Inefficiencies in surgical case scheduling can lead to large revenue losses. When leaders at Providence Sacred Heart Medical Center (SHMC) in Spokane, Washington, realized poor room utilization was the cause of more than $1 million in annual overtime costs, they knew that better planning was needed.
“For every 60 minutes of procedure time, we were accruing 45 minutes of caregiver overtime,” says Glenn Doherty, MPH, LSSBB, director of perioperative and procedural business operations for Providence Health Care—Eastern Washington Region. “Our block system was managing us; we weren’t managing it.”
SHMC, which has 28 ORs, increased utilization from 65% (far below the benchmark of 80%) to 73% and reduced overtime by 33% over a 12-month timeframe.
Doherty says the sweet spot seems to be 80% block time and 20% unblocked (first come, first served), and that creating a dynamic scheduling system helped the organization meet its goals. “Surgeons require more space than they use because at their level cases are unpredictable,” he says. “In today’s financial climate, administration can’t afford any extra padding, which creates inherent conflict between the surgeon and administration.”
According to Doherty, a vital insight into making improvements was that physicians and administration had to have a common goal.
He adds that research by Franklin Dexter, MD, PhD, FASA, suggests efficiencies can’t be gained (or sustained) until ORs are filled consistently with predictable case types. “The majority of OR waste stems from a fully staffed but partially used OR,” Doherty says. “So, we granted blocks to physicians who could bring in a minimum of 8 hours of procedure and turnover time in a day.” Those who did not meet the criteria were given the option to reallocate their caseload to fill ORs, or access to the first-come, first-served room that opened up because of the adjustments. “We knew that we had more space than community demand, but we had to unclog the OR for our community to realize it,” Doherty says.
Members of the team realized they had to attack utilization on three management levels: strategic, tactical, and operations. Each level now uses specific data to make decisions.
• Strategic management. This is done at the top level, and it refers to the work of the resource allocation committee, which meets quarterly to adjust blocks and support appropriate service line access to OR time. Members of the team are the chief medical officer, OR business director, OR nursing director, surgeon from each service line, anesthesia provider, and a business analyst.
“We had to change the way we thought about OR space,” Doherty says. “A change in OR allocation is never permanent.” For example, as seasonal factors and everyday life impact a surgeon’s volume, the needed OR space changes, too.
The committee uses a simplified, action-oriented report to determine when and how to adjust a surgeon’s OR time to eliminate waste (sidebar below). The report indicates over- and underutilization of a room, and makes clear what adjustments need to be made. Every minute of OR time is accounted for—physicians aren’t penalized for working outside their block, and they get credit for the room’s turnover time.
“The committee empowers surgeons to be in control of those adjustments, ensuring physicians are the agents of change, not victims of it,” Doherty says.
• Tactical management. This refers to the scheduling and resources planning performed by the perioperative committee and in town hall meetings held on a biweekly to monthly basis. Participants include clinic schedulers, anesthesia providers, the OR nurse director, and perioperative nurse managers. The group focuses on bridging the gap between clinics and OR scheduling and enables the hospital to communicate important policy and procedure changes. It also allows participants to communicate opportunities for improvement in scheduling and to partner in optimizing OR space for their physicians.
• Operations management. This level connects the details of tactical with the goals of strategy, and occurs in daily huddles. Representatives from anesthesia, perioperative nursing, and radiology are able to quickly analyze daily utilization and schedules to make rapid adjustments, including room closures and changes. OR managers and schedulers collaborate in filling unblocked time. “Any case is better than no case, and some cases are better than others,” Doherty says. “If we have resources to be able to meet the case, we’ll put it into a first-come, first-served room.”
The organization’s data showed that even the unexpected can be expected, Doherty says. “We generally don’t know when a trauma will happen, or what type of trauma will present, but we do know that we can expect anywhere between four and seven orthopedic trauma cases on a Tuesday, so we plan for it,” he explains. “Doing this for every surgeon, every group, and every service line gives us a level of predictability that is dependable. We stopped trying to control the variation, and started managing to the variation.”
The levels of management work in a feedback loop. For example, the strategic level of management supplies the tactical level with blocks and grids that indicate how to organize the anticipated volume. The tactical level manages the content of the blocks and the schedule, and facilitates planning between the community and OR operations. Operations reviews upcoming schedules daily and closes rooms that will not be used, or adjusts nurse staffing to meet demand.
At the daily huddle, operations provides feedback to the tactical level of management regarding upstream inefficiencies (gaps in schedule). The tactical level of management works with the team to avoid these scheduling issues, and the block is adjusted quarterly using the Plus/Delta Report.
“Iterations of this cycle over time will balance out the OR volume because we are addressing both the systemic and the symptomatic breakdowns in capacity management simultaneously,” Doherty says. He emphasizes that block scheduling is an ongoing process that requires involvement of service line physicians. “There is no finish line,” he says. “Once you start, you have to keep going.” ✥
Cynthia Saver, MS, RN, is president of CLS Development, Inc, Columbia, Maryland, which provides editorial services to healthcare publications.