In this challenging healthcare environment, OR leaders have a fiscal responsibility to help hospitals meet financial goals that contribute to a healthy bottom line.
There is no more expensive procedure you can have in the hospital than to spend time in the OR,” says Keith Siddel, PhDc, JD, MBA, CHC. Siddel, a long-time consultant in the healthcare industry, is vice president of revenue for Baptist Memorial Health Care Corporation in Memphis, an integrated system that includes 15 hospitals and 600 physicians in three states. “When hospitals are paid for these patients, that payment goes directly to the bottom line.”
Siddel says OR leaders can improve the bottom line by managing the revenue cycle, minimizing denials, improving billing and reimbursement, and understanding business models.
“There are certain steps that have to be done—and done correctly—for a hospital to get paid,” Siddel says. He cites a recent example of a hospital that was reimbursed $5,000 for a patient who incurred $61,000 in costs. Although there were many points where someone could have raised a red flag, no one did.
Paying close attention to the revenue cycle can help improve the likelihood the hospital will receive payment and be paid in a timely fashion (sidebar, p 8).
“The revenue cycle starts before the patient is even at our facility and ends much later, after the patient has left,” Siddel says.
Before and during patient registration, the hospital must collect the information needed to ensure subsequent payment, including demographics, insurance coverage, and the planned procedure. This information should be obtained for all patients, including those transferring from other hospitals. Hospital staff then need to verify coverage, including whether the patient is in network, and obtain authorization.
Siddel also suggests several other key areas related to the revenue cycle that OR leaders can focus on to reduce delays in payment or nonpayment.
Clean claims refer to those that insurers start processing upon receipt, without requests for additional information. “You should know the clean claim percentage at your facility,” Siddel says. “If it’s low, you’re going to spend a lot of time, a lot of money, and a lot of effort simply trying to fix that claim before the processing starts.”
The goal should be 85% to 95%. He cautions leaders to avoid focusing on simply reducing the time it takes to fix claims that end up in an electronic work queue for correction before submission. “That’s not a clean claim,” he says. “Ask, ‘what do I need to do differently to prevent them getting into the work queue to begin with?’”
Claims that are not clean are in suspense. When it comes to Medicare, suspending a claim halts any progress until the needed information is received. “Most of the [Medicare] clearinghouses around the country have been throwing a lot of claims into suspense,” Siddel says. Hospital leaders need to understand why their claims are being suspended so they can revise what they include before submitting the claim. Once Medicare starts processing a claim, payment must be made within a set period of time.
Some payers require notice of admission (NOA). “If you don’t tell them their beneficiary is in the hospital, they won’t pay your claim,” Siddel says. For example, Blue Cross requires notification within 24 hours of admission. It’s best for hospitals to set up an automatic electronic notification for payers that require NOA and for staff to document it was done.
Major complications and comorbidities (MCCs) need to be documented so money isn’t left on the table. In Medicare’s Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement model, that can be as much as $29,000 for a single patient. Coders need to ensure they review documentation to determine whether patients had MCCs.
Siddel recommends having an audit program, which periodically (usually at least quarterly) reviews accounts to check for accurate coding. The report from these audits is typically sent to several departments, including compliance and the COO, and Siddel recommends OR leaders ensure they receive a copy.
Hospitals should minimize the time frame for discharge, not final billed, which refers to how long a claim is held, waiting until all charges and documentation are complete, before it is submitted.
“The longer you have to sit on a claim so that late charges, documentation, and coding can be added, the more money you have tied up in your accounts receivable,” Siddel says. The ideal is 3 to 5 days, with the longer time frame reserved for special situations such as a new billing system.
“I can’t emphasize enough the amount of denied charges in our industry,” Siddel says. “It is huge; millions of dollars get written off every single day.” He says the top five reasons for denial by payers are lack of authorization, level of care, out of network, not medically necessary, and noncovered charges.
Lack of authorization.It’s not unusual for a patient to have authorization for one procedure, but either a different procedure or an additional one is performed in the OR. “The key is what we do after that,” Siddel says. “You have a small window in which to contact the insurance company and get authorization for the new procedure.” This should be done within 24 hours, and certainly before discharge. If authorization isn’t obtained, the hospital will likely not be paid. Siddel recommends having a process for clinicians to notify staff responsible for authorization that a different or additional procedure was done.
Level of care not correct. “We need to ask the physician to tell us what level of care is needed at the time surgery is scheduled,” Siddel says. Although the level can change, often it does not, so there is no reason not to establish before admission whether a patient should be an inpatient or outpatient. Of course, level of care changes need to be documented.
Out of network. “As payers continue to narrow their network, out of network continues to be a problem,” Siddel says. In the case of cities with few hospitals, for instance, insurers may pit competing hospitals against each other to get the best deal.
Patients who are out of network should be told as soon as possible and transferred to an in-network hospital if feasible. “Almost all patients who buy a plan on the ACA [Affordable Care Act] exchanges are buying a high-deductible plan,” Siddel notes. Unfortunately, patients don’t realize the cost difference between in network and out of network until their bills arrive in the mail.
Not medically necessary. Although this may be the reason cited for denial, Siddel says more often it’s a case where the procedure was not coded or billed correctly.
Noncovered charges. Billing departments need to ensure that systems have current information on which procedures and items are covered by insurers. Ideally, noncovered items should be identified up front and discussed with the patient.
“You have to know the rules,” Siddel says. Too often, hospital leaders think they know the Medicare rules. However, nearly half of Medicare patients are in Part C, a managed care type of program.
“That provides a whole different set of processes we have to go through,” he says, adding that most states now use a managed care plan such as United Healthcare or Blue Cross to manage Medicaid. Many states that currently don’t are moving in that direction, and they each operate under a unique set of rules, Siddel adds.
Managing each step of the revenue cycle is essential to strengthen a
hospital’s bottom line.
Source: Keith Siddel. Used with permission.
Accurate billing improves reimbursement. To ensure accurate billing, Siddel says, OR leaders must understand recent changes by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to the two-midnight rule and inpatient-only procedures as well as the establishment of site-neutral payments.
The two-midnight rule refers to the fact that a patient whose stay crosses two midnights should probably be an inpatient. “If you have an outpatient or an observation patient who is in house greater than 48 hours, somebody should be asking why,” Siddel says. “They either don’t belong in the hospital anymore, or they should have been converted to an inpatient.”
But can a hospital receive Part A payment for a person who is an inpatient for one night? As of January 1, 2016, CMS says yes, in rare cases. These exceptions to the two-midnight rule need to be determined by a physician and are subject to medical review. Siddel says the exceptions seem to be inherently subjective, but CMS states that some factors to consider include:
• severity of the signs and symptoms exhibited by the patient
• medical predictability of something adverse happening to the patient
• need for diagnostic studies that appropriately are outpatient services (ie, their performance does not ordinarily require the patient to remain at the hospital for 24 hours or more).
Siddel emphasizes the rare nature of the exceptions. “For the most part, if patients stay two midnights, they’re inpatients. If they stay one midnight, they should have been outpatients,” he says, adding that it’s crucial for physicians to clearly document any exceptions.
Historically, inpatient-only procedures were those for which Medicare will reimburse only if they are performed in the inpatient setting. Typically, these are surgical services that require inpatient care because of the invasive nature of the procedure, the underlying physical condition of the patient, or the need for at least 24 hours of postoperative recovery time or monitoring before the patient can safely be discharged.
However, CMS has revised its billing instructions to allow payment for inpatient-only procedures performed in the outpatient setting on the date of or up to 3 calendar days before the inpatient admission.
“This gives the hospital the opportunity to bundle an inpatient-only procedure performed in the outpatient setting with an inpatient-related admission so the hospital can gain additional reimbursement,” Siddel says.
It also means that if an inpatient-only procedure was performed as an outpatient, the hospital only needs to admit the patient sometime before he or she goes home to obtain reimbursement. Previously, if the patient wasn’t classified correctly before the incision was made, the opportunity for reimbursement was lost.
The bill must be submitted correctly (as an inpatient and not an outpatient); otherwise, payment will be denied. Unfortunately, hospitals too often fail in making the correct submission because most surgery scheduling systems don’t use CPT codes, even though these codes are used by billers, coders, and payers.
“The breakdown between what we in the operating room suite call procedures and what the rest of the world calls them causes more loss to hospital bottom line than any other breakdown,” Siddel says.
Using CPT codes for scheduling makes inpatient-only procedures easily identifiable. Siddel suggests if the codes aren’t part of the system, a clinician and a staff person in the coding department should assign CPT codes to all the procedures that can be scheduled. The codes need to be reviewed annually when the American Medical Association updates them. Hospitals also need to work with physician offices, providing education sessions as needed.
CMS is moving toward site-neutral payments in response to the growth in provider-based facilities that are close to, but not in, the hospital. These facilities are the result of purchases of physician practices. Once the practice or clinic becomes part of the hospital, costs are based on inpatient rather than outpatient fee schedules.
In response to patients upset by the price increases, provider-based facilities that started after November 2015 will now receive the same reimbursement for certain outpatient procedures whether they are performed in hospital- or nonhospital-based settings.
“CMS calls it the equalization of payments,” Siddel says, adding that the American Hospital Association believes the rule change will cause hospitals to lose up to $1.44 billion each year.
Siddel also cautions hospital leaders to be aware of new regulations about the copy-and-paste feature for electronic health records (sidebar, p 9).
Hospitals should be sure they are in line with a new fraud advisory, released February 2, 2016, about the copy-and-paste feature for electronic health records (EHRs) from the Office of the Inspector General (OIG).
Keith Siddel, PhDc, JD, MBA, CHC, vice president of revenue for Baptist Memorial Health Care Corporation in Memphis, notes that OIG believes the feature “gives us inaccurate, contradictory, duplicative, inapplicable, erroneous, misleading information.” For example, 78% of nurses’ notes and 54% of progress notes are duplicative when information is pasted into a new record. In other words, the information is not individualized.
Misinformation can cause hospitals to bill for services not given, and the lack of individuality of entries from one visit to the next could result in payers questioning whether the service is legitimate and medically necessary.
OIG is taking a hard line against the problem, saying, “Inappropriate copy-pasting could facilitate attempts to inflate claims and duplicate or create fraudulent claims.”
“It’s not wrong to cut and paste,” Siddel says. “It’s just wrong to do it in the wrong way.” He cites the American Health Information Management Association (AHIMA) position statement that says: “The use of copy/paste functionality in EHRs should be permitted only in the presence of strong technical and administrative controls, which include organizational policies and procedures, requirements for participation in user training and education, and ongoing monitoring.” AHIMA provides a sample policy on the topic and an audit strategy at http://library.ahima.org/xpedio/groups/public/documents/ahima/bok1_042416.hcsp?dDocName=bok1_042416.
Siddel suggests sharing the following best practices with providers:
“We really have three different business models that are going on in a hospital, and the challenge is how to make each of these models work,” Siddel says, referring to the work of Clayton Christensen, author of The Innovator’s Prescription: Disruptive Solutions for Health Care.
• The diagnostic function of a hospital works best with a fee-for-service business model. “We’re trying to compete with the stand-alone lab or with CVS or Walgreens,” Siddel says. These types of simple services should be priced accordingly.
• The acute care and surgery functions of a hospital, which are similar to a process business such as manufacturing, should have an outcomes-based business model. “We should be charging based on what happens to this patient,” Siddel says.
• Chronic disease management and patient community building are essentially facilitated networks similar to telecom or insurance companies, so these work best as a membership-based model.
“We need to make sure patients are taking their medications, eating right, and exercising to limit the amount of times they come to us, which seems counterproductive,” Siddel says.
Christensen believes that decentralization of care would enable each business to function more efficiently, with less overhead—currently, overhead accounts for about 85% to 95% of total costs.
Siddel says the goal for OR managers and other hospital leaders should be to focus on all three business models.
Surgical services can be provided in a number of settings, including the OR, at the bedside for inpatients, at ambulatory surgery centers, at occupational/physical therapy clinics, and in physicians’ offices. Beyond the clinical services to be provided, OR leaders must consider the business model that works best for the particular setting.
OR leaders should ensure they have a place at the table where the C-suite representatives are discussing finances. “If they haven’t invited you, let them know that you have a role,” Siddel says. “That role is key to the financial success of the hospital.” ✥
Siddel K. Managing clinical and financial objectives to ensure a strong bottom line. OR Business Management Conference, 2016.