July 23, 2018

Editorial

By: Elizabeth Wood
Share

Value-based payment (VBP) models of patient care have not been shown to effectively reduce healthcare costs, according to a recent report from the Healthcare Financial Management Association (HFMA). But that conclusion comes with several caveats, such as:

• It’s too soon to have data on programs like the Medicare Shared Savings Program, which was just getting started during the years covered in this report (2012 to 2014).

• Incentives are tied more to productivity-based compensation than to quality outcomes.

• Investments in infrastructure (eg, data analytics, care management) haven’t yet been offset by any savings achieved during the early years of VBP.

The authors say that the government and payers should continue experimenting with VBP models that could increase the quality and cost-effectiveness of care.

Leaders at the 2018 HFMA Annual Conference echoed this recommendation. In his keynote speech on June 25, HFMA President Joseph Fifer urged chief financial officers to implement payment models that truly share the risk and use metrics to assess the return on investment.

“If you invest, you’re part of the solution, even if your fee-for-service revenue goes down,” he said. “But if you don’t invest, someone else will. And the revenue could still go down.”

Why should you care about VBP? Because despite its rather slow evolution, healthcare leaders, financial experts, and policy makers agree that VBP isn’t going away. And it’s much more than a numbers game. VBP is based on the full episode of patient care, which involves a multidisciplinary approach.

Our cover story on social determinants is one example of how OR managers’ responsibilities are broadening to include patient care beyond the surgical suite. Although much of the literature on social determinants focuses on what healthcare administrators and primary care providers can do, OR managers and their staffs increasingly are taking on nontraditional tasks. That’s why leaders from the Cleveland Clinic will speak about social determinants at the 2018 annual OR Manager Conference.

 

VBP outlook

Despite doubts about profitability of VBP adoption, there are some signs of optimism. For example, in a recent poll conducted by KPMG LLP, an audit, tax, and advisory firm, 46% of healthcare organizations said value-based contracts improve profitability, even though fee-for-service contracts still dominate.

The 2018 HealthLeaders Media Value-Based Readiness Survey also suggests an increasingly optimistic outlook for VBP. Their data represent responses from 90 leaders at hospitals, health systems, physician organizations, and other providers.

Of those, 62% claim they are strongly prepared for value-based financial changes, and 54% say they are strongly prepared for value-based care delivery changes. They also project that net patient revenue tied to VBP will rise from the current rate of 21% to 44% within 3 years.

When it comes to care delivery, respondents see better care coordination and patient engagement as top priorities (cited by 70% and 68%, respectively). Yet answers to the question, “How well do your existing processes and systems support your care teams and practices in their coordination, communication, and patient outreach efforts?” were most revealing: Just 3% of respondents stated that theirs are “fully mature.”

Although 47% claimed to be “evolving to a mature state,” fully 50% were not nearly so far along in their process development.

 

Improving quality of care

Much has been written about the administrative burden of record keeping, and quality reporting is often viewed negatively. In an effort to reduce the burden, the American Medical Group Association recently came up with a list of 14 metrics for a value and quality measurement set for data reporting. Of those, the top three are:

• emergency department use per 1,000

• skilled nursing facility admissions per 1,000

• 30-day all cause hospital readmissions.

Several other metrics include screenings handled by primary care providers, but the top three are related to the quality of surgical patient care. OR Manager previously has examined the link between enhanced recovery after surgery protocols and improved outcomes. There is also a direct correlation between preadmission testing and outcomes (see articles on pages 14-19).

Improving patient care is the underlying theme of most OR Manager articles, and upcoming issues will feature a mix of clinical research and business management tactics to help you do that. We also provide invaluable continuing education at the annual OR Manager Conference (September 17-19, Nashville, Tennessee; http://2018.ormanagerconference.com/) and the 2019 OR Business Management Conference (January 27-30, San Diego; www.orbusinessmanagementconference.com).

We will share news from both events in the pages of OR Manager, but there are multiple benefits of being there, and we hope you’ll consider attending one or both of them. ✥

 

References

Bannow T. Hospitals ‘can’t afford not to’ provide value-based care. Modern Healthcare. July 2, 2018.

Cheney C. AMGA endorses 14 metrics for quality and value reporting. HealthLeaders Media. July 2, 2018.

Freeman G A. Healthcare providers much more optimistic about value-based care. HealthLeaders Media. July 2, 2018.

Landman J H, Moore K, Muhlestein D B, et al. What is driving the total cost of care? An analysis of factors influencing total cost of care in US healthcare markets. Healthcare Financial Management Association. June 25, 2018. https://www.hfma.org/tcoc/.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat