Five years have passed since the Institute of Medicine recommended changes in nursing education and practice. Soon after the IOM issued its report, The Future of Nursing: Leading Change, Advancing Health, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation (RWJF) partnered with AARP to launch the Future of Nursing: Campaign for Action to help implement the IOM’s recommendations.
What progress has been made, and what remains to be done? The IOM is undertaking a new study to assess the impact of its report and the campaign.
The IOM’s key recommendations in 2010 were to:
• remove scope-of-practice barriers
• expand opportunities for nurses to lead and diffuse collaborative improvement efforts
• implement nurse residency programs
• increase the proportion of nurses with a baccalaureate degree to 80% by 2020
• double the number of nurses with a doctorate by 2020
• ensure that nurses engage in lifelong learning
• prepare and enable nurses to lead change to advance health
• build an infrastructure for the collection and analysis of interprofessional healthcare workforce data.
On May 28, the IOM’s Committee for the Evaluation of the Impact of the IOM Report heard from stakeholders who have analyzed data or supported programs to advance nurse education. Panelists represented research groups, academia, professional nursing and physician organizations, and healthcare agencies. Here are highlights from their sessions.
The first panel represented researchers who have been gathering and evaluating data on behalf of RWJF. Among these is the Interdisciplinary Nursing Quality Research Initiative (INQRI). Spokesperson Mary Naylor, PHD, RN, FAAN, of the University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing, Philadelphia, said INQRI has funded eight research teams that are investigating areas such as:
• the return on investment for increasing bachelor’s-prepared nurses
• how nurses can develop and use data to inform policy change
• the role of federal policy in the future scope of practice regulations for advanced practice nurses.
Thus far, Naylor said, multiple studies have linked nurses with a bachelor’s of science in nursing (BSN) to better patient outcomes and lower costs. INQRI plans to send its recommendations to the IOM by July 1. Findings of INQRI studies and how they relate to the IOM recommendations are available at www.inqri.org.
Another research firm, TCC Group, has been examining the work of state action coalitions. According to Kate Locke, MPH, associate director of evaluation, TCC Group has found the RWJF campaign has resulted in:
• a breakdown of barriers between associate’s degree and bachelor’s degree programs
• new leadership in some states and collaboration with non-nursing stakeholders such as the partnership between RWJF and AARP
• an easier pathway for new nurses to obtain their bachelor’s degrees.
Panelists representing education and training stakeholders generally agreed that much progress has been made, for example, an increasing number of nurses are pursuing bachelor’s and advanced degrees.
Since 2010, 38 new entry-level BSN programs have opened nationwide, and enrollment in these programs has increased 17%, from 161,540 to 189,729 students, said Eileen T. Breslin, PhD, RN, FAAN, president of the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN).
“In the past 5 years, the number of schools offering accelerated baccalaureate nursing programs has increased from 231 to 293, and enrollment has increased 24%, from 13,605 to 16,935 students,” she said. Even more remarkable, she noted, since fall 2010, enrollment in doctor of nursing practice (DNP) programs has increased 161%, from 7,037 to 18,352.
According to an employer survey conducted by AACN, the percentage of employers requiring new RNs to have a baccalaureate degree has risen from 30% to 45% since 2011, and the number of employers who prefer to hire RNs with BSNs also has increased. However, Breslin said, scope of practice barriers remain an issue.
“BSNs are often not fully utilized in all facilities,” she said. “We could consider new ways to credential and/or license BSN nurses, and we suggest the IOM convene stakeholders at the federal, state, and local levels to look at scope of practice concerns.”
Other panelists echoed concerns about scope of practice, advocating for both greater autonomy and better teamwork between nurses and other healthcare professionals. Concerns also were voiced about the cost of education, the lack of compensation for the time nurses take from work to complete their education, and the lack of access in remote areas to universities or even to online programs.
“The key is to build on the foundation community college programs and ensure the majority of our students progress directly to a BSN,” said Donna Meyer, MSN, RN, chief executive officer of the Organization for Associate Degree Nursing. Meyer said dual enrollment programs in Kansas and New Mexico allow students to attend both community college and university, earning about 90 credit hours from the community college and 30 credit hours from the university, as a way to increase the number of BSNs.
Mary Lou Rusin, EdD, RN, ANEF, chair, Accreditation Commission for Education in Nursing, said that in 2014, New York State graduated more nurses with bachelor’s degrees than with associate’s degrees—for the first time ever.
“From 1960 to 2000, only 20% of associate degree graduates continued on to a bachelor’s,” she noted. “In 2013, 36% of all BSN graduates were RNs. However, this won’t be high enough in New York State to meet the increased demand for bachelor’s-prepared nurses or to meet the IOM recommendation by 2020.”
At the end of the panel presentation, one committee member said the IOM report implies that the bachelor’s degree will become the standard for entry into practice for new nurses. For nurses pursuing BSNs later in life, it’s more economically challenging. “What expectations and what role do you see for entry at the associate degree level and continuation to the bachelor’s degree while in practice versus making the bachelor’s degree the entry credential to practice for people entering nursing education now?” he asked.
Rusin suggested mandating that a baccalaureate degree be obtained within a specified time period after graduating from an associate degree program. “I believe the community colleges provide the opportunity for students to attend a nursing school that’s more affordable. If we moved toward a baccalaureate level of entry, I’m fearful we wouldn’t have even the diversity that we have in the profession now,” she said.
“I think a lot of people cannot start at a university level, and find comfort in starting at a community college,” said Marsha Howell Adams, PhD, RN, CNE, FAAN, ANEF, president of the National League for Nursing. “We’ve got to facilitate academic progression, but keep the rigor,” she said. And, she added, a strong workforce depends on having strong nursing faculty with either research-based or clinical-based doctorates. “We can’t advance the health of the nation without nursing faculty.”
The committee meeting was intended as an information-gathering session; the IOM plans to issue another report in the future.
Stay tuned for more on nursing education. And to learn how one facility is tackling OR nurse education, see p 18 in this issue. ✥