October 1, 2011

The weak economy challenges OR case volumes, directors’ raises

By: OR Manager
Share



OR Manager; Vol. 27 No. 10; October 2011



OR directors and managers are striving to stay ahead of a weak economy, according to this year’s OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. Much has changed in the past 10 years of the survey.

The good news is that salaries, bonuses, and compensation have risen. The bad news includes shrinking raises and surgical case volumes.

Highlights of this year’s survey include:

  • The average annual salary was $114,000.
  • The average raise was only 2.8%, compared to 5% in 2001.
  • Nearly half (42%) of respondents received bonuses.
  • Only 33% reported an increase in surgical case volume, compared to nearly two-thirds (63%) in 2001.

The lack of a large increase in budgets and case volume is consistent with a Moody’s Investor Services report that says, “With reimbursement pressures coming from all major payers—Medicare, Medicaid, and commercial health insurers—falling revenue growth has become the most important and immediate challenge confronting US not-for-profit healthcare providers.” Medicare reductions are putting more pressure on hospitals, which count on Medicare for 43% of revenue on average.

About the survey

The OR Manager Salary/Career Survey was mailed in 2 waves from April to July 2011 to 800 OR Manager subscribers classified as directors of hospital ORs. There were 247 usable responses for a 31% response rate. To ensure representation of the target audience, results were filtered to include only the 230 respondents who work full time in an OR. The margin of error is ±5.4 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. A separate survey was sent to nurse managers of ambulatory surgery centers (see page 24). This is the 11th year the staffing questions have been asked and the 3rd year for the economic questions. Results from the staffing portion of the survey appeared in the September OR Manager.

Surgical volume and the economy

Surgical volume drives ORs’ financial success. The average annual case volume is 8,900. The change in volume is evenly divided among those who say volume increased, decreased, and remained about the same, with 33% for each. Those who saw an increase were understandably pleased, with one respondent reporting as an accomplishment, “increased surgical volume in challenging economic times.”

The numbers are far from those seen in better times. Moody’s says fewer elective procedures are one factor behind the decline in inpatient admissions (down 0.4% in 2010). Elective surgery continues to fall because the poor economy and persistent unemployment cause many to postpone surgery.

On the bright side, some respondents continue to add services such as robotic surgery and bariatrics to entice more surgeons and patients and boost revenue. “Taken on an active GYN service and became skilled in this new area,” said one respondent.

Others report new building projects and equipment purchases such as “high definition equipment,” “robots,” and “telecommunications.” One respondent’s accomplishment was, “Growth in service lines, getting ready to add a 4th OR and retrofit the other 3 so all are minimally invasive.” Another respondent reported, “$225 million expansion to include 10+ ORs.”

On the expense side, respondents are still focused on improving OR performance, highlighting accomplishments such as “increased on-time starts,” “decreased turnover times,” and “better block time allocation and utilization.” Several also started Lean management programs.

Compensation profile

OR directors and managers earn an average annual salary of $114,000. The average total compensation including wages, bonuses, and benefits is $139,000. Once again, respondents in the West earn the highest salaries ($132,000) and total compensation ($169,000). The lowest average salaries are in the Midwest ($101,000) and in the smallest ORs ($89,000). As expected, those who supervise more ORs and those in teaching hospitals earn more than those who oversee fewer ORs and work in community hospitals.

Raises down, bonuses up. The average raise has steadily decreased over the past decade. This year it was 2.8%, down from 3.5% in 2010 and 5.0% in 2001. The median raise for 32% of the respondents was 3%. The 2011 raise fell below the Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U), which increased by 3.6% for the year ending in June 2011 according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

There is some good news: The number of OR directors and managers who received bonuses in the past 12 months has risen over the past decade, from 30% in 2001 to 42% this year. The bonus value has risen, too, from $6,440 in 2001 to $8,680 in 2011, more than last year’s $8,060. Managers in the West (56%) and the South (48%) were most likely to receive a bonus as were those in larger ORs (51%) and in teaching hospitals (46%).

Benefits. All respondents receive paid time off (vacation, sick time, and holidays), on average 29 days. Some 10% receive 40 or more days off annually.

Other top benefits include:

Health insurance 94%
Dental insurance 88%
Life insurance 88%
401(k) retirement plan 85%
Tuition reimbursement 78%
Disability insurance 76%
Dependent health ins 69%
Eye care 69%
Educational benefits 57%
Bonus/profit sharing 51%
Pensions 41%
Incentive pay 18%

Fewer respondents lost benefits in the past 6 months compared to last year (15% vs 19%).

Some pointed out the lack of education funding, with one commenting, “freeze on education reimbursed travel.” Another lost “200+ hours of sick time unless I have a catastrophic illness” as a result of a change in the paid leave plan. One respondent noted that insurance copays had increased.

The number of hospitals that offer plans to reward staff financially for helping to improve performance or reduce supply costs remains low at 28%, about the same as the 27% in 2010.

A high-pressure job

Data from the survey indicate that OR directors and managers work in a high-pressure environment.

About your hospital. Most respondents (74%) work in a community hospital, while 21% work in a teaching hospital, and 5% indicated they worked in another type of facility. Most hospitals (89%) are not for profit. For-profits are more prevalent in the South and West. More than a third (39%) are located in suburban areas, 35% in rural areas, and 20% in urban areas. The average number of licensed beds is 256, with 14% of the respondents working in hospitals with 500 or more beds. The median number of hospital beds is 200.

Title and work area. Most respondents say their title is director (46%), followed by administrator or administrative director (31%), and nurse manager (18%). “Perioperative services” has steadily gained traction as a description for the work area in the past decade, more than doubling from 16% in 2001 to 33% this year. Although surgical services remains the more common description at 47%, that’s significantly less than the 69% 10 years ago.

Reporting structure and scope of role. In all, 61% of respondents report to nursing administration, which has stayed fairly consistent over the past 10 years. Most (31%) other respondents report to hospital administration. This is more common in larger, teaching hospitals.

The largest group, 66%, report they have responsibility for the OR and other departments within one hospital. Nearly 1 in 5 (18%) have responsibility at more than one facility, either managing the OR and other departments or managing only the OR at multiple facilities. Only 10% manage only the OR in one hospital.

The breakdown varied by title, with 80% of directors, 60% of nurse managers, and 57% of administrators or administrative directors overseeing the OR and other departments in one hospital. Respondents with responsibility for the OR and other departments at multiple sites are more likely to hold the title of administrator or administrative director.

Respondents manage an average of 12.5 ORs and 6 departments and services. The most common departments that report to OR directors and managers are postanesthesia care, central processing, outpatient/same-day surgery, and preadmission testing. This breakdown is consistent with 2006. Other responses reflect the diversity of what OR directors and managers oversee: pain management, cardiac cath lab, ICU, rehab services, radiology, surgical support management, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, center for wound care, total joint unit, labor and delivery, infusion therapy, bronchoscopy lab, bariatric program, and respiratory care.

Budget numbers. OR directors and managers hold significant budgetary responsibilities.

Average annual OR budget managed
Operating $32.3 million
Capital $1.3 million
Personnel $5.2 million

A few (8%) have operating budgets of $75 million or more, primarily in larger, teaching hospitals. The largest percentage (22%) have operating budgets between $10 million and $24.9 million.

Budgets remained the same for nearly half (49%) of respondents, with 29% reporting an increase, and 17% reporting a decrease.

About the operating room

How many clinical FTEs do you supervise directly or indirectly?
By facility type By number of ORs By title
Community Teaching 1-4 5-9 10+ Admin director Director Manager
Clinical 77.0 194.0 27.0 54.0 172.0 168.0 76.0 49.0
Nonclinical 15.7 32.9 3.9 11.5 32.0 32.5 14.0 11.2
What is the annual budget for the ORs (in millions)?
By facility type By number of ORs By title
Community Teaching 1-4 5-9 10+ Admin director Director Manager
mean (median)
Operating $21.3 ($12.0) $68.6 ($46.0) $7.1 ($3.3) $10.9 ($7.4) $52.2 ($27.6) $50.8 ($30.5) $18.5 ($10.0) $19.7 ($9.0)
Capital $1.1 ($0.8) $2.0 ($1.6) $0.4 ($0.3) $0.7 ($0.5) $1.8 ($1.5) $1.5 ($1.4) $0.9 ($0.6) $1.4 ($1.0)
Personnel $3.9 ($2.6) $10.9 ($9.1) $1.1 ($0.9) $2.7 ($2.2) $8.0 ($5.7) $7.5 ($4.8) $3.8 ($2.2) $3.5 ($2.5)

Management scope

How many sites do you manage?
By title Admin director Director Nurse manager
OR only within one hospital 0% 12% 28%
OR & other depts within one hospital 57% 80% 60%
OR only at multiple sites 3% 1% 0%
OR & other depts at multiple sites 34% 8% 5%

OR managers’ purchasing clout

Do you influence the selection and purchase of …
OR supplies/equipment 92%
OR capital equipment 88%

Purchasing clout. OR directors and managers have significant clout over those purchases, according to survey results. Almost all (92%) report that they influence the purchase of OR supplies and equipment, and 88% influence capital equipment purchases. Respondents most commonly describe their involvement as membership on a decision committee or team (60%) or a value-analysis team (51%), followed by primary decision maker (34%), and serving in an advisory capacity (29%). One respondent’s accomplishment was “implementing a purchasing advisory committee,” and another had established a task force for value analysis.

Span of control increases. OR directors and managers directly or indirectly supervise an average of 102 clinical and 19 nonclinical FTEs for a total of 121 FTEs. In 2001, the total number was 101 and in 2006, it was 104, indicating a steady increase over the past 10 years.

Respondents in teaching hospitals oversee more clinical FTEs than community hospitals (194 vs 77). The number of clinical FTEs under an OR directors’ or managers’ span of control increases with the number of ORs. Administrators and administrative directors supervise the most clinical FTEs (168), followed by directors (76) and managers (49).

Perioperative managers’ education

While 21% supervise 1 to 4 nonclinical FTEs, 9% supervise 50 or more, and 15% supervise between 25 and 49. The median number of nonclinical FTEs is 9.

Putting in long hours. OR directors and managers work hard, putting in on average 52.3 hours a week. About one fifth (21%) work 60 to 64 hours, and more than one third (37%) work 50 to 54 hours.

Satisfaction stays high. Respondents are satisfied with their current positions, with an average of 3.9 on a 5-point scale (with 5 being “very satisfied,” and 1 being “not satisfied at all”). A fourth (25%) of respondents are very satisfied, and more than half (51%) rated their satisfaction as a 4.

Few job hunts and low vacancies. Given the high satisfaction level and the poor economy, it’s not surprising that nearly three-quarters (72%) of respondents aren’t considering a new job. Just 9% are actively looking, and 19% say they are “strongly considering” a job search.

Only 7% of respondents report vacant OR manager or director positions, consistent with the past 2 years. The average length of a vacancy is 5.5 months, down from 2010’s 7.3 months.

Your profile

The survey provides a snapshot of OR directors and managers. OR directors are primarily RNs (94%) and female (87%). Although 7% indicated that they were not RNs, no respondent specified being an MD or surgical technologist.

Age, experience, and retirement. Consistent with the rest of the nursing profession, the average age of OR directors and managers has risen from 49 years in 2001 to 53 in 2011. Some 21% are 60 years of age or older, and 27% are under 50, with 51% between 50 and 60 years of age. The median age of RNs is 46 years, according to the 2008 National Sample Survey of Registered Nurses.

Given the average age, it’s not surprising that respondents report an average of 29.4 years in nursing. Respondents have held their current positions for an average of 8.4 years, with 10 respondents (4%) in their positions for 25 or more years.

Watch for management staffing issues in 2020, the average year when directors and managers plan to retire. The poor economy continues to affect many respondents’ retirement decisions, with more than a third (38%) citing it as a factor in postponing retirement.

Education rises. The educational level for OR directors and managers has progressively risen over the past decade, with 39% reporting a master’s as the highest degree in 2001 compared to 48% this year. In 1996, only 25% of OR directors and managers had a master’s.

Most (78%) of directors and managers say a specific degree is required for their position. The most common degrees required are a bachelor’s (57%) and master’s (42%). One respondent noted that in addition to a bachelor’s degree, the position “must have master’s degree within 5 years of accepting position.”

Keeping an eye on the basics

Through the economic challenges, OR directors and managers continue to focus on the basics of staff, surgeons, and patients, as their comments illustrate. Comments related to staff include “retained excellent quality staff,” “healthy work environment,” and “employee survey scores were the highest in 15 years.”

Comments about surgeons include “improved doc/nurse relationship,” “increased physician satisfaction,” and “reinvolving physicians in direction of ORs.”

Patient-related comments include “safety measures for safe patient handling,” “warming all patients,” and “incorporating briefing and debriefing into our work flow.” Several mentioned achievements in meeting SCIP measures, referring to the Surgical Care Improvement Project.

OR directors and managers will need to stay focused on these basics in the face of the expected further reimbursement cuts and stepped-up emphasis on preventing infections and other complications.

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN

Cynthia Saver is a freelance writer and president of CLS Development, Inc, in Columbia, Maryland.

References

Health Resources and Services Administration. The Registered Nurse Population: Findings from the 2008 National Sample Survey of Registered Nurses. Washington, DC: HRSA, 2010. http://bhpr.hrsa.gov/healthworkforce/rnsurveys/rnsurveyfinal.pdf.

Goldstein L, Nelson J C. Hospital revenues in critical condition; downgrades may follow. Moody’s Investor Service. Aug. 10,2011. www.hhnmag.com/hhnmag/PDFs/2011PDFs/moodys.pdf.

What’s your OR’s greatest achievement?

In the OR Manager Salary/Career Survey, we asked OR directors to tell us about the greatest improvement in their ORs in the past year. Many reported that they had achieved SCIP (Surgical Care Improvement Project) goals. Others have been able to decrease surgical site infections (SSI). Many said they had improved turnover time and first-case starts. New equipment included robots, HD equipment, and hybrid ORs. Others reported cost savings on implants. Here are some of the comments.

1. Improved patient safety

  • Through evidence-based practice and other changes, we have decreased SSI by about 50%. We received a top ten in Maryland in patient safety innovations.
  • Meeting all SCIP measures.
  • Implementation of Safe Surgery Initiative with surgeon participation (including briefing, time-out, debriefing, and new count policy).
  • Implemented fire safety risk assessment into timeout.
  • We have increased patient safety by implementing several measures toward lowering SSIs. Our SSI rate is 50% of the national average of 2.8%!
  • Sentinel events decreased—collaborative initiative between surgery, anesthesia, and nursing.

2. Making ORs more efficient

  • Start and turnover times improved. Also efficiencies in the preop area.
  • Improved teamwork. Maturation of shared governance.
  • Decreased turnover time; improvement to 80% on-time starts.
  • Patient throughput. Accommodates nonelective cases and reduces PACU holds in the OR.
  • Reduced overall turnover time from close to 30 minutes to average 24 minutes.
  • Average turnover of 17 minutes. Improved start time from 12% to 75%. Room turnovers between 13 and 15 minutes. Case throughput increased to 80%.

3. Construction, renovation, and equipment

  • Growth from community/hospital to tertiary hospital, from 6 ORS to 11 ORS.
  • Implemented robotic surgery and spine surgery.
  • Opening 3 high-tech integrated rooms on time and at budget.
  • Cost savings and innovations. Total joint costs— saved $725K.
  • Driving supply costs down by methodical collaboration with physicians.
  • Added single-incision surgery and robotic surgery.
  • 24% growth.
  • Recycling efforts have decreased waste by 32%.

4. Power to the people

  • Increased the number of certified OR nurses.
  • Fixing pay inequities and standardization of many things across 5 sites. Reducing bloodborne pathogen injuries. Reinvolving physicians in direction of ORs.
  • Getting RNs to return to school and become certified.
  • Working with physicians as partners.
  • Significantly improved customer satisfaction, employee satisfaction.
  • Improved doc/nurse relationship.


Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat