October 1, 2011

For ASC managers, it’s all about the economy

By: OR Manager
Share



OR Manager; Vol. 27 No. 10; October 2011



Financial challenges continue to buffet ambulatory surgery centers (ASCs), according to the 21st annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey.

Almost half (48%) of managers say their ASCs have experienced financial difficulties compared to 31% in 2009. The primary impact of the sagging economy is the continued decline in elective surgery, but that is just one effect of larger issues such as high unemployment, higher deductibles, and fewer independent physicians (related article, p 29).

Bright spots include the 1 in 5 who said case volume had increased in the past 6 months. When asked about their accomplishments, ASC managers’ responses included, “increased volume by 16%,” and “case numbers up from previous year.” One respondent said, “We have slowly turned this facility from the edge of bankruptcy.” Others reported renovations, new ORs, and high-ticket technology purchases such as electronic health records.

The OR Manager Salary/Career Survey was mailed in May 2011 to 1,000 OR Manager subscribers and an external list of nurse managers of ASCs. There were 198 usable responses for a 20% response rate. To ensure representation of the target audience, results were filtered to include only the 182 respondents who work full time in an ASC. The margin of error is ±6.7 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. Managers trace ASC financial difficulties to the slow economy. Of the half experiencing financial difficulty, 83% have done less elective surgery. Overall, 29% said volume had fallen in the past 6 months, compared to 14% in 2006. Other effects include changes in reimbursement (67%) and lack of available credit (17%).

Despite the decline in elective surgery, many managers say their ASCs are successfully weathering the economic climate. Nearly half (49%) said overall volume was unchanged in the past 6 months, and 22% said it had risen.

Managers are taking a familiar two-pronged approach to improving ASC spreadsheets: increasing volume and decreasing costs.

Expanding services such as urology, ophthalmology, general surgery, ENT, and orthopedics is a common way to boost volume. “Successfully increased case volume of orthopedics…has financially turned center profitable,” said one respondent. Another respondent said the ASC had “established an outpatient interventional radiology product line.” Examples of interventional radiology procedures being performed in the outpatient setting are placement of dialysis catheters, other vascular access procedures, liver biopsies, and angiography.

In the 6 months, the ASC’s volume has …
2011 2009 2007
Increased 22% 19% 46%
Decreased 29% 30% 14%
Remained about the same 49% 51% 39%

Source: Mercy Hospital Cadillac, Cadillac, Michigan.

Respondents to ASC survey
Region Response
Northeast 18%
Midwest 26%
South 33%
West 23%

ASC managers’ purchasing power

Do you influence the selection and purchase of …
OR supplies/ equipment 87%
OR capital equipment 79%
What best describes your involvement in purchasing decisions?
Member of committee 48%
Primary decision maker 46%
Advisory capacity 29%

Other managers are adding physicians to service lines. Sample comments include, “recruited several new physicians,” “added new surgeons,” and “adding more procedures/doctors.”

Some ASCs are expanding. “Build/open 2 additional ORs, additional waiting room space,” said one respondent. “Addition began to increase our center from 6 to 10 rooms,” said another, adding the ASC is completely redoing its entire facility.

In reducing costs, education has taken a hit. Nearly half (49%) of managers said their funding for attending education events has been reduced. Of these, 65% have limited funding, and 24% have eliminated it all together. Travel has been banned by 6%.

Other strategies include reducing supply costs and increasing efficiencies. Among comments were, “cost savings on various inventory products” and “reduction in cost of medical/surgical supplies.”

Facility profile

Most respondents (74%) are employed in multi-specialty ASCs, while 26% are in single specialty centers. For those, the most common specialties are orthopedics, gastroenterology, and ophthalmology. About half (46%) of the facilities are physician owned, 28% are joint-venture owned, 15% are corporate owned, and 6% are hospital owned.

About half (46%) are in a suburban location, while 36% are in an urban area, and 18% are located in a rural area. The average annual case volume is 4,280.

Compensation

ASC managers continue to earn less on average than their hospital counterparts.

Hospital ASC
Salary $114,000 $88,500

The average salary in 2011 was up slightly from $86,700 in the 2010 survey, although total compensation was about the same as the $105,000 last year.

ASC managers in joint-venture centers earn the most, followed by those in physician-owned and corporate-owned ASCs. Those in the Northeast and multi-specialty centers also earn more.

A quarter (25%) earn $100,000 or more, while 12% earn $60,000 or less. The span of difference from least to most earned between ASCs and hospitals was $11,900 for salary and $18,000 for total compensation.

The average raise for ASC managers was 3.4%, compared to 2.8% for hospitals. The average raise was slightly less than the 3.7% in 2010. For most (91%) of the respondents, the increase did not involve a promotion or change in responsibilities.

ASC leaders receive an average of 26.4 days of paid time off a year, compared to 29.3 for hospital leaders.

Total compensation for ASC managers is highest in the Northeast, followed by the West, Midwest, and South. As expected, those who manage 5 or more ORs earn more than those supervising fewer.

Benefits. As in past years, ASC leaders have fewer benefits than their counterparts in the hospital, with pensions, tuition reimbursement, and life and disability insurance among those with the highest discrepancies.

ASC Hospital
Paid time off 99% 100%
Health ins 87% 94%
401(k) plan 81% 85%
Dental ins 72% 88%
Life ins 65% 88%
Disability ins 51% 76%
Eye care 51% 69%
Dependent health ins 41% 69%
Educ benefits 40% 57%
Tuition reimb 25% 78%

As in 2010, 10% of respondents lost benefits in the past 6 months.

Bonuses

Nearly three-quarters (72%) of ASC managers have bonuses or profit sharing as part of their benefits package compared to just slightly over half (51%) for their hospital counterparts. More than half (60%) of ASC respondents received a monetary bonus or profit sharing in the past 12 months, compared to less than half (42%) of hospital respondents. The average monetary award was $6,530 for ASC leaders and $8,680 for hospital leaders. Only 7% received incentive pay.

In the 6 months, the ASC’s volume has …
2011 2009 2007
Increased 22% 19% 46%
Decreased 29% 30% 14%
Remained about the same 49% 51% 39%
ASC managers’ span of control
Clinical FTEs 19.6
Nonclinical FTEs 4.1
Total FTEs 23.7
Average annual salary and total compensation
Annual salary Total compensation
By number of ORs
<5 ORs $86,100 $102,000
5+ ORs $94,700 $113,000
By ownership
Physician owned $84,900 $100,000
Corporate owned $81,800 $96,000
Joint venture $93,700 $114,000
By title
Administrator/admin director $97,700 $121,000
Nurse manager $86,400 $97,000

Manager scope and influence

The survey provided insights into the scope and influence of ASC managers.

Number of ORs managed. ASC managers hold responsibility for an average of 3.6 ORs, basically unchanged for the past 2 years. Respondents in joint-venture ASCs manage the most ORs (4.2), with those in physician-owned and corporate-owned facilities managing 3.3 and 3.1 ORs respectively.

Span of control. ASC managers supervise an average of 23.7 FTEs. Managers supervise 19.6 clinical FTEs and 4.1 nonclinical FTEs. In the hospital, managers supervise an average of 121 FTEs, 102 clinical FTEs, and 19.3 nonclinical FTEs.

More than one-third (39%) of respondents hold the title of administrator or administrative director, with the remaining split among nurse manager (21%), director of nursing (19%), and clinical director (18%).

The largest number of respondents (28%) report to administration, with an equal percentage (18%) reporting to the board of directors or physician owners. Other reporting structures include the medical director (7%) and corporate office (4%).

Budget. The average ASC annual operating budget is $4.4 million, slightly less than the 2010 $4.7 million annual operating budget.

ASCs budgets by ownership:

Corporate $6.1 million
Joint venture $5.9 million
Physician $2.7 million

Half of respondents said their budgets had stayed the same in the past 6 months, with the other half equally split between saying that the budget increased and decreased.

Purchasing power. Managers continue to have impressive influence on purchases. The vast majority influence the selection and purchase of OR supplies and equipment (87%) and OR capital equipment (79%), about the same as last year. Nearly half are members of a committee (48%) or serve as the primary decision maker (46%); 29% act in an advisory capacity.

Work hours and satisfaction. Respondents work an average of 48 hours a week, with 27% working between 50 and 54 hours and 23% between 45 and 49 hours. On a scale of 1 to 5 with 5 being “very satisfied” and 1 being “not satisfied at all,” respondents reported a mean of 4 for satisfaction with their current position. Slightly more than a third (34%) said they were very satisfied.

Manager profile

Respondents were fairly equally distributed across geographic areas. Most (33%) work in the South, followed by the Midwest (26%), West (24%), and Northeast (18%).

Almost all (91%) are female, while 9% are male. And 91% are RNs. No respondents indicated they were MDs or surgical technologists.

ASC managers bring a wealth of experience to the table, including an average of 26 years of nursing employment. They have held their current positions an average of 8.3 years. The average age of respondents was 52 years, compared to 53 years in 2010.

As in 2010, 48% of managers said their highest degree was a bachelor’s, followed by 20% for an associate degree, 18% for a master’s, and 11% for a diploma. Education levels are higher among hospital OR nurse leaders, with 48% having a master’s as their highest degree and 36% having a bachelor’s.

Slightly more than half (52%) of respondents’ employers require a specific degree, compared to 78% for hospital OR respondents. Most ASCs that require a degree specify a bachelor’s (64%), followed by an associate degree (16%) and a master’s (16%). By comparison, 57% of hospitals require a bachelor’s and 42% a master’s for perioperative managers.

Sailing ahead

Though the economic times are tough for some, ASC managers are keeping their eyes on the patient. Many cited passing surveys and receiving accreditation that attest to good patient care as their proudest achievements.

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN

Cynthia Saver, president of CLS Development, Inc, is a freelance writer based in Columbia, Maryland.


Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat