dozens of examples of the positive impact. If your institution has not explored technological advancements in OR management with the same rigor as surgical technology advancements, I encourage you to do so.
—Shawn Sefton, MBA, BSN, RN, is a nursing executive with more than 40 years of clinical and consulting experience that includes healthcare administration, clinical transformation, process redesign, and quality and cost structure improvements in various healthcare provider settings.