February 21, 2020

Back to basics: How collaboration can improve PACU patient flow

By: Catherine Spader, RN
Share

Healthcare technology can be a great thing, but nurses at Abington—Jefferson Health, in Abington, Pennsylvania, have discovered that sometimes stepping back from it is the best way to make progress. Going low-tech was the key that unlocked patient flow gridlock that had plagued the postanesthesia care unit (PACU).

Jennifer Prater, BSN, RN, CCRN, CPAN

Before 2017, PACU staff had experienced long holding times, and some patients never received bed assignments. “We were discharging some patients directly home after a day or two in the PACU,” says Jennifer Prater, BSN, RN, CCRN, CPAN, nurse manager, PACU and Same Day Post Op. “We felt that was a disservice to the patients because they might have missed some services they would have gotten on an inpatient unit, such as case management and other resources that are not in the PACU’s usual scope of practice.”

The situation reached a tipping point when some critical-care patients were held and cared for in the PACU until discharge. Patients received the standard of care, but it wasn’t through the normal pathway. “They never got an ICU bed, and they did not get care in the step-down unit, either. They missed two steps of their care,” says Katie Domrzalski, BSN, RN, team coordinator, PACU and Same Day Post Op.

Despite the fact that all PACU nurses are qualified to provide ICU care, patients and staff alike were frustrated by the situation. “The nurses felt like they couldn’t give the most optimal care,” says Prater. “PACU is designed to be a transitional unit, and as the manager, I was holding my breath because boarding patients put us at a high risk to make errors. We had to figure out a better way.”

In 2017, the PACU nurses decided it was time to take back surgical flow. After 2 years of data collection on patient flow and hold times, Prater and Domrzalski developed a simplified bed assignment plan, which was approved for a trial by the director of the Patient Flow Center (PFC) in spring 2017. The PFC is kept very busy controlling all bed assignments and patient flow throughout the organization, so the director and staff were receptive to an idea that might streamline their processes. “They decided to give it a try and see how it worked,” says Prater.

The preliminary plan was launched in July 2017 along with the Surgical Flow Collaborative. The collaborative included management, and PACU and postoperative surgical nurses met biweekly to monitor and fine-tune the plan. Their process included assessing the new plan and barriers to efficiency, developing strategies to overcome obstacles, and creating metrics to measure progress. All decisions were made by group consensus. By January 2018, the process had been streamlined enough to reduce meetings to a monthly schedule.

 

Eliminating time-consuming steps

The old process included a total of 14 steps to getting a bed assignment, many of which were done electronically. “There were a lot of barriers in the process,” says Prater. “First, we would send a message to the PFC and assume it had been received. Then the PFC would call the floor and wait for the charge nurse to call back with a bed assignment. Because the PFC is busy managing multiple, complex processes, there were times when a bed was ready for quite a while before they had a chance to enter it into the system. Each of these steps took more time, which all added up.”

In the new plan, a PACU nurse calls the floor charge nurse directly when a patient has met PACU discharge criteria and is ready for a bed. This eliminates seven time-consuming steps, cutting the process in half and saving significant time.

“The goal now is to receive a bed assignment on the first call to the charge nurse,” says Domrzalski. “If there are no empty beds, a time is discussed and set to get one.” For example, the PACU and unit charge nurses will discuss the times of imminent discharges and the patients who may be ready to be moved to another level of care, which will open beds. This tactic is especially helpful in getting critical-care surgical patients to the ICU as quickly as possible. They also agree on the time the primary nurse will take report and what to do if that nurse in not available at that time. “We set time goals for each step of the way,” says Domrzalski.

The data speaks for itself, and staff continue to collect and monitor the times from when patients meet PACU discharge criteria to when they are transported out. The findings are startling:

• flow times dropped from an average PACU wait time of 59.6 minutes in April 2017 to a wait time of 33.7 minutes in August 2019

• OR/PACU holds decreased from 42 holds/month (552 minutes) in April 2017 to zero OR/PACU holds in August 2019.

 

Taking a step back

Despite the success of the new patient flow model, there were concerns about the plan initially, says Prater. “I did not know how the process would be received because it felt like we were taking a step backward. The centralized PFC was a new concept at the time, and our plan was eliminating the electronic technology piece of it,” she says.

The primary role of the centralized PFC was promoting the flow and admission of patients through the emergency department (ED). It helped address the Joint Commission’s “The Patient Flow Standard” in 2014, which recommended having systems in place to prevent the boarding of ED patients for more than 4 hours.

“Our perception was that our patients were the last priority because they often got bumped for ED admissions and in-house transfers,” says Prater. “We felt we were competing for beds with other units.”

 

The secret to success

Katie Domrzalski, BSN, RN

So how did reducing the use of technology, instead of possibly increasing it, lead to such success? Domrzalski says the human factor and the Surgical Flow Collaborative were crucial elements. “Before the collaborative, a lot of communication was done through the computer. Now we meet monthly in person, and we put a face to the email or voice on the phone.”

During the Surgical Flow Collaborative meetings, the PACU and unit charge nurses evaluate metrics and discuss concerns and areas that still need to be addressed, such as emerging obstacles to patient flow. “The charge nurses are at the meetings to speak their minds about their real issues and challenges,” says Domrzalski. “We listen to their ideas and try to help make things better, so they know their voices are heard.”

The collaborative also provides the units with monthly data, so they can see areas of improvement and those that still need work. “The unit staff love getting the data,” says Prater. “It has been eye opening for them to see that our patients were waiting so long and why and how that was happening. We didn’t know what other units were dealing with, either, so this process has been enlightening for us, too. We have learned so much about the workflow throughout the hospital and each other’s pressures and challenges.”

 

Improving give and take

Sidestepping some technology in favor of more human contact has fostered more flexibility, a kind of “give and take” between nurses that is not built into computer programs, says Prater. “In the past, we were told that we would have to hold a patient—end of discussion. Now bed assignments are a nurse-to-nurse conversation. We are all working together to improve overall patient flow,” she says.

For example, the charge nurses may negotiate holding a stable surgical patient in the PACU, so the surgical unit bed can be used for a patient who is ready to transfer from the ICU. This opens the ICU bed for a critical-care surgical patient.

“Holding a general surgical patient a little longer is more appropriate than holding an ICU patient,” says Prater. “We now talk though these kinds of situations to make decisions that work best for everybody, especially the patients.”

Working together has increased the understanding and trust between the units. “The nurses feel more like a part of the process and the decision making, but for this process to succeed, all the nursing staff have to be on board,” says Prater. “They are the ones doing the work of caring for patients; they have to be engaged with the process.”

 

Ongoing challenges, unexpected benefits

The new patient flow process was relatively easy to get off the ground, but the collaborative is still ironing out some of the kinks. This includes challenges ensuring consistent, accurate documentation as well as moving patients near shift change.

“Shift change is always a thorn in the side,” says Domrzalski. “Trying to be flexible for shift change is complex, and we haven’t nailed it quite yet.”

Along with ongoing process improvement challenges, the staff have also discovered unexpected benefits of the process.

“I did not realize how much we would benefit from making this change,” says Domrzalski. “The new process created a cascading effect throughout the entire surgical department, resulting in decreased OR holds, which cleared up the bottleneck in preop. This has been a huge satisfier for surgical patients and staff.”

In fact, OR hold minutes dropped dramatically from 4,797 minutes in 2016 to 75 minutes in 2019.

The process has also given new purpose and meaning to the charge nurse role. “Our charge nurses must really use their critical-thinking skills to keep patients moving appropriately and safely,” says Domrzalski. “It has also improved the rapport between them.”

 

Yours, mine…ours

Prater and Domrzalski believe Abington—Jefferson Health’s new patient flow process can be replicated successfully in any healthcare organization. The keys are to keep communication open between the units and prioritize patient needs—something nurses excel at. Abington—Jefferson Health’s nurses have embraced collaborating with other units for the good of all their patients. “More often, we hear the nurses refer to ‘our patients’ instead of ‘my patient’ and ‘your patient,’” says Prater. “There is a role for technology in healthcare, but we can’t forget the importance of nurse-to-nurse interaction.” ✥

–Catherine Spader, RN, is a medical writer, editor, and award-winning fiction author based in Littleton, Colorado.

 

Reference

Prater J, Domrzalski K. Taking Back Surgical Flow. Poster, 2019 OR Manager Conference.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat