November 1, 2011

Full-rotation three-dimensional intraoperative imaging during spinal procedures

By: OR Manager
Share



OR Manager; Vol. 27 No. 11; November 2011



• NOVEMBER 2011

Editor’s Note

OR leaders are striving to make evidence-based decisions about new technology. OR Manager, Inc, and ECRI Institute have joined in a collaboration to bring quarterly supplements with summaries of the Institute’s Emerging Technology Evidence Reports to OR Manager readers. ECRI Institute is an independent nonprofit organization that researches best approaches to improving patient care. It does its work by analyzing the research literature and data on clinical procedures, medical devices, and drug therapies.

This summary provides a review of the literature through March 14, 2011.

Technology description

The O-arm Imaging System is a mobile cone-beam imaging system that combines a traditional C-arm fluoroscope in 2-D scan acquisition mode and a CT scanner in 3-D scan acquisition mode.

The system consists of a mobile view station and an x-ray stand and has the following features:

  • A breakaway ring-shaped gantry that opens
  • Standard 2-D fluoroscopy
  • 3-D volumetric imaging in standard and high-definition modes
  • Single and multiplane 2-D imaging
  • 360-degree rotation for CT-like multiplanar imaging
  • Mobility over the length of the operating room table
  • Automatic registry and recall of images
  • Robotic control
  • Acquisition and reconstruction of about 400 images in 30 seconds in standard 3-D mode
  • Acquisition and reconstruction of about 750 images in 50 seconds in high definition 3-D mode

The O-arm system is typically used with a computer-assisted navigation system. However, surgeons can also use the system in a stand-alone mode at the end of spinal fusion surgery before final closure as an intraoperative CT scanner to confirm screw placement, spine decompression, and alignment.

Full-rotation 3-D intraoperative imaging using the system may offer the following benefits over intraoperative imaging using conventional C-arm fluoroscopy in 3-D mode:

  • Faster rotation time, resulting in shorter image acquisition time
  • Improved resolution and higher-quality images
  • Larger field of view, allowing the generation of multiplanar images

These features potentially offer enhanced visualization, improved precision, shorter operative times, and reduced radiation exposure for the surgeon and patient.

Manufacturers/suppliers

Medtronic Navigation (Louisville, Colorado, USA) manufactures and distributes the O-arm Imaging System and compatible navigation systems.

Regulatory status

In May 2005, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) granted 510(k) marketing clearance for the O-arm Imaging System.

Indications/contraindications

The O-arm Imaging System is intended to be used where a physician benefits from 2-D and 3-D information of anatomic structures and objects with high x-ray attenuation such as bony anatomy and metallic objects.

The system may be used during the following spinal procedures:

  • Posterior cervical fusion with C2 pedicle screw
  • Posterior fusion with pedicle screws of the lower cervical and upper thoracic vertebrae
  • Posterior thoracic fusion after spinal trauma
  • Posterior thoracic fusion requiring pedicle screw/rod constructs to correct a scoliosis deformity
  • Posterior lumbar fusion requiring interbody fusion devices and pedicle screw/rod constructs
  • Minimally invasive lumbar fusion
  • Posterior lumbar fusion revision surgery

Impact on hospital operations/safety considerations

Hospitals should consider the following potential impacts:

  • Multidisciplinary use may confound operative scheduling.
  • Procedure times may increase because of device setup, increased image acquisition, and image confirmation.
  • Operating rooms <600 sq. ft. may not be able to accommodate the system.
  • Operating room tables must be x-ray compatible.
  • Mobile imaging systems can be challenging to maneuver because of weight and size.
  • Imaging systems with an exposed x-ray tube and detector can collide with other equipment or staff.
  • Surgeons performing multiple procedures are at risk from cumulative radiation exposure.

Credentialing/Training

Surgeons inexperienced with the technology may face a learning curve regarding the system’s setup, imaging protocol, and navigation capabilities. Also, proper training in computer-assisted surgery system use is essential. To assist clinicians, Medtronic offers technical support and training for health care professionals.

Effect on other technologies

The O-arm Imaging System competes with other mobile intraoperative imaging systems that can provide 3-D imaging. Competing systems have imaging speeds that are slower than the O-arm Imaging System.

Cost considerations

The average quoted price for the O-arm Imaging System without the navigation interface is $603,710. The average quoted price for the O-arm Imaging System navigation interface is $35,000. System enhancements are available for additional cost. These costs are significantly higher than for mobile C-arm systems.

Reimbursement/coding/payment

The U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services has no national coverage determination for this technology. Thus, coverage decisions are left to the discretion of local Medicare carriers.

ECRI Institute searches of 11 representative commercial third-party payers that provide their coverage polices online did not identify any policies that mentioned full-rotation 3-D intraoperative imaging. Six of the payers have policies that deny coverage for computer-assisted surgical navigation, and the other five have no specific policy.

The American Medical Association has not assigned a specific Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) code to describe full-rotation 3-D intraoperative imaging. However, the following CPT codes may be listed in addition to the primary procedure:

  • Fluoroscopy up to one hour
  • Computer-assisted surgical navigational procedure for musculoskeletal procedures, imageless
  • Stereotactic computer-assisted spinal procedure
  • Radiologic supervision and interpretation of percutaneous vertebroplasty vertebral augmentation, or sacral augmentation under fluoroscopic guidance.

In the inpatient setting, payment for the O-arm Imaging System is linked to one of more than 500 Medicare Severity Diagnosis-Related Groups. In the outpatient setting, payment for imaging guidance during procedures that involve the spine is bundled into the Ambulatory Payment Classification rates for outpatient procedures. The professional component of the procedure may be paid under Medicare’s physician fee schedule.

Evidence base

Our searches identified one nonrandomized controlled study (Silbermann et al., 2011) that compared the accuracy of pedicle screw placement in two groups of patients, and five single-group studies (Nottmeier et al., July 2010; Nottmeier et al., December 2010; Oertel et al., 2011; Park et al., 2010; Schils et al., 2011).

Key clinical questions/findings

Does using full-rotation 3-D intraoperative imaging improve the accuracy of pedicle screw placement during spinal fusion compared to standard 2-D or 3-D C-arm fluoroscopy?

Only one comparative study assessed this outcome. Silbermann et al. (2011) reported a higher accuracy rate for pedicle screw placement in an O-arm navigation group than in a 2-D fluoroscopy/CT group (99% versus 94.1%; p = 0.012). Applicability of these findings to clinical practice is unclear.

Does using full-rotation 3-D intraoperative imaging during spinal surgery reduce total radiation exposure time, operative time, and number of revision surgeries compared to standard 2-D or 3-D C-arm fluoroscopy?

Only one comparative study reported on differences in operative time and adverse event rates, and no comparative study reported on radiation exposure times or revision surgery rates. Silbermann et al. (2011) reported that the mean patient positioning time was significantly longer in an O-arm navigation group than in a 2-D fluoroscopy/CT group (p <0.05). However, the between-group difference in the mean operative time did not reach statistical significance in this study.

What adverse events are associated with using this technology?

The studies we assessed reported no adverse events directly associated with full-rotation 3-D intraoperative imaging during spinal procedures.

Excerpted with permission from ECRI Institute’s database of Emerging Technology Evidence Reports. The complete report can be purchased from ECRI Institute’s Health Technology Assessment Information Service at htais@ecri.org.

ECRI Institute is an independent nonprofit health services research agency designated as an Evidence-based Practice Center by the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. The Institute maintains the strictest conflict-of-interest standards in the healthcare industry to protect against biases and ensure the integrity of its information.


Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat