Successful hiring for the OR depends on ensuring nurses have the right education and clinical skills as well as the right attitude: Are they are willing and able to be team players?
OR nurse leaders at Saint Luke’s Health System (SLHS), Kansas City, Missouri, have been revamping their intern and fellowship programs to speed orientation and boost retention. Thus far, they have whittled down orientation to 6 months.
SLHS includes 11 hospitals with 48 ORs. Previously, orientation at SLHS took 9 to 14 months to complete, according to Tandi Toone, BSN, RN, CNOR, clinical nurse manager of surgical services, at Saint Luke’s Hospital (main campus), the flagship hospital of SLHS. With upwards of 20 open positions, there was a need to hire and get OR nurses up to speed quickly.
Cheryl Fisher, BSN, RN, CNOR, joined SLHS in June 2013 as the system clinical education specialist for surgical services, and began building the intern and fellowship programs. By February 2014, when the fellowship program began, 18 OR nurses had been hired into the program: 10 new graduates and eight experienced nurses from other specialties. Of those, 12 completed the program with an average orientation length of 25 weeks, Fisher told OR Manager.
As part of the hiring process, Fisher recommends having candidates spend 1 or 2 days observing in the OR. That way, staff can gauge their level of interest and engagement, and candidates get a better idea of what the job entails.
“A lot of the bedside nurses and new graduates don’t have a true concept of what OR nursing involves,” Fisher says. “I didn’t want the managers to hire someone who might have a false idea of what the OR is and then lose them after orientation.”
Toone, who manages the ORs on the main campus, doesn’t require observation as part of her hiring process because many interns get that exposure in nursing school. However, she notes, “Sometimes, no matter what you do, you may hire someone who just isn’t the right fit.” For example, a floor nurse coming to work in the OR must be willing to give up autonomy and get used to working as part of a team.
The intern program was designed to enable SLHS to hire bachelor of science in nursing (BSN) students as scrub technologists and have them complete a 12-week orientation by working full time during the summer before their senior year.
After completing orientation, interns must work independently as a scrub technologist at least 8 hours per month PRN in their senior year, Fisher explains. To balance their case load with their school work, she says, they must work a minimum number of hours during the school year—about one shift per month—for a total of 72 hours (sidebar at right).
Interns are encouraged to work extra during school breaks and free time off to maintain their competency. The goal of this program is to decrease RN circulator orientation from 6 months to less than 4.
“We used two models: Benner’s model to help nurses gain the competency needed for the OR and Donna Wright’s model,” Fisher says (sidebar below). “Donna Wright very firmly believes that competency should be meaningful, and we should get away from skills fairs.”
Instead, Fisher designed competencies based on meaningful use. For example, for skin prepping, students must meet behavioral criteria (sidebar below). Out of a total of 37 competencies Fisher compiled for the OR, she says, 12 focus on teamwork based on Joint Commission criteria, and others are based on regulations.
As a stellar example of teamwork, Toone cites the partnership between an intern and an ear, nose, and throat (ENT) nurse who was an excellent scrub technologist. “I wanted to show Steven [the intern] that you really can do whatever comes through your door,” Toone says. “Even though Jess [the scrub technologist] is on the ENT team, she can do it all. Once you know your basics, you can start to grow. Our surgical technologists were very happy to have Steven because he helped reduce their call load.”
In addition, Toone explains, Saint Luke’s College of Health Sciences offers a 2-week perioperative elective in the summer. Her intern took that class, which gave him a good head start for coming into the OR.
A total of three interns went through the program in 2014. The fellowship program was underway when the intern program began, so fewer new candidates were needed.
All three interns were offered RN circulator positions. Of those, only one decided to stay in the OR, one moved to the neurosurgical ICU within SLHS, and the other went to a hospital outside of the system to work in labor & delivery.
“We’re currently in limbo in terms of how much we want to gear up the intern program,” Fisher says. One problem with hiring junior nursing students, she says, is that they haven’t yet completed their clinicals. They’re being asked to decide if they want to work in the OR before they’ve been exposed to other specialties.
To increase retention from interns, she is recommending posting the open RN circulator positions in January instead of April. “We decided we wouldn’t require the interns to accept a position after graduation because there was too high a risk that they would stay for the required 6 months and then leave. This summer, we hope to expand the intern program to include critical care, emergency room, labor & delivery, and neonatal ICU—specialty areas that have a more difficult time retaining new nurses—to see if we can decrease their orientation time as well,” Fisher says.
Although preceptor education is encouraged, it’s not required. “Saint Luke’s offers a preceptor boot camp, and the Missouri Hospital Association offers a preceptor academy,” Toone says. “We try to get people to attend some kind of workshop or class.”
Preceptor boot camp is a 5-hour class during which nurses work through topics of their choice. Examples include conflict resolution, accountability, and any issues that have arisen with the orientee they’re precepting. “They do a lot of role-playing and hands-on activities,” Fisher says.
The smaller hospitals within SLHS have two to six ORs, and students at those facilities are exposed to a wide mix of cases, Fisher says, whereas on the main campus, there are 16 specialty rooms in the main OR, four in the neuro tower, and five in the cardiovascular OR. “At the main campus, rooms are split up by teams. For example, a student may be working all day in orthopedics or gynecology, versus a mix of cases at one of the smaller hospitals,” she explains. Likewise, students tend to work with just one preceptor in the smaller hospitals, but students at the main campus have different preceptors for each of the specialty teams.
“Essentially we are a team-based model, and everyone is required to take call. Saint Luke’s Hospital is a Level 1 trauma center,” Toone explains. Once nurses have completed orientation and are placed on a specialty team, they are scheduled mostly for procedures in their specialty; however, they’re also expected to be able to flex to other specialties.
To provide adequate orientation, Toone says, she has a primary and a secondary preceptor for each specialty. That way, there’s coverage if the primary preceptor is unavailable on a given day.
“The preceptor boot camp is currently an elective class, but we’re considering whether to require formal training before nurses can precept new hires,” Fisher notes.
The fellowship begins when a nurse is hired and ends with completion of a 6-month orientation. The program includes classroom instruction and mentoring by a preceptor. Students receive human resources and patient care services orientation along with EPIC software training. The didactic component consists of 6 days focusing on specific skill sets (sidebar).
Fellowship programs take place in summer and winter, Toone says. During orientation, nurses first scrub for a couple of weeks, and then they circulate through all the different specialties before being placed into the specialty of their choice.
For the fellowship program that started in February 2014, 18 OR nurses were hired: 10 new graduates and eight experienced nurses from other specialties—five of whom had less than 2 years’ experience, while the other three had more than 5 years of experience.
A total of 12 nurses completed the fellowship program with an average orientation length of 25 weeks. New graduates completed the program slightly faster than the more experienced nurses: an average of 24.5 weeks vs 25.5 weeks, respectively.
The nurse residency program, which started in 2012, has six modules that all new nurse graduates must complete: teamwork and collaboration; legal, ethics, and informatics; care coordination and safety; evidence-based practice; quality; and professionalism.
“The whole cohort is together in one room for an hour-long lecture, and then we split up into specialties,” Fisher explains. “We talk about how the different modules affect their specific unit.” Some of the content in the modules isn’t OR-specific, so Fisher provides exercises that apply to those environments.
New nurse graduates often struggle with the transition from being a nursing student to being an RN, according to Fisher. She uses evidence-based practice projects to orient students to both teamwork and professionalism. For example, she says, young nurses need to learn how to collaborate with older team members or to help establish protocols.
For the 2015-2016 programs, Fisher says, most of the nurse managers who didn’t participate in hiring anyone in 2014 are interested in hiring this year. In addition, according to Toone, managers are more open to hiring interns than they used to be.
“For the 6-month orientation, the fellowship program costs about $22,000, compared with about $15,000 for the intern program,” Fisher notes. “One of our goals is to decrease the number of fellowship nurses and increase the number of interns. We also would like to increase the participation of our critical access hospitals, and we would like to expand our float pool.”
Careful selection of interns is one key to future success. “They have to be interested in the technical side of nursing, and they have to understand there isn’t the level of patient interaction you have on the floor,” Fisher says. ✥
Toone T, Fisher C. Optimize OR orientation with OR nursing intern and OR fellowship. OR Business Management Conference 2015.