July 23, 2018

Full-scale mockup clears path to efficient new ORs

By: Judith M. Mathias, MA, RN
Share

Anyone who has been involved in an OR design and construction project knows it is a labor-intensive, time-consuming effort—and usually far from seamless. There’s almost always something no one thinks of until it is too late, and the staff must learn to live with the flaws. But a multidisciplinary team at Wesley Long Hospital in Greensboro, North Carolina, took an innovative approach based on Lean concepts that not only facilitated the process but also improved efficiency for the staff working in this new area.

To design their new perioperative space, the team knew they had to “think outside the box.” They built a full-scale cardboard mockup of their new perioperative space in an old warehouse that they called “cardboard city” (photo, right).

In cardboard city, teams re-enacted care delivery scenarios that informed the process of building the 10 new ORs and 20 postanesthesia care unit (PACU) bays.

More than 70 meetings with physicians and staff, in addition to shadowing each team member through their workday, allowed the designers to eliminate wasted space and inefficiency.

Building the mockup

The seven-hospital system known as Cone Health, of which Wesley Long Hospital is a part, began a project in 2015 called “Reinventing Care.” The project involved closing one hospital and redeploying services across their health system. Within this project were three new OR suites on the different campuses, one of which will be in a new tower.

“About 3 years ago, we knew we were going to build 10 new ORs and 20 PACU bays,” Karin Henderson, MSN, RN, CCRN-K, CENP, EDAC, executive director of strategic management at Cone Health, told OR Manager. This was a replacement project that was the first of three.

The system already had an operational Lean department to make workflow more efficient, Henderson says. However, they made a site visit to Seattle Children’s Hospital, which was working with operational Lean processes to build an outpatient surgery center.

At Seattle Children’s, they figured out their workflow first and then built their space around it to the extent that they don’t have any waiting rooms—patients enter the surgery center and go right into a preoperative area.

“We were really intrigued by this and found out they had mocked up a single OR out of cardboard,” says Henderson. Her team came up with the idea of building a full-scale cardboard mockup of all 10 ORs, 20 PACU bays, and sterile corridor. When they asked senior administration for $40,000 and an empty warehouse, they got full support for this new design and construction approach.

Traditionally, Henderson says, when doing a building project, a multidisciplinary team holds multiple meetings, looks at two-dimensional plans on paper, and signs off on them. Then, because it is difficult for most people to understand from paper how spaces actually work, teams may design and build spaces that are not efficient or don’t promote optimal patient care delivery.

“We didn’t want this to happen, so we built everything out of cardboard first,” she says. “We had everyone who was going to be working in the perioperative space—environmental services, respiratory, lab, physicians, and staff—give input into the building and arrangement of the cardboard mockup.”

A company produced the cardboard for mockup building, and the general contractor who was going to build the new space did the actual building of the mockup to scale.

The walls were about eight feet tall, and everything was to scale, even down to the cabinetry and the curve around the nurses station (photo, right).

 

Mapping the flows

Once cardboard city was built, the team mapped all of the flows through the area using the 7 Flows of Lean Healthcare, which included family, patients, healthcare staff, medications, information, supplies, and equipment.

“By mapping all of those flows through the mockup, we were able to determine before we built the perioperative space whether the equipment and supplies were in the right place, whether the flow of medication from practitioner to patient was without barriers, and whether there would be bottlenecks to patient throughput and the flow of families and staff,” she says.

“It was interesting to see the physicians, who might have been skeptical, walk through the mockup and point out right away that the isolation room, which isn’t used that often, was in a prime space, and the door into their lounge was wrong,” Henderson adds. “We moved the isolation room, and we changed the door into their lounge. Even the staff lounge and locker rooms were changed after the staff looked at the flow of the area.”

Initial assumptions for booms and lights changed as actual equipment was placed in the cardboard spaces and staff “test drove” equipment, says Henderson.

The vendors were asked to bring their equipment to the warehouse and place it in the cardboard rooms. The staff and surgeons then simulated patient care and tried out the booms and lights and other equipment and made selections based on how they worked in the cardboard mockup room (photo at right).

“A lot of hospitals will mock up one OR, but it is the whole picture and the whole flow through space that we found allowed for the greatest learning and ultimate value to our project,” she says.

“The room might be right, but if the nurse doesn’t have the right equipment and supplies in the right place, this takes valuable time away from the nurse-patient interaction,” Henderson says. “If you design the space that allows the staff to have what they need, at the right time, and in the right place, you ultimately support staff and patient satisfaction while enhancing quality and safety.”

The 10 ORs are built and operational, and the PACU bays will open in January 2019. Thus far, results include:

• Change orders are the lowest the hospital has ever seen on a construction project, down by more than 50%.

• Patient transport distances decreased by 15% from initial design to final approved design.

• The hospital had the highest employee project satisfaction scores ever attained during a design and construction process.

Since the new ORs opened, staff are beginning to quantify efficiencies in block times. “We are following this very closely because if we are able to free up an hour or two every day in an orthopedic block, that’s like gold,” she says.

Henderson’s team delivered a design that helped optimize workflows, equipment placement, and patient throughput pathways, so surgeons and staff can spend more time with their patients and provide exceptional care. ✥

References

Cardon K, Giffin H. Designing for hospital efficiency: Eight health care flows that improve operations and safety. Health Facil Manage. May 6, 2015. https://www.hfmmagazine.com/articles/1539-designing-for-hospital-efficiency

Henderson K, Fencl J. Way out of the box: A new approach for the design of perioperative spaces. Poster session. AORN Global Surgical Conference & Expo. 2018.

Hicks C, McGovern T, Prior G, et al. Applying Lean principles to the design of healthcare facilities. Int J Prod Econ. 2015;170(Part B):677-686.

Hogan M. The 7 flows of Lean health care. https://wearestudioplus.com/blog/2016/12/30/the-7-flows-of-lean-healthcare.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat