Many perioperative services leaders still struggle to get meaningful data on what influences the success or failure of a surgical patient. One resource that’s readily available and has a proven track record is the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS NSQIP).
“NSQIP has shown that the use of accurate, rigorous, standardized data helps you evaluate how you’re doing and improve your care,” according to Clifford Ko, MD, MS, MSHS, FACS, director, division of research and optimal patient care, at the ACS in Chicago. “When we compared registry data to claims data, we found that claims data has an accuracy of about 25%. It’s not good enough to use claims data to measure how we’re doing in surgery.”
Dr Ko, director of ACS NSQIP and a colon/rectal surgeon and professor of surgery at the University of California Los Angeles School of Medicine, will be a keynote speaker at this year’s OR Manager Conference, October 7-9, at the Gaylord Opryland in Nashville. The 2015 Becker’s Hospital Review named Dr Ko as one of 50 experts leading the field of patient safety in the US.
ACS NSQIP was started about 10 years ago after studies of Veterans Administration hospitals found that more rigorous data collection correlated with actual outcomes. Previously, mortality rates at Veterans Health Administration (VA) hospitals had been seemingly higher than at non-VA hospitals, Dr Ko told OR Manager. However, after comorbidity data were collected in a more accurate, standardized manner and mortality rates were risk adjusted, it became clear that mortality rates weren’t any worse at VA hospitals.
Not only that, but providing ongoing feedback to VA hospitals led to lower mortality and complication rates, shorter length of stay, and higher patient satisfaction, according to Dr Ko. A grant from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) funded research to test whether the VA model of data analysis was transferrable to the private sector, and that was the beginning of ACS NSQIP. Today, more than 600 hospitals participate in the program.
As part of ACS NSQIP, hospitals have a designated surgical clinical reviewer who is trained by the ACS to collect data that is entered into the NSQIP database. Twice yearly, administrators and surgical services staff receive a comprehensive report so they can compare their risk-adjusted surgical outcomes to other participating sites.
Risk-adjusted 30-day morbidity and mortality outcomes are computed for each participating hospital. In addition, ACS NSQIP hospitals’ data are reported on the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ (CMS) Hospital Compare website.
A preoperative risk calculator tool compiles information to project the likelihood of various outcomes from procedures. “The risk calculator was developed using thousands of CPT codes,” Dr Ko says. “For the majority of inpatient CPT procedures, we can predict how patients will do based on the NSQIP data.”
To use the risk calculator, which is also open to non-NSQIP members, a user simply inputs the CPT code or procedure name as well as risk factors such as age, gender, and comorbidities. From that information, the risk calculator estimates the risk of mortality, infection, or other outcomes for that individual patient (http://riskcalculator.facs.org/).
The CMS has adopted use of the risk calculator as a performance measure for the Physician Quality Reporting System, Dr Ko notes. CMS also uses the NSQIP-developed elderly surgery measure, which looks at outcomes in those aged 65 and older. “It’s risk adjusted and procedure mix adjusted, so hospitals performing complex surgeries in the elderly aren’t penalized for doing difficult operations,” Dr Ko explains.
An Annals of Surgery study published online in February found that among hospitals currently participating in ACS NSQIP for at least 3 years, 69% reduced the rate of death; 79% reduced the rate of complications; and 71% reduced the rate of surgical site infections. Dr Ko was one of the study’s coauthors.
Some ACS NSQIP hospitals belong to collaboratives, or groups that share best practices, quality improvement initiatives, or compare surgical outcomes. “We have more than 30 collaboratives—regional, state, or topic-based, such as ERIN (enhanced recovery in NSQIP),” Dr Ko says. “They can learn from each other, network, and share data, successes, and failures—by and large, these hospitals tend to improve better than if they were working on their own.”
The next steps, he says, include figuring out how to employ technology and informatics to further gain efficiencies in obtaining accurate data for improving the delivery of high-quality, safe, and reliable surgical care.
In April, ACS NSQIP received one of the Joint Commission’s 2014 John M. Eisenberg Patient Safety and Quality Awards for its data collection achievements to help improve surgical patient care. ✥