Stiff economic headwinds are challenging ambulatory surgery centers (ASC). Among them are stubbornly high unemployment, higher copays and deductibles, and fewer independent physicians. After strong growth, the number of new ASCs opening is nearly zero for 2011.
Brian Mathis, vice president of strategy for Surgical Care Affiliates, surveyed the economic climate in an August 2011 webinar presented by Becker’s ASC Review.
With unemployment at 9.2%, fewer people have health insurance, higher than anticipated a year ago. More than 1 in 5 adults under 65 (22%) was uninsured in 2009, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.
About 60% of the ASC payer mix is commercial insurance, and most is from employer-sponsored plans, Mathis said.
“Every percent increase in unemployment has a huge impact on patients who are able to get care in our surgery centers.”
Of the unemployed, 30% have been out of work for more than 1 year, making it even less likely that they have the discretionary income to be able to get care, he noted.
More insured people are expected to contribute to their health costs. A total of 27% of covered workers have annual deductibles of $1,000 or more, the Kaiser Family Foundation reports.
That has an impact on ASCs because much of the care they provide is discretionary. A patient who has to pay a bigger part of the bill for a colonoscopy, is likely to think twice about it, for example.
“When you start to shift the burden of cost to the consumer, you are going to see more deferring care,” Mathis said.
The trend for physicians to be employed is accelerating.
By 2013, fewer than one-third of physicians will be in private practice, opting to be employed by larger health systems, according to consultants Accenture Health.
Physicians are attracted to the resources health systems offer as well as more manageable work weeks and job stability.
For independent ASCs, that means fewer independent physicians to recruit.
These are some ways ASCs can respond to the changing conditions.
Though ASCs are confident of their high quality and safety, they’ll need to prove it to payers and the public. An example is Medicare’s proposed plan for ASC quality reporting outlined in the August 1, 2011, outpatient prospective payment proposed rule (September OR Manager.)
“We’re doing a lot of the right things, Mathis said. “It’s going to take more work and commitment across the industry to collect data, report on outcomes, and convince legislators we want comparable metrics for ASCs and hospitals.”
With a saturated market, each ASC will struggle for volume. There are no longer many unaffiliated physicians.
“You have to understand every doctor in your market and the capability to recruit those doctors,” Mathis said. That means having the right person on board who can analyze the physician market, decide what cases to recruit, and build relationships with those surgeons.
The 6 best specialties for ASCs, outlined in the webinar by Scott Becker, continue to be:
ASCs, like many, are in a revenue and cost squeeze. Commercial and Medicare reimbursement rates are flat to declining. And labor and supply costs are not coming down.
“We probably are not going to see any big increases from Medicare, given the federal debt picture,” said Mathis.
“When you have the kind of margin pressure we have, you need systems to be able to understand the profitability of every single case and be able to work with your physicians to increase the margin on those cases.”
A key response to all these forces—good systems. That includes good systems to understand the ASC’s clinical outcomes, revenues, and costs, Mathis advised.
By participating in quality reporting, ASCs have an opportunity to demonstrate the caliber of care they provide.
“We think we play a pivotal role in improving care by providing high quality at a low cost—it is a winning solution in our minds, and we need to position it that way more broadly,” he said.