AORN’s updated Guideline for Sterilization is based on a recent review of evidence in peer-reviewed journals and regulations from 2012 to 2017. In addition to guidance for sterilizing reusable medical devices to be used in perioperative and procedural settings, the updated guideline points to findings that substantiate current practices, and it introduces some pioneering research. This article will explore some of the most notable changes to this guideline.
The importance of leadership skills is recognized as a key contributor to an effective perioperative services department. As such, AORN has added a new recommendation on leadership: Recommendation XII. The healthcare organization should assign responsibility and authority for leadership of the sterile processing team to qualified personnel.
The previous Sterilization Guideline had recommendations on leadership throughout the document, whereas Recommendation XII details all aspects of leadership pertaining to healthcare sterilization.
Over the years, sterilization tasks have become more complex, and technology continues to evolve; therefore, leaders of sterile processing activities should have a high level of expertise in the sciences of sterilization and disinfection. Technical knowledge is essential to plan and organize work operations because leaders need to direct and train subordinates with these specialized activities.
The quality of work needs to be monitored, and performance needs to be evaluated. If the activities are not monitored, they cannot be improved. The leader is responsible for coordinating improvement efforts. Having technical expertise prepares leaders for managing disruptions caused by equipment failures, quality defects, accidents, insufficient materials, and coordination problems. This recommendation defines specific tasks leaders perform. Providing a high level of sterilization quality assurance is of utmost importance. A quality management program is needed to evaluate effectiveness of processes, compliance with instructions for use (IFU), sterilization policies and procedures, steam and water quality supplied to steam sterilizers, and routine maintenance and function of equipment.
These programs provide data that may be used to determine whether the healthcare organization is within benchmark goals, and, if not, to identify areas that may require corrective action. Implementation of Recommendation X, The healthcare organization should establish a quality assurance and performance improvement program to evaluate and monitor sterilization processes in all areas of the facility where sterilization processes are performed, begins with an interdisciplinary team that has the authority to establish and implement a quality assurance and performance improvement program for sterilization processes.
Recommendations for monitoring quality and ensuring that quality indicators are met have previously been included in the sterilization guideline. This new guideline also recommends centralization of sterilization to one area.
There has been a significant amount of research and debate over the issue of sterilizing endoscopes used in semi-critical procedures. Selection of the type of disinfectant to use on a medical device has been based on the Spaulding classification, which has been in use since the 1950s. Research has shown an association between outbreaks and a lack of compliance with sterilization and disinfection guidelines. Most are related to medical devices categorized as semi-critical items that were processed using a high-level disinfectant. The evidence presented has also shown some pathogens are resistant to high-level disinfection.
According to these evidence-based findings, semi-critical items that undergo high-level disinfection have a greater risk of disease transmission compared with those that undergo sterilization. Based on this information, a new recommendation was added to sterilize reusable semi-critical items that are manufacturer-validated for sterilization, whenever possible.
In 2017, the Association for the Advancement of Medical Instrumentation (AAMI) held an endoscope stakeholders meeting, with representation from healthcare professional organizations, manufacturers, testing laboratories, independent research groups, academia, patient and clinical end-user interests, the US Food and Drug Administration’s Center for Devices and Radiological Health, and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, among others. The discussion presented many concerns regarding flexible endoscope processing. The findings from this meeting are consistent with this recommendation: If endoscopes can undergo sterilization according to their IFU, it is recommended to provide a sterilized endoscope instead of a high-level disinfected endoscope.
The guideline also introduced a new concept on specific positioning of medical devices in a sterilizer. Current standards have included basic sterilizer loading guidance. Manufacturers’ IFU specify a certain type of sterilization modality and cycle.
What is new is that some manufacturers are requiring a specific position in a sterilizer, based on their validation testing. For example: “Packages containing phacoemulsification hand pieces may be sterilized in an upright (ie, vertical) position and held in a manner that allows for free drainage of the channel during steam sterilization.”
Two laboratory studies cited in the guideline demonstrate that sterilizing this device in an upright (vertical) position allows free drainage of the channel during steam sterilization. Although these studies looked specifically at phacoemulsification hand pieces, other similarly configured devices also may have the same channel drainage issues and could need similar vertical orientation. Because this is such a new practice, additional research is needed.
Immediately after sterilization, a package may contain moisture that comes out of the package as a gas (ie, water vapor) during the drying and cooling period. If certain types of packaging are touched, a moist area may be created that can act as a wick and draw bacteria from hands before the package is cooled and dry. Putting hot packages onto a cool surface can also result in a wet pack.
A new recommendation is to use a calibrated infrared thermometer or similar device before handling packages after sterilization.
The immediate use steam sterilization (IUSS) process has been updated, and recommendations pertaining to this process are in the section on steam sterilization, rather than as a stand-alone recommendation. IUSS can be an effective sterilization method, provided all the required cleaning and inspection steps are strictly followed before placing the item in the sterilizer.
Quality improvement efforts should focus on monitoring the quality of every process step instead of only tracking IUSS rates. According to Erin Kyle, co-author of this guideline, “Immediate use steam sterilization should be done by competent personnel using the right equipment in the right setting. It should not be done by personnel whose expertise is in a different area and who do not have the appropriate training and resources.” The method of performing biological monitoring for the dynamic air-removal cycles for sterilizers used for IUSS now permits the use of a preassembled process challenge device.
Specific guidance for environmental conditions is found in the AORN Guideline for Design and Maintenance of the Surgical Suite. The recommendations are to limit exposure to moisture, dust, direct sunlight, handling, and temperature and humidity extremes.
If there is a variance in the parameters of the heating, ventilation, and air conditioning system, designated perioperative team members, along with an interdisciplinary team, should perform a risk assessment of the sterile storage areas.
Low-temperature sterilization is accomplished using chemicals. A variety of low-temperature systems are used in many healthcare facilities. The safety of ethylene oxide sterilization (EtO) has been included in the previous edition of the Sterilization Guideline.
This updated guideline adds discussion of environmental toxicity and potential acute and chronic health effects of exposure to hydrogen peroxide, ozone, and peracetic acid.
Research from the International Agency for Research on Cancer has determined that hydrogen peroxide is classified as carcinogenic to animals by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH). No reports were located on the developmental or reproductive effects of hydrogen peroxide in humans.
Additionally, exposure limits from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) are 0.1 parts of ozone in a million parts of air (0.1 ppm) in the workplace for an 8-hour work shift, 40-hour work week. Although ozone is not classified as a carcinogenic, there can be acute injury after exposure to ozone.
Peracetic acid, another sterilization chemical system, has not been shown to be carcinogenic to humans; however, at high levels of concentration, it has been found to be carcinogenic to animals.
This guideline discusses the potential acute and chronic health effects of peracetic acid exposure to humans. The ACGIH recommends a limit of 0.4 parts of peracetic acid in a million parts of air (0.4 ppm) in the workplace for an 8-hour work shift, 40-hour work week.
The AORN guidelines have long included safe handling practices for EtO, including the OSHA exposure limits. What is new is that mixtures of EtO consisting of 10% EtO and 90% hydrochlorofluorocarbon are no longer available in the US, per US Environmental Protection Agency regulations. Only 100% EtO is being used in the US.
The use of instrument tracking systems is also addressed in the guideline. Many instrument tracking systems provide the sterilization lot control information on the label. However, even if an instrument tracking system does not include the lot control tracking information, the addition of the lot control information in the form of a handwritten identifier or load control sticker is no longer required.
If a sterilization failure occurs, additional guidance is provided on how to investigate, document, and report on the failure. The investigation should be conducted with an interdisciplinary team in a standardized, systematic manner.
Water quality for steam supply is an important factor for the quality of steam, and the guideline recommends monitoring and controlling the water supply used for steam production.
A new recommendation that provides guidance on being stewards of our environment was also added because human health is dependent upon the environment, and we all have an ethical and professional responsibility to protect the environment.
Recommendation XI, The healthcare organization should assess the environmental impact of sterilization processes and equipment, provides strategies for reducing the impact of sterilization on the environment.
To provide the best care for our patients, we must stay abreast of best practices. The new AORN Guideline for Sterilization provides current evidence-based best practices. This article outlines some of the changes from the previous edition.
For a complete updated guideline, visit www.aorn.org. ✥
Susan Klacik, BS, CRCST, CHL, CIS, ACE, FCS, is a clinical educator for IAHCSMM (International Association of Healthcare Central Service Materiel Management) and a representative to AAMI. She also serves on AORN’s Guidelines Advisory Board.