Even when recommended cleaning and disinfection protocols are followed, residual contamination of instruments is possible, researchers have found (OR Manager, November 2016, 1, 10-11). Visual inspection can catch some signs of contamination, but it won’t reveal problems within channels and other areas of complex medical devices. That’s why it’s important to conduct cleaning verification tests.
Cleaning verification is recommended in the 2016 edition of the AORN Guidelines for Perioperative Practice and in the 2013 American National Standards Institute/Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI) ST 79 Comprehensive Guide to Steam Sterilization and Sterility Assurance in Health Care Facilities.
Following these recommendations and implementing quality control measures will help lessen the likelihood of contamination. This article will explore the different types of cleaning verification tests.
Cleaning is the physical removal of soil, whereas disinfection and sterilization are processes that kill microorganisms under a defined set of conditions. When mechanical cleaning equipment is used, malfunctions may occur and cannot always be detected easily. Even though the cleaning action can be seen, there may be a problem with the water quality, detergent dosing, type of detergent, equipment performance, or other factors.
Performing cleaning verification is a way to improve performance, ensure quality, and evaluate the competency of new employees or the processes for new medical devices. There are cleaning verification tests to gauge cleanliness of medical devices and to clean equipment. This article will review both types of tests.

Borescopes make it possible to view internal channels. All photos courtesy of Susak Klacik, BS, ACE, CHL, CRCST, FCS.
In the decontamination process, automatic cleaning equipment is used. Monitoring and verification of cleaning processes should be documented.
Some mechanical washers have printouts to review at the end of the cycle, but those printouts may lack critical information such as whether the pump is working, the correct detergent is being used, the spray arms are clogged, and so on. It is important to consult the mechanical equipment manufacturers’ instructions for use (IFU) for safe and effective operation, along with the cleaning verification test IFU.
Automatic cleaning equipment should be tested to ensure it is functioning properly. There are cleaning verification tests for the ultrasonic washer, washer/decontaminator, cart washer, and the automatic endoscope reprocessor (AER).
Both AAMI and AORN recommend testing decontamination equipment weekly—preferably daily—upon installation, during routine use, and after major repairs. Replacement of the water pump(s), detergent delivery system, heating system, water delivery system, water treatment system, or computer control would be considered major repairs.
A test device is used for cleaning verification that directly tests for residual soils, verifies that the cleaning process did clean the surface, and measures specific key parameters to evaluate the functionality of the cleaning equipment. Cleaning verification tests should be documented.
Washer/decontaminators clean by impingement action, ie, the mechanical action of pressurized water forced through the spray action of the spray arms to remove debris. Therefore, the spray arms must be clear and unobstructed, and the correct cleaning chemistries and temperature must be used. Cleaning verification tests check to ensure all of these are in place.
The washer/decontaminator test should be performed using an empty washer to remove any variation in loading. This test can also be used to demonstrate proper loading. An overcrowded load will not pass a cleaning verification test. The IFU for the washer verification test will provide the specifics of how to perform the test, including the placement of items in the load.
An ultrasonic washer cleans by cavitation. Cavitation is produced from the transducers, which are usually located on the bottom of an ultrasonic bath. Instruments are subjected to high-frequency, high-energy sound waves that cause the soil to dislodge from the instruments and drop to the bottom of the tank, or to be sufficiently loosened that it will be removed during the rinsing process.
If the ultrasonic washers fail the cleaning test, that means either the sonic bath conditions were faulty, or one or more of the ultrasonic transducers was not working correctly.
Problems can include using the incorrect water level, detergent, or time; using the wrong type of basket; or having a mechanical failure.
There are two types of testing to perform: one for initial setup and after repairs, and one for routine testing.
The initial setup test and for testing after major repairs is to verify uniform distribution of cavitation in the sonic cleaner generated by the ultrasonic transducers.
Uniform distribution of sonic cavitation is required for the cleaning to demonstrate all of the transducers are functioning.
This type of testing is also used to identify broken transducers in the sonic bath. The test is performed by placing the verification tests evenly throughout the sonic bath. The amount of tests varies depending on the size of the ultrasonic bath.
A routine test, performed weekly (preferably daily), verifies that proper cavitation is taking place. The routine test is performed under normal conditions in an empty tank, and the amount of verification test depends on the size of the ultrasonic bath.
There are verification tests for ultrasonic washers that irrigate channels to verify the flushing mechanism is functioning.
Instrument inspection is a part of reprocessing—even with the mechanical cleaning verification tests to verify that the mechanical washing equipment is functioning.
Visual inspection or cleaning verification occurs after the initial cleaning step but before the sterilization or disinfection step.
Traditional instrument inspection has been visual, and although that is still the most widely used, lighted magnification is also being used to better identify debris, staining, and flaws.
The use of lighted magnification is included in some IFUs and in the 2016 AORN and 2013 AAMI guidelines.
One of the most challenging visual inspections is for channels. Borescopes are available to view internal channels, including for flexible endoscopes. There are also cleaning verification tests for these medical devices.
An adenosine triphosphate (ATP) monitor is a verification tool that provides cleanliness marker levels that are measured quantitatively to assess the type and amounts of soil present on a medical device.
ATP is a molecule that is present in all living organisms; hence, it is present in clinically relevant soils such as tissue, cells, excretions, secretions, body fluids, and microbes.
The ATP monitor can provide real-time feedback on the effectiveness of the cleaning process so that staff can immediately see whether any quality issues need to be addressed.
This method can sample both instrument surfaces and internal instrument channels. To determine the cleanliness of an instrument, the monitor is swabbed with a proprietary swab, and the sample collected from this swab is placed into a luminometer. The results are provided in relative light units (RLU). The higher the RLU number, the more contaminated the sample.
The RLU provides a metric for measuring cleanliness and for quality monitoring reports. The benchmark for cleanliness is set to a predetermined pass/fail level. Unlike sterilization, there is no zero result in the RLU number. Even a perfectly clean sample will not give a zero result because the instrument and the ATP test device will have a “background” RLU level. In addition, the character of the tested surface will affect the results.
There are different manufacturers of ATP cleaning verification tests, and it is important to follow their IFUs. Not all ATP systems have validated pass/fail benchmarks. Before investing in an ATP cleaning verification system, check first for validation data.
Protein, blood, and carbohydrates are organic soils seen in healthcare that are a significant part of bioburden. Having organic residue on a surface can result in cross-contamination.
To detect organic residue, a swab or a brush is used to test the surface and then is placed into a vial with a test solution. A color change to the solution indicates the presence of organic residue.
This test method is also used for medical devices with channels such as flexible endoscopes.
Some test kits use brushes or swabs pushed through the channel, and others require a specific amount of water (preferably sterile water) flushed through the channel into a clean (preferably sterile) container. Next, a residual indicator is placed into the container, and a color change indicates organic residue. Some test kits use test strips that are compared to an accompanying results chart.
The IFUs for these tests provide the correct amount of testing solution, applicator (brush or swab), contact time, and method of test collection.
Fluorescent protein detection systems visualize and measure invisible residual proteins on surgical instruments after cleaning and before sterilization.
These systems show exactly where and how much protein is present on a surgical instrument by presenting a three-dimensional picture of the instrument with the concentration of protein in any given location.
After the cleaning process is completed, the instrument can be tested. The instrument is placed in the fluorescent protein detection system and sprayed with a reagent. Within minutes, an image of the instrument is displayed showing where and how much protein is present.
Cleaning verification is used for both mechanical cleaning and manual cleaning. Implementing cleaning verification systems, taking action when the results show unacceptable ranges, and keeping a record of these tests will enhance the quality processes of central sterile systems. ✥
Susan Klacik, BS, ACE, CHL, CRCST, FCS, is president, Klacik Consulting (Klacik.consulting.com), in Canfield, Ohio, and CSS manager at St Elizabeth Health Center and the IAHCSMM (International Association of Healthcare Central Service Materiel Management) representative to AAMI (Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation).
American National Standards Institute/Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation. Comprehensive guide to steam sterilization and sterility assurance in health care facilities. ANSI/AAMI ST79:2010 & A1:2010 & A2:2011 & A3:2012 & A4:2013. www.aami.org.
AORN. Sterilization and disinfection. Guidelines for Perioperative Practice. Denver: AORN, 2016. 675-850. www.aorn.org.