November 14, 2016

ASC quality scores added to Hospital Compare

By: OR Manager
Share

Ambulatory surgery center (ASC) quality scores became public for the first time in 2016.

ASCs and regulators including the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) say they are pleased to have documentation of their track records. But what do the scores really mean, and how useful, exactly, are they to patients?

Opinions vary, and the scores themselves are hardly front-page news, buried as they are in lengthy tables. One thing is sure, however: ASCs at last have something concrete to show for the hours they have spent recording quality measures such as rates of patient burns and falls as well as employee vaccination rates.

 

Signs of improvement

The Ambulatory Surgical Center Quality Reporting (ASCQR) Program has posted results for the first two quarters of 2016 on Medicare’s Hospital Compare website. At the same time, the ASC Quality Collaboration (ASC QC), which developed the original quality measures, published its own summary of the results and trends for selected measures.

For example, between the third quarter of 2015 and the second quarter of 2016, the rate of patient falls per 1,000 ASC admissions rose to 0.104 from 0.099. However, the rate appears to be trending downward from a high of 0.123 falls per 1,000 admissions in the first quarter of 2016. Of course, all of these rates, which are based on approximately 1.8 million admissions, are extremely low.

The picture is similar for patient burns. From a high of 0.024 burns per 1,000 admissions in the fourth quarter of 2015, the rate dropped to 0.011 in the second quarter of 2016.

The rate of hospital transfers fluctuated in a similar manner, rising from a low of 0.998 in the fourth quarter of 2015 to a high of 1.067 in the first quarter of 2016 and dropping back to 1.008 in the second quarter of this year.

The full results are available on the ASC QC website, www.ascquality.org. One reason ASC QC tabulated its own results, according to executive director Donna Slosburg, BSN, LHRM, CASC, is that ASCs and their patients will find it easier to read than the Medicare version, which is located on a section of the better-known Hospital Compare site.

Some states, such as New Hampshire, also publish quality results based on their own analyses. In its September 2016 announcement, the New Hampshire Department of Health and Human Services compares the state’s rate of surgical site infections with national results. Statewide, ASCs reported three cases of infection in 2015, four in 2014, six in 2013, and four in 2012.

“The overall observed number of surgical site infections in New Hampshire ASCs was 53% fewer than predicted based on national data; however, this difference is not significant and is considered similar to national data,” the report concludes.

Donna Quinn, MBA, BSN, RN, CAPA, CPAN

Donna Quinn, MBA, BSN, RN, CAPA, CPAN

Donna Quinn, MBA, BSN, RN, CAPA, CPAN, director of the Orthopedic Surgery Center in Concord, New Hampshire, says the data are reassuring and useful as benchmarks, but otherwise make little difference to ASCs or the public.

“I can look at my data, and it looks pretty good,” she says. “But the numbers are so low, and reporting is cumbersome.” Like other ASCs contacted by OR Manager, the Orthopedic Surgery Center has had no questions from patients regarding the quality results.

“But we’ll keep reporting to avoid the financial loss,” Quinn says, referring to the 2% reduction in Medicare reimbursement to ASCs that do not report quality data.

 

Quality benchmarks

The 2016 Medicare tables cover national, state-by-state, and facility-level reports on these measures:

• ASC 1: patient burn

• ASC 2: patient fall

• ASC 3: wrong site, side, patient, procedure, or implant

• ASC 4: hospital transfers

• ASC 5: timing of prophylactic antibiotics

• ASC 6: safe surgery checklist use

• ASC 7: annual case volume for selected procedures: eye, gastrointestinal, genitourinary, musculoskeletal, nervous system, respiratory, skin, and multisystem

• ASC 8: vaccination of healthcare personnel against influenza

ASCs will begin reporting on the following measures in 2017, and compliance will affect Medicare payments in 2018:

• ASC 9: colonoscopy intervals for average-risk patients

• ASC 10: colonoscopy intervals for patients with previous adenomatous polyps

• ASC 11: vision improvement following cataract surgery (reporting is voluntary)

• ASC 12: hospital visit within 7 days after colonoscopy.

Reporting to CMS will begin in 2018 for these additional measures, and affect payments in 2020, if a proposed CMS rule is finalized:

• ASC 13: normothermia (body temperature of 96.8°F) within 15 minutes of arrival in the postanesthesia care unit

• ASC 14: unplanned anterior vitrectomy during cataract surgery

• ASC 15: patient response to the Outpatient and Ambulatory Surgery Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (OAS CAHPS).

CMS is asking for ASC comments before proposing an additional measure for 2018, the occurrence of toxic anterior segment syndrome during ophthalmic procedures.

 

More data, less information?

Even as the list of ASC quality measures grows, some are questioning whether the information they produce is worth the trouble. In an August letter to acting CMS administrator Andrew Slavitt, the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPac) suggested that ASC 5, antibiotic timing, and ASC 8, influenza vaccination, could be dropped because—as with hospitals—ASCs are now almost totally compliant.

“We encourage CMS to examine whether the measure of prophylactic IV antibiotic timing remains useful in the ASC setting. Quality measures are considered ‘topped out,’ and no longer useful, when performance is so high and unvarying that meaningful distinctions among providers and improvement in performance can no longer be made….This burden of this measure could outweigh its value within the ASCQR,” the letter stated.

MedPac also warns that ASC 7, the facility volume measure, could have the side effect of leading ASCs to try to increase patient volume just to improve their scores.

MedPac urges CMS to reconsider its decision to allow ASCs to opt out of making their quality reports public. If publication is voluntary, MedPac says, the resulting information will create a distorted picture of ASC performance, and reduce the usefulness of the data.

According to CMS, there were 331 requests from ASCs to suppress data from 2013 or 2014, or both years.

In its comment letter to Slavitt, the ASC QC proposes (as does MedPac) that ASCs be given 60 days, rather than the present 30 days, to preview their results before they are published. “ASCs are generally small providers whose staff does not include a team member dedicated solely to managing quality reporting requirements,” ASC QC notes.

ASCs also wonder if the published results will have any meaning for patients. For one thing, by the time of publication, the numbers are 2 years old. “The public information is out of date,” Tracy Hoeft-Hoffman, MSN, MBA, RN, CASC, administrator of Fremont Health Surgery Center in Fremont, Nebraska, says. “If we have a patient burn, we’re going to find the cause and make sure it’s not going to happen again. Yet, that will appear 2 years later on the Internet.”

Tracy Hoeft-Hoffman, MSN, MBA, RN, CASC

Tracy Hoeft-Hoffman, MSN, MBA, RN, CASC

While patients are becoming more active in researching healthcare providers, the main thing they are interested in is the cost of procedures, managers say. As Mary Stewart, MSN, RN, chief clinical officer of the Springfield Clinic, Springfield, Illinois, explains, “Our patients in general are using phone calls only to question pricing and infection rates. In our area, not many patients are aware of data.medicare, or at least have not mentioned it to us.”

Quinn reports, “I do not think patients will search for this stuff unless they have had a family member with a bad outcome that makes them aware of such information.”

According to a CMS spokesman, ASCs welcome the chance to have their quality scores made public.

“Feedback from the ASCs indicates they are pleased to have become part of CMS’ quality reporting structure. The public reporting forum of Hospital Compare gives them the opportunity to demonstrate the high quality of care provided in the ASC environment,” he says. “Individual ASCs can compare data in much the same way as the patients to compare facility performance. We provide state and national data so that ASCs can see how they fare in comparison with others,” he adds.

 

Navigating through Hospital Compare

To see a specific ASC’s score on the Hospital Compare site requires going through a multistep process. First, visit www.medicare.gov/hospitalcompare/asc-ambulatory-surgical-measures.html. Or, while on the Hospital Compare site, scroll down to the last menu item, “Get ambulatory surgical center quality (ASCQP) program data.”

Second, after reaching the page “Ambulatory surgical center quality reporting program,” scroll down to the first table, “Ambulatory surgical measure data—by facility.” Facilities are grouped by state.

Third, scroll down to the name of the ASC you are looking for. On the left, find the search symbol, three horizontal lines preceded by dots. Click on the symbol, and the ASC name, location, and scores for each measure will appear.

Another way to access the data is to visit the site data.medicare.gov. Click on “choose a data category.” On the next page, six choices appear; choose “hospital compare.”

A list of titles appears with brief explanations. The first three items on the list are ambulatory surgery center facility, national, and state scores. Continue clicking to open the desired files. You can then download the displayed numbers as an Excel, PDF, or other type of file by selecting one from a list of formats on the screen.

The process, as ASC managers have noted, is lengthy and complex compared with viewing the ASC QC reports, but some people are finding their way through the site, CMS reports indicate.

As of October 31, 2016, the ASC facility measures had received 20,331 views. ASC national results were viewed 8,580 times, and state results were viewed 8,959 times.

In a September 2010 letter to Slavitt, Slosburg recommended separating ASC results from those of hospitals.

“The current link to ASCQR Program data on Hospital Compare is not prominent, being but one of many in a list of quality program links. This is not user-friendly for consumers trying to find ASC information,” she wrote. “We would like to see CMS establish a website that is dedicated to ASCs, as it has done already for nursing homes, dialysis facilities, and home healthcare,” the letter said.

“I think eventually we’ll have our own space,” she says. ✥

 —Paula DeJohn

References

Ambulatory surgery center quality reporting program. www.medicare.gov/hospitalcompare.

ASC Quality Collaboration quality report 2nd Quarter 2016. www.ascquality.org/qualityreport.cfm.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat