The perioperative surgical home (PSH) has been gaining momentum, with early results linking it to lower costs, better quality, fewer emergency department (ED) visits and readmissions, and shorter stays in skilled nursing facilities or none at all. In February, the PSH Learning Collaborative, a partnership between the American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) and Premier, Inc, announced results from the first phase of the program (sidebar, p 12). Most of the 44 participating healthcare organizations said the PSH model enhanced clinical quality, controlled costs, and improved patient experiences. For the phase two, which began in April, nearly 60 participating organizations will be striving to build on the success of phase one.
“Perioperative surgical homes have just exploded over the last couple of years,” says Mike Schweitzer, MD, MBA, chair of the ASA committee on future models of anesthesia practice and chief medical officer of bundled payments for Premier, Inc, in Charlotte, North Carolina. “The reason it has exploded is that it’s focused on redesigning or reengineering care,” he says. “Before, people were focused on the money, and now the focus is on the patient.”
“A surgical home ensures your hospital provides high-value care to patients and payers,” adds Jeff Peters, MBA, chief executive officer at Surgical Directions, a consulting firm in Chicago. Peters, who has helped many hospitals across the country establish and optimize PSHs, sees the concept as essential for success under current payment structures.
PSH requires caring for patients from the time they decide to have surgery through 90 days postoperatively. Peters says the surgical home manages the patient experience, including scheduling, preoperative surgical optimization, hospital recovery, and postdischarge care.
Critical components are early ambulation and pain management while in the hospital and the following services after hospitalization:
• primary care visit within 24 hours of discharge to manage comorbidity
• home health nurse who sees the patient when he or she arrives home
• daily rounding on patients, whether they are at home or in a skilled nursing facility.
A PSH often requires additional time and resources, so how can hospitals ensure they are fiscally responsible when it comes to this initiative? Procedure codes don’t exist for PSH services, but fortunately, Dr Schweitzer says, the PSH fits well with the move from a fee-for-service to a value-based payment (VBP) model. Typically one of the following VBP models is used: bundled payment, comanagment, or accountable care organization.
Bundled payment occurs as part of the Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement (CCJR) or the Bundled Payment Care Improvement (BPCI) programs through the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS). The CCJR program was designed to test bundled payment and quality measurement for an episode of care associated with hip and knee replacements.
“Bundled payment is the way to get paid for a surgical home; that’s the way payers want to go,” Peters says. “What’s been proved by bundled payment is that it improves clinical outcomes, reduces costs, and allows the government to align incentives; we can reward hospitals and their surgeons if their clinical outcomes are better and costs are lower.”
The accountable care organization (ACO) is essentially a shared savings program from CMS that focuses on managing a population of patients, such as those having total joint surgery.
“The perioperative surgical home fits nicely under the ACO,” Dr Schweitzer says. “It’s managing a defined population of patients over a period of time.”
A hospital’s comanagement payment arrangement can be with a commercial payer or as part of the CCJR or the BPCI. The comanagement arrangement includes physicians involved in a patient’s care.
“In the comanagement agreement, you’re sharing savings through a healthcare system, or a hospital in preparation for either bundled payment or an accountable care organization,” says Dr Schweitzer.
Each option has a shared savings component. In some cases, as with comanagement, those savings are shared with physicians. When it comes to gain sharing, however, Peters says, “A lot of hospitals by their nature are uncomfortable with that. Some feel it’s important, but others are philosophically uncomfortable with it, and they are just as successful [with PSH.]” He adds, “Believe it or not, people are still motivated by doing what’s best for their patients.
OR leaders are seeing their role expand yet again with the advent of PSHs. “With a surgical home, the [perioperative] director needs to have responsibility for the entire perioperative process,” Peters says. “You can’t deliver a surgical home if the OR director’s responsibility stops at the PACU [postanesthesia care unit].”
Cindy Mahal-van Brenk, MS, BSN, RN, CNOR, is an example of an OR leader with broad responsibilities for a PSH. Mahal-van Brenk is vice president of surgical services for Lutheran General and Christ Medical Center, the flagship hospital for the Advocate health system in Park Ridge, Illinois, and the executive sponsor for the PSH.
“I’m the one who supports the ideas and creates momentum to keep things moving,” Mahal-van Brenk says. Her responsibilities at Lutheran General include three inpatient units, GI lab, bariatric program, institutes of digestive health and orthopedics, main OR, ambulatory surgery center, perianesthesia area, central processing, business management, and materials management.
At Christ Medical Center, the main OR, perianesthesia area, the outpatient pavilion with 14 ORs, and the GI lab fall under her purview. The PSH at Lutheran General includes colorectal, total joint, and spine patients, and Mahal-van Brenk says the plan is to go systemwide with the initiative.
Mahal-van Brenk is honest about her initial reaction to adding inpatient units to her list of responsibilities. “I wasn’t thrilled,” she says. “I’ve never had a great passion for inpatient nursing.”
Ultimately, however, she saw the benefits. “If we want to reduce length of stay, improve our outcomes, reduce our readmissions, and reduce our complications, we all have to be rowing in the same direction.”
One example of collaboration is daily huddles to discuss patient safety and bed status. “We look proactively to be sure beds are in order for postoperative patients and make a plan in case there’s a backup in the ED,” Mahal-van Brenk says. Collaboration also fosters sharing resources. “If inpatient units have extra staff, we have them come down to the preoperative area and admit patients,” she notes.
Inpatient nurses and nurse leaders were excited to become part of the surgical team. “It has been a nice collaborative effort,” Mahal-van Brenk says. “The nurses have built relationships they’ve never had before; they share goals because we’re all under the same umbrella.”
Her advice to other OR leaders assuming responsibility for inpatient units? “In the beginning it will be a struggle, but they will see the benefits in the end. It takes time.”
The structure at Advocate has paid off. Mahal-van Brenk says that Lutheran General has seen significant reductions in length of stay with the PSH—from 6 days to 2 to 3 days for colorectal patients. Elements that contribute to the success include:
• Having a physician champion for each service line.
• Establishing an oversight committee that meets about once every 6 months.
• Supplementing the oversight committee with ongoing work groups such as one for pain management and one for patient education. The same work groups work on each service line and report to Mahal-van Brenk.
• Preparing patients for postoperative needs before the day of surgery. For instance, patients can use online communication tools to review information they have received in person.
• Creating clinical pathways and standardized order sets.
• Partnering with home health agencies and skilled nursing facilities (the patient’s discharge location is established before surgery).
• Communicating with the C-suite about PSH efforts.
“I report to the COO and CMO every month as part of our strategic growth,” Mahal-van Brenk says. “I keep them very much in the loop.” She is well positioned to let senior leadership know how they can help if obstacles arise.
Currently Advocate has two part-time nurses for the PSH program. “One manages the surgical optimization clinic, and the other manages our metrics as well as external customers,” Mahal-van Brenk says. External customers include home health staff, physical therapists, ostomy nurses, hospitalists, and primary care physicians.
For more examples of successful PSH experiences, see the related article on page 14.
The American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) Perioperative Surgical Home (PHS) Learning Collaborative 1.0 included 44 healthcare organizations that piloted and evaluated the PSH model from July 2014 through November 2015.
Many members selected pilots that focused on total hip and knee replacements to help prepare for voluntary and mandatory bundled payment programs. Other commonly selected service lines were colorectal, general surgery, and urology.
PSH Learning Collaborative 2.0, which includes nearly 60 healthcare organizations, started April 1 and runs until March 31, 2018. It is focusing on PSH strategies that are compatible with alternative payment models such as the Bundled Payments for Care Improvement, Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement, the Medicare Shared Savings Program, and accountable care organizations.
Phase 2.0 includes two cohorts, each with a 2-year commitment. The Care Collaborative, which cost $47,500 to join, consists of hospitals that are starting on the journey of creating a PSH.
The Advanced Collaborative, which costs $76,000 to join, includes hospitals that have a PSH or similar model up and running in their organization, and want guidance and resources to optimize the existing model or launch a PSH model in a different service line.
The American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) Perioperative Surgical Home (PHS) Learning Collaborative 1.0 included 44 healthcare organizations that piloted and evaluated the PSH model from July 2014 through November 2015.
Many members selected pilots that focused on total hip and knee replacements to help prepare for voluntary and mandatory bundled payment programs. Other commonly selected service lines were colorectal, general surgery, and urology.
PSH Learning Collaborative 2.0, which includes 77 healthcare organizations, started April 1 and runs until March 31, 2018. It is focusing on PSH strategies that are compatible with alternative payment models such as the Bundled Payments for Care Improvement, Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement, the Medicare Shared Savings Program, and accountable care organizations.
Phase 2.0 includes two cohorts, each with a 2-year commitment. The Care Collaborative, which cost $47,500 to join, consists of hospitals that are starting on the journey of creating a PSH.
The Advanced Collaborative, which costs $76,000 to join, includes hospitals that have a PSH or similar model up and running in their organization, and want guidance and resources to optimize the existing model or launch a PSH model in a different service line.
Dr Schweitzer says that when it comes to a PSH, “this is really a team sport, a team-based effort. Everybody has to be sitting around the table at the same time.”
An interdisciplinary team is a must. “If you try to do this with a couple of surgeons, a couple of anesthesiologists, and a hospitalist or two, it’s going to fail,” Dr Schweitzer adds.
“You need to have the hospital and healthcare system engaged and involved with all of their resources to support redesign of delivery of care.” Those resources include staff such as nurses, physical therapists, and social workers, and the ability to provide technology for collecting and reporting data to monitor progress. Data are used to guide needed changes and reinforce desired behavior.
Based on his experience with the Learning Collaborative, Dr Schweitzer sees a trend toward dyad or triad leadership of the PSH team.
“The triad model of a physician champion, a C-suite champion, and a performance improvement or project manager has been shown to be the most effective model for leadership,” he says.
The performance improvement or project manager can “rally the resources needed, keep everybody on track, and create communication processes so everybody is on the same page,” he adds.
A concentric circle around this core leadership group includes stakeholders who are involved in various aspects of the PSH but don’t need to attend every meeting.
Although everyone is expected to participate on the team, Dr Schweitzer says that there will be “situational leaders.”
For example, if a surgical patient is found to be at high risk for discharge to a skilled nursing facility, a social worker or care manager will work with the patient and the patient’s family to identify community resources and plan for the patient to be discharged to home instead, he explains.
“Perioperative surgical homes are not just at academic centers,” Peters says. “Forward-thinking community hospitals have figured out that’s the way to success.”
Dr Schweitzer says many community hospitals are farther ahead in the PSH process than their academic counterparts.
“It’s like a speedboat and a cruise ship,” he says. “The community hospital is the speedboat. They can turn on a dime and make change quickly.” They might not be publishing results, but they are seeing good outcomes. On the other hand, he says, “An academic center is like a cruise ship, which takes a long time to turn.” However, when academic centers make that turn, they often publish large studies that demonstrate the effectiveness of the PSH.
In 3 to 5 years, Peters says, most better-performing hospitals will have surgical homes with clinical pathways for their top surgical procedures.
“If you measure the goal as value, the surgical home is the pathway to provide better value to your patient, your payers, and your surgeons,” he says. ✥
American Society of Anesthesiologists. First-of-its-kind perioperative surgical home initiative demonstrates measurable impact on quality and costs. February 9, 2016. http://www.asahq.org/about-asa/newsroom/news-releases/2016/02/first-of-its-kind-perioperative-surgical-home-initiative.
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement Model. March 11, 2016. https://innovation.cms.gov/initiatives/cjr.