September 1, 2011

Two-thirds of managers report economy has affected staffing

By: OR Manager
Share



OR Manager; Vol. 27 No. 9; September 2011



Economic conditions continue to challenge OR staffing. Though fewer OR directors and managers than in 2009 say they are reducing use of overtime and eliminating open positions, more than two-thirds (69%) say the economy did affect their staffing in the past 6 months, according to the 21st annual OR Manager Salary/Career Survey. That is some improvement over the 79% who had adjusted staffing for economic reasons in 2010.

The majority—60% or more—say their staff turnover and vacancy rates were unchanged from last year. More ORs are using temporary staff than in 2010, but not as many as a few years ago. Only a few (5%) had laid off direct-care staff.

Reflecting a long-term challenge, more respondents this year say recruiting of experienced perioperative RNs became more difficult in the past year.

Key findings include:

  • Respondents still list reducing overtime (45%), eliminating open positions (35%), and requiring staff to take time off with pay (35%) as their top staffing responses to the economy.
  • The 64% who said RN turnover has stayed about the same is nearly the same as last year.
  • The number of OR directors who report more difficulty in recruiting RNs is up to 40%, compared to only 26% in 2010.
  • Nearly three-fourths (74%) of directors now hire new graduate nurses and RNs without OR experience.

Overall trends show that both the RN and ST (surgical technologists) turnover rates are now on a par with 2007 prerecession levels.

About the survey

The OR Manager Salary/Career Survey was mailed in two waves from April to July 2011 to 800 OR Manager subscribers classified as directors of hospital ORs. There were 247 usable responses for a 31% response rate. To ensure representation of the target audience, results were filtered to include only the 230 respondents who work full time in an OR. The margin of error is ±5.4 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. This article features the staffing findings from the survey. The rest of the findings will be reported in the October 2011 issue.

Most respondents work in a community hospital (74%) rather than a teaching hospital (21%), with locations split between suburban (39%), rural (35%), and urban (26%). Nearly all (89%) are not-for-profit facilities.

Staffing profile

The average number of open positions remained relatively unchanged from 2010, with 2.4 open RN positions and 1.1 ST positions. Nearly half (46%) have no openings for RNs, and more than half (59%) have no openings for STs. Most respondents say those numbers are about the same (60% for RNs, 72% for STs) as last year. Positions stayed open an average of 13.1 weeks for RNs and 9.3 weeks for STs. The longest average time RN positions were open was in the Northeast at 22 weeks.

The percentage of budgeted FTE positions for RNs that were open was 7%, comparable to last year’s 6%, but the percentage for STs was 13%, much higher than 2010’s 8%. The average percentage of open RN positions is highest in the Midwest (9%) and in teaching hospitals (8%). For STs, the West has the highest percentage of openings (17%), and the South the lowest (8%).

Nearly a quarter of directors (23%) report using overtime always or almost always, compared to 52% for occasionally, 21% for rarely, and 4% for never. As is usually the case, overtime use is significantly higher in teaching hospitals compared to community hospitals (35% for always/almost always vs 21%).

Average number of open FTE positions in ORs
Type of facility Region
Overall Community Teaching Northeast Midwest South West
RNs 2.4 1.8 3.7 3.2 1.6 2.6 3.2
STs 1.1 1.0 1.8 0.8 1.2 1.5 0.9
What percentage of budgeted FTE positions are open?
Type of facility Region
Overall Community Teaching Northeast Midwest South West
RNs 7% 7% 8% 6% 9% 7% 5%
STs 13% 14% 11% 11% 15% 8% 17%
Average number of weeks positions have been open
Type of facility Region
Overall Community Teaching Northeast Midwest South West
RNs 13 14 11 22 10 9 15
STs 9 10 10 14 6 10 12
Average staff turnover rate
Type of facility Region
Overall Community Teaching Northeast Midwest South West
RNs 8% 8% 8% 7% 6% 9% 11%
STs 7% 8% 7% 8% 6% 8% 8%
ORs that use agency or travel nurses to fill budgeted positions
Type of facility Region
Overall Community Teaching Northeast Midwest South West
14% 11% 19% 13% 4% 7% 42%

Recruitment is tougher

More directors are facing recruitment challenges, with somewhat higher average turnover rates for both RNs (8% vs 5% in 2010) and STs (7% vs 6% in 2010), and fewer respondents say ST turnover had decreased in the past year (16% vs 23%). Respondents from the South are most likely (20%) to say RN turnover had increased. Turnover is defined as the percent of staff who have left and been replaced in the past 12 months.

The number of respondents who say it’s harder to recruit experienced OR nurses soared from 26% in 2010 to 40% this year. More respondents in the Northeast (61%) say recruiting has become more difficult in the past year.

Perhaps because of these challenges, 14% of directors are using agency or travel nurses to fill budgeted positions, compared to only 8% last year. Still, the overwhelming majority (86%) do not use temporary staff, and their use is much lower than the 32% reported in 2007 and 23% in 2005. As in previous years, the use of agency or travel nurses is significantly higher in the West, where 42% of directors employ them, compared to only 4% in the Midwest. When used, travelers make up on average 5% of the nursing staff.

In addition, 74% of directors hire new graduate nurses and RNs with no OR experience. More than two-thirds (67%) hire RNs without OR experience, compared to only 41% in 1991 and 69% in 1997. Nearly half (47%) hire new grads, but that still falls far short of prerecession 2006’s 67%. ORs in the Midwest (76%) are significantly more likely to hire RNs without experience in the OR.

Respondents continue their staff development endeavors. Two respondents say their greatest achievement was increasing the number of certified perioperative nurses. Another said, “retained excellent quality staff.”

OR skill mix little changed

The ratio of RNs to surgical technologists (STs) in the operating room has changed little since OR Manager began collecting this data in 1995. This year, the average ratio, at 62:38, is nearly the same as the 62:36 reported 10 years ago. The ratio in 1995 was 70:30.

Federal Medicare regulations say STs and licensed practical/vocational nurses may assist in circulating duties with an RN immediately available.

When OR Manager started collecting this data, there was concern that with economic pressures, managers would be expected to increase the proportion of technical and unlicensed personnel. To date, the shift has been minor.

AORN reports that 23 states have a strong law or regulation regarding the RN circulator.

Circulating duties

In all, 4% of this year’s hospital OR respondents said STs were circulating with a supervising RN in the room. One, a small OR in a community hospital in the West, allows STs to circulate with a supervising RN immediately available. No hospital ORs reported that STs are circulating on their own.

Ambulatory surgery centers

The average skill mix for ASCs is 66:34 RNs to STs. A small number—9%, or 15 of the 176 who responded to this question—allow STs to circulate. For 12 of these, an RN is in the room or immediately available. In 3 of these ASCs, STs circulate on their own; 2 of these are physician owned.

Retention of nurses over 50

This year’s survey asked respondents to submit their most successful strategy for retaining nurses over 50 years of age.

The most common answers related to scheduling, including “flexible schedules” and “consistent work hours.” Some say nurses over 50 do not have to work shifts, and others say they receive additional vacation time. Flexibility also includes the length of the shift, days worked, and working part time or flextime instead of full time.

Reducing call is the most popular scheduling strategy for retaining nurses over 50. One respondent noted that call was reduced to 1 to 2 days a month. Seniority plays a key role in call decisions. In some facilities, length of service (15 years, 20 years, 25 years) or age (older than 55, older than 60) determines when staff members are exempt from call. One respondent pays a salary to RNs and STs who take call, which reduces the amount of call for other workers; another has hired a weekend call team that provides in-house coverage; and a third respondent has full-time shift coverage that results in “very little call requirement.”

Retirement and pension benefits are also important retention strategies, with one hospital offering full-time benefits for a 32-hour work week.

In addition to scheduling and financial interventions, some hospitals allow staff with more seniority first choice in time off, holiday call requirements, and choice of specialty team.

Some respondents shift nurses over 50 to positions outside the OR, such as same-day surgery, preprocedure center, the lab, central reprocessing, and respiratory therapy. One respondent assigns staff to OR responsibilities that are “less physically demanding,” which some directors identified as being educators, mentors, or nurse advocates. Other ways to reduce physical demands include providing more lifting help, using “programs to make work less physical,” and “providing an ergonomically safe environment to practice.” One director assigns nurses over 50 to fewer cases and/or “turnover help.”

Basic management counts

Respondents say that basic management skills count. One director reports using good communication to retain nurses over 50, including monthly staff meetings and “daily postings on (the) bulletin board with any changes.” Others note the importance of good staff relations, with one writing, “presence with the staff, frequent rounding.”

Not all directors worry about retaining nurses over 50. Some respondents noted that current economic conditions have kept nurses in their jobs, and one respondent wrote that there was no other “competition” in the area.

Others see potential in this age cohort. One respondent reported using the AORN Periop 101 course to recruit nurses older than 50, and another’s strategy is “encouraging professional goals such as certification.”

One director provides “increased support for new technology.”

Good strategies for any age

Many listed management strategies applicable to retaining staff of any age. Examples include:

  • “a good work environment”
  • “making [staff] feel ‘important’”
  • “respect”
  • a “good orientation program”
  • “rewarding excellence” and “recognition”
  • “shared governance”
  • “collegiality”
  • “clinical ladder”
  • “professionalism”
  • “good leadership skills.”

One respondent wrote, “constant use of this staff to drive policy generation and unit improvement. They feel their opinions are HEARD!” Another director noted that it’s important to make changes slowly and to “involve them in getting their input.” Other strategies included “amazing support from senior leadership,” “appreciate their knowledge,” and “phased-in retirement.”

—Cynthia Saver, MS, RN

Cynthia Saver, president of CLS Development, Inc, is a freelance writer based in Columbia, Maryland.


Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat