Reducing room turnover time is a goal in many surgical services departments, and refining the cleaning process is one path to success. Implementing a Lean process improvement at our hospital helped us not only meet but exceed our targets for room cleanliness and cleaning time.
A 73% average rate of cleanliness has soared to more than 97%, and cleaning time per OR has dropped to around 29 minutes, down from the 41 to 51 minutes required previously. We continue to monitor and make changes, but some of the lessons we’ve learned may help others with similar issues.
Indiana University Health Goshen Hospital in Goshen, Indiana, is a 124-bed hospital with nine ORs.
We were using washcloths and a 3-minute dwell time cleaning solution, along with rag mops to clean the floors. All available staff were expected to respond to cleaning needs. OR turnover time, measured as the time from when the first patient left the OR until the next patient arrived in the OR, averaged 21 minutes for orthopedics and 18 minutes for general surgery. However, the total staff labor required for cleaning ranged from 41 to 51 minutes.
We monitored turnovers between cases and observed chaos—either too many or too few staff were involved in turning over the OR. There were no defined roles, and we lacked guidelines for newer staff. Yearly performance evaluations were based partly on how fast rooms were turned over, but the quality of that cleaning was not addressed.
We had been relying on the naked eye to assess cleanliness, but swab testing done with Ultrasnap ATP (Hygiene, Camarillo, California) revealed that our cleanliness was 73%.
A team consisting of our deployment leader, vice president of operations, managers of the OR and environmental services, a couple of OR staff, and staff from outside the OR met for 4 days and identified these problems:
• All available hands were trying to clean the OR without any direction about who was doing what, and what exactly had to be cleaned.
• Cleaning supplies were not easily accessible; staff often reported for cleaning and then had to gather supplies outside of the OR.
• Cleaning processes varied; some staff dribbled the cleaning product across surfaces and then wiped equipment clean, whereas others saturated the microfiber cloths with the solution.
• Some items were cleaned twice, and others were not cleaned at all.
• We were not consistently following AORN standards for cleaning.
OR staff were surprised and disappointed that their efforts did not meet a high enough standard, and they were determined to make changes for the patients’ benefit.
Several spaghetti diagrams were completed to study the current cleaning flow. The team visualized a future state. We knew we had to identify everyone’s role, make cleaning supplies easily accessible, and develop a process based on AORN standards.
We believed if we identified cleaning zones following the AORN standards and assigned these roles, there would be less confusion, staff would be held accountable, and the total time required for cleaning would decrease. We wanted to achieve a passing score for at least 95% of all items and areas within the OR.
To change the current cleaning process, we developed an educational video that showed problems such as the lack of personal protective equipment, rework, wasted steps, improperly cleaned items, and failure to follow AORN standards.
A slide presentation helped to outline the new cleaning process for OR turnovers, which we established in September 2014. Changes included using microfiber wipes for the equipment and the floor, and switching to a cleaning solution with a 1-minute dwell time. This mandatory education process included instructions for use of the new cleaning product.
In addition, laminated cleaning “zone” cards were place in each of the ORs to identify what was to be cleaned in each zone and who was responsible (photo, p 22):
• Zone A—the anesthesia area, handled by the anesthesia technologist or the first available nursing assistant.
• Zone B—the area of the boom tower that holds equipment, the back table, the Mayo and ring stands, and additional equipment on that side of the OR, handled by the scrub technologist.
• Zone C—trash and linen, OR lights, OR bed and additional equipment attached to the bed, handled by the RN, scrub technologist, or nursing assistant.
• Zone D—the nurse stand, nurse desk, cupboard doors, and door handles leaving the OR, handled by the circulator.

Designated cleaning zones match staff with specific tasks, creating a more efficient process. Photos courtesy of Elaine Gibson, BSN, RN, CNOR.
Standard tasks for each specific zone were written, and shelves were added to the cleaning closets for microfiber wipes, which improved organization and our 6 S scores; sort, straighten, scrub, safety, standardize, and sustain.
The manager of environmental services instructed the OR manager, educator, a circulating RN, and a specialty nursing assistant on proper use of the Ultrasnap ATP equipment to measure the residue left behind after cleaning. This group became the monitoring team.
We defined the cleaning process as the time from when the patient is wheeled out of the OR until the cleaning is complete and the next case cart enters the OR. Our goal was to swab test 10 frequently touched items in three ORs per day: anesthesia carts and machines, OR beds and bed controls, patient bed rollers, OR lights, IV poles, electrode cautery units, computer keypads, and the mouse. After the room was cleaned, team members swabbed the key items to test for cleanliness. Monitoring staff looked for wasted steps and timed the cleaning process.
Data collected each day included the number of staff cleaning during turnover, the time needed to clean, Ultrasnap ATP swab testing for cleanliness, and comments about whether the new cleaning zones were honored.
This information was posted in the main OR hallway in the form of graphs, charts, and documentation of issues we were noticing, as well as suggestions for improvements (photo above). Each morning, we huddled around this information and discussed what was going well and what needed improvement.
When we switched to the 1-minute cleaning solution in which microfiber wipes were soaked, the solution turned blue, pulling the color from the microfiber wipes. The environmental services manager contacted the vendor of the cleaning product and learned that the color was leaving the microfiber wipes because the cleaning solution was breaking down the dye in these wipes.
We also noticed the rubber on the OR bed safety straps was becoming tacky to the touch and breaking down. The vendor recommended placing the cleaning solution directly onto the microfiber cloth and then cleaning the surfaces.
Initially, we were informed that the swab test results needed to be equal to or less than 50 relative light unit (RLU) values to pass. After the new process had been in place for about a month, we learned that our cleaning factor needed to be equal to or less than 10 RLU values.
For the next month, we were unable to consistently meet the 10 RLU values target. Finally, once we switched out to new sliders and starting using disposable bed sheets, our cleaning scores improved to 10 or less RLU values, and we started to get consistent results.
Use of the 1-minute cleaning product resulted in an increased number of dials and the on/off buttons becoming brittle and breaking on the bovies and anesthesia machines. The coloring on equipment logos was smearing, and more equipment repairs were needed, so one of our vendors banned the use of this product on his equipment. In addition, environmental services staff were getting sores on their arms from skin coming in contact with the cleaning solution. We are trialing a different cleaning product.
It was difficult to achieve a passing score for the patient bed rollers, even after repeated cleaning. After we noticed that the material in the rollers was breaking down, we bought new rollers and immediately got a passing score.
Motors burned out in two OR beds because of fluid reaching inside the base of the beds. By testing mattresses, we found extra time and labor were needed to clean effectively. Using disposable sheet packs, we achieved a consistent passing result and process for cleaning the OR beds while protecting the equipment.
However, the disposable sheet packs were slippery, causing patients to slide toward the anesthesiologist when the OR bed was placed in the Trendelenburg position. We tried alternatives but ultimately resumed placing large chuxs under the patient’s operative site. We have since maintained passing scores.
Within 120 days, we were able to make a change in the OR turnover cleaning process with consistent results during the last 60 days (chart at left). Swab testing for cleanliness was 97.6%, surpassing the target of 95%, and our total labor cleaning time was 29.1 minutes, surpassing the target of 33 to 41 minutes.
By honoring the cleaning zones, we have seen better communication and less duplication of efforts during cleaning. Through good teamwork, we have maintained a good turnover room time and reduced the labor needed.
Additional Lean projects have helped decrease the time spent cleaning ORs. As we trial the new cleaning product, we continue to use the Ultrasnap ATP testing to monitor results. There have been fewer skin problems and less equipment breakage.
Audits continue to be done each day to ensure ongoing success, and so far we remain in compliance.
AORN Periperative Standards and Recommended Practices; Recommended Practices for Environmental Cleaning. Denver, CO: AORN, 2014:255-276. www.aorn.org.