July 22, 2015

Take time to make time: Involve your team in closing schedule gaps

By: OR Manager
Share

Turnover time and first case on-time starts are a common problem in most ORs, so leaders are always seeking ideas for improvement. OR Manager recently spoke with two leaders who have had remarkable success in each of these areas.

 

The Dartmouth-Hitchcock experience

Carol Majewski, MS, RN

Carol Majewski, MS, RN

When the average turnover time (TOT) at Dartmouth-Hitchcock in Lebanon, New Hampshire, reached a sobering 39 minutes (vs a desired benchmark of 26 minutes), Carol Majewski, MS, RN, director of patient experience and previously administrative director for perioperative services, knew it was time for an in-depth initiative. The long TOT was causing room delays, excess staff overtime, and limits on the number of add-on cases.

The initiative resulted in significant improvements. For example, over 3 months, TOT decreased by 30% for orthopedics, 21% for ear, nose, and throat (ENT) and plastic surgery, and 19% for vascular surgery. The hospital saved $430,000 in a year in staffing costs as a result of revamping the turnover process. Dartmouth-Hitchcock has 23 ORs and averages about 20,000 cases annually.

 

A diverse team

To achieve results, Majewski assembled a 13-member team that included representatives from ENT, ophthalmology, general surgery, gynecological surgery, OR nursing, patient support technicians (PSTs), housekeeping, the sterile processing department, and human resources. “We tried to be very inclusive,” she says.

Majewski credits the diversity of members with part of the team’s success. “Involving many stakeholders from different levels and different work areas is part of the richness of what we do,” she says. “The more stakeholders you have, the easier it is to create an environment where they can be heard.”

The absence of most managers on the team also encourages members to speak freely and feel more empowered. “Members not from the OR have a lens on what we do that we don’t have,” Majewski adds. For instance, the nurse from the preoperative holding area could speak about the frustration patients and families felt when long TOTs led to surgical delays.

The human resources representative served as an “inside outsider,” someone who can view processes with fresh eyes. “We knew we were going to be thinking about who did what work and why, and sometimes that can be uncomfortable,” Majewski explains. “We also wanted to think creatively about new roles.”

This kind of work requires managers to have an open mind and be flexible, Majewski says. The team of mostly staff members is the ultimate decision maker, so the solution might be one the manager did not expect. In this case, the manager asks the team how they anticipate managing certain challenges to continue the dialogue and find solutions.

 

Processing the process

The team attended a 5-day rapid process improvement workshop led by an in-house consultant who holds a black belt in Lean Six Sigma. Members first learned about process improvement methods, including value stream analysis and process mapping, as well as analytic tools such as root-cause analysis and fishbone diagrams. They were taught to ask, “Why?” five times to ensure the true source of the issue was identified.

Next, the team reviewed TOT data and customer comments, then took part in a Gemba walk so members could observe processes. Based on that experience, they created a process map for turnovers and established that step one would be when the patient left the OR and the last step would be when the next patient entered the OR.

The factors identified by the team as contributing to delays are familiar to many OR managers. “We had significant process variation in many elements of our work,” Majewski says, adding that other problems included a lack of clarity about who was responsible for each TOT task and who would assume responsibility should the primary person be unavailable.

 

Identifying solutions

The more challenging work of developing solutions started on day 2 of the workshop, when, as is typical in groups, conflicts arose. Having the right facilitator is crucial, according to Majewski. “You need to have someone who is skilled in facilitation, who allows conflict to arise, and then moves people toward a solution,” she says.

The TOT team brainstormed 31 opportunities for improvement and then narrowed down the possibilities. “They examined which opportunities were the ones that would give us the greatest return,” Majewski says. With this type of work, “You want to analyze what will have the biggest impact and then run with it,” she notes. The analysis included examining each of the roles in TOT and evaluating whether adding or modifying a role would help address the problem.

Once the team members identified possible solutions, they rounded out their 5-day workshop by planning pilots using the plan-do-study-act (PDSA) model and identifying next steps.

 

Putting solutions into practice

After analyzing the cost and level of staff acceptance for each solution, the team chose to add a turnover pit crew (sidebar). Options considered and discarded included adding an additional certified surgical technologist (CST) to each OR or having the CST/RN team partner with the pit crew to expedite turnovers and room setup.

Another strategy to reduce TOT was to have CSTs and RNs take their breaks during a turnover unless the case was longer than 3.5 hours. This significantly reduced the number of staff previously needed to provide breaks during cases. “We were bringing in a lot of resources [such as travel nurses] to cover breaks and lunches,” Majewski says.

Reducing these expenses offset the cost of hiring 13 additional staff (five PSTs and eight housekeepers) for the pit crews; the new hires also rotate to other work duties. “The solution chosen by the team turned out to be the most economical,” Majewski notes. In addition, staff now use incision closing time more effectively in terms of TOT by improving communication with support staff, the pit crew, and with each other.

“The more you can do during closing, the easier it is to set up the needed breaks and move the process along,” Majewski says. Simple changes, such as standardizing how “dirty” case carts are loaded, also shave time off TOT.

Majewski says that improving TOT is a work in progress. “When you do the workshop in a week, it’s energizing, but testing change and tweaking takes time,” she says. “It’s important to get people engaged and to have them think of it as an evolving process.”

 

The Mayo Clinic experience

Kimberly Valentine, BSN, RN, RNFA, CNOR, the OR manager at Mayo Clinic in Phoenix, found herself facing a steady decline in first case on-time starts (FCOTS) over 7 months, down to an average of 56% compared to a national benchmark of 76%.

The time lost at the start of the day was cascading through the entire day’s schedule, causing bottlenecks and additional delays in the OR, which has an average of approximately 12,800 cases a year.

 

Better communication

A team of OR managers, nurse administrators, and the chairs of anesthesia and surgery developed an integrated approach to the problem that boosted the percentage of FCOTS to 73%. “The key was getting all the parties involved and talking about the problem,” Valentine says.

Team members agreed to define delay as the patient entering the OR 1 minute after the scheduled start time.

Analysis revealed the most common reason for failing to start the first case on time was lack of timely coordination between the surgical team members. This discovery led to an innovative strategy—the 10-minute rule.

The surgeon, anesthesia provider, preoperative nurse, and the RN circulator are required to meet at the patient’s bedside in the preoperative holding area 10 minutes before the start time for surgery. “The main purpose is to get everyone together so they can huddle about the surgery and address any concerns,” Valentine says.

Team leaders, educators, supervisors, and a few staff members who were positive about the change monitored adherence to the rule. When there was a problem, a manager met with the person individually.

The team developed a communication tool to facilitate face-to-face handoff between the preoperative and OR staff. They also decided to stagger first cases, with four ORs starting at 7:15 am and 17 starting at 7:30 am.

“Creating an even split wasn’t practical given that many anesthesia providers and surgeons didn’t want the earlier start,” Valentine says. However, the slight change contributed to success.

All strategies were communicated to members of surgical services, including staff, surgeons, and anesthesia providers.

 

Sustaining change

FCOTS have averaged around 70% for the last several months. According to Valentine, sustainability has depended on reminding people about the 10-minute rule.

“We stress the importance of on-time starts for the patient and to help the rest of the day go well,” Valentine adds.

Future plans include periodically reeducating staff about the 10-minute rule, monitoring for compliance, and adjusting as needed. ✥

 

Turnover pit crew

The pit crew at Dartmouth-Hitchcock, Lebanon, New Hampshire, consists of two patient support technicians (PSTs) and two housekeepers. The four pit crews are assigned based on geographic sections of the OR. Responsibilities include:

  • The PST assumes full responsibility for the turnover.
  • The PST prechecks the case care and equipment for follow-on cases, helps with teardown of the case just ending, and helps set up the OR after it is cleaned.
  • The RN accompanies the patient to the postanesthesia care unit, and as scheduled, takes a break during the turnover.

Join our community

Learn More
Video Spotlight
Live chat by BoldChat